logo
   Web Issue 3323 December 5 2008   
spacer
How they rated: Celtic
GRAEME MACPHERSONApril 17 2008

  • Artur Boruc For once not at the centre of any controversy in another heated Old Firm encounter. Failed at the one serious question asked of him, namely to keep out Novo's angled drive, although it was virtually past him before he could move. Biggest danger in the first half came from Darcheville's flying boot rather than any Rangers shots 6

  • Andreas Hinkel Steady performance from the German who looks more and more like a shrewd signing with each passing game. Battled well with the more powerful McCulloch in the air and offered a threat moving forward too. Rarely tested defensively as Rangers failed to beat a regular path to the Celtic goal-line 7

  • Gary Caldwell Much-maligned defender can take credit for his role in the winning goal deep into stoppage time. Rangers' persistence with a 4-1-4-1 formation meant he and McManus could share the task of babysitting Darcheville although, in truth, there was little for either to do 6

  • Stephen McManus Coped well with the pace of Darcheville and the aerial threat of McCulloch.

    A regular presence in the opposition box for corners and free kicks but got little change from Cuellar and Weir in an attacking sense. His spat at full-time with his opposite number Ferguson demonstrated just what the victory meant for him 6

  • Lee Naylor Scarcely troubled defensively due to Whittaker's regular back-tracking, allowing him the space to amble occasionally forward to add his presence to the Celtic attack.

    A back injury, however, resulted in him being replaced by Wilson at half-time 6

  • Shunsuke Nakamura Outrageous banana shot deceived McGregor for the opening goal and it was his goalbound strike that prompted Cuellar to throw up a hand to concede Celtic's penalty. Aside from those two pivotal moments, though, it was hard to recall the Japanese creating anything else from open play 6

  • Barry Robson Elbow into Dailly in first minute signalled his heart for the battle and he put in a productive shift in central midfield in place of the suspended Scott Brown. In-swinging corners caused endless problems before he was sacrificed, to universal disapproval by the home hordes, to allow Samaras to add his not insubstantial weight to the Celtic attack 7

  • Paul Hartley Needed to be dominant in central midfield and came out on top in the heavyweight battle with Ferguson. Offered a protective shield to his defence that allowed Robson the freedom to motor forward. Early booking could have blunted his edge but he responded responsibly 7

  • Aiden McGeady Celtic's most creative outlet. Had to cope with the twin presence of Broadfoot and Whittaker in the first half but still managed to send in a number of tantalising crosses. Faded after the break when Whittaker dropped back to full-back but was still able to add a contribution whenever he received the ball 7

  • Jan Vennegoor of Hesselink Will steal the headlines and the glory after his late winner but in truth it was his first meaningful contribution to the match.

    A clumsy first touch denied him an early chance to test McGregor and it would prove symptomatic of his performance overall before his late, late intervention 6

  • Scott McDonald Penalty miss and first-half dive aside, the Australian put in a productive shift against Cuellar and Weir.

    His tenacity often carried Celtic forward into dangerous areas, one first half shot testing McGregor at his near post.

    His assist for Vennegoor of Hesselink's late winner made amends for spot kick blunder 7

    SUBSTITUTES

  • Mark Wilson Half-time replacement for Naylor was twice culpable at Novo's equalising goal, coming out second-best in a 50:50 tussle and then left floundering as the Spaniard dashed past him 5

  • Georgios Samaras Thrown on after McDonald's penalty miss and passed up a golden chance to put his side back in front but couldn't direct his header on target 5


  • © All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.



    spacer
     IN YOUR AREA
     
    Travel Shop
    Airport Parking
    Travel Insurance
    Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
    Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use