logo
   Web Issue 3149 May 17 2008   
spacer
How a £3bn tunnel is all that’s needed to get from Cork to South Korea via Scotland
DAVID ROSS, Highland CorrespondentDecember 08 2007

Northern Ireland and Scotland should be linked by a tunnel, which would allow the traveller to go all the way from Cork to South Korea by train, according to a leading authority on public finance.

David Clement, a past chairman of the Chartered Institute of Public Finance and Accountancy (CIPFA) in Northern Ireland, said such a tunnel would be the next logical step following the reopening of St Pancras Station in London, bringing faster travel from Britain to the continent.

He will be presenting his arguments for a physical link across the North Channel when he appears at the CIPFA Transport and the Environment event on Tuesday in Belfast.

He will tell delegates that a tunnel would benefit the economy of both countries, and would allow travel from the south-west of Ireland right the way through to South Korea solely by train.

Mr Clement said yesterday: "The idea of a tunnel between Northern Ireland and Scotland is extremely exciting. Based on recent research conducted by the Centre for Cross Border Studies, there is enormous potential benefit for the Irish economy, north and south.

"I really hope that the new Northern Ireland Executive will pursue this exciting scheme."

Mr Clement will be part of a panel on Tuesday discussing what needs to be done to balance the need for an effective transport system with the need to protect the environment.

The Centre for Cross Border Studies was founded in September 1999 and is based in Armagh and Dublin.

It researches and develops co-operation across the Irish border in areas such as education, training, health, business, public administration, communications, agriculture and the environment.

In August, the centre's director, Andy Pollak, first floated the idea of a 21-mile bridge or tunnel connecting Scotland with Ireland. He thought a figure of £2bn or £3bn might be needed for a fixed link between the countries.

"The arguments against such a hugely ambitious proposal can be easily listed, led by the extremely high cost of building a bridge or tunnel between two underpopulated and peripheral regions of Britain and Ireland," Mr Pollak said.

"The 22.5-mile road bridge between Shanghai and Ningbo, believed to be the longest sea-crossing bridge in the world, is costing around £750m in a country with one of the industrialised world's lowest labour costs."

But he said the arguments in favour were worth hearing too. A link would provide a massive social and economic boost to both parts of Ireland and Scotland, "something a lot of people, including the Taoiseach and Northern Irish and Scottish First Ministers, view as an unadulterated good".


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Big Geo, Breakfast in Singapore on 12:42am Sat 8 Dec 07
The longest road tunnel in the world is the 24.5km Laerdal tunnel in Norway. In an underpopulated country on the periphery of Europe. How can they do it? Must be the positive attitude.
Posted by: Rothesay Saint, seoul on 3:48am Sat 8 Dec 07
Good luck finding a train that takes you through North Korea and into South Korea.
Posted by: donald, glasgow on 7:34am Sat 8 Dec 07
Yeah, Labour supported the Border in Korea too, as well as Ireland, Vietnam, Gibraltar, Hong Kong, Singapore, India, Africa, etc, etc.

They will put a Cork on this proposal.
Posted by: Shug, Glasgow on 10:42am Sat 8 Dec 07
Can we have a hi-speed rail connection to the continent first please!
What we don't need is another symbolic white elephant. The channel tunnel is still debt ridden so lets forget teh tunnel and build a TGV infrastructure which will link to the ferry terminal at each side of teh crossing
Posted by: derek, embra on 11:38am Sat 8 Dec 07
not necessarily so - you might have to get the wee bus thingy between central and queen st depending on where you need to arrive in london
Posted by: leesome, Glasgow on 4:59pm Sat 8 Dec 07
A tunnel under the Irish sea, surely this would get in the way of all those proposed drill bits seeking oil & gas. Mind you, if it were deep enough then we could pipe water between the countries and save on our heating bill, lovely hot water fresh from the deep.
Posted by: Ian McKellar, West Kirby on 7:53pm Sat 8 Dec 07
You can get a train from Cork to Belfast/Larne, Then at the tunnel you'll have to change. The Irish Gauge is 5'3" while the Standard Gauge is 4'8.5" is in most of Europe. If you go via Poland/Russia the gauge changes again at Brest Litovsk.

Unless of couse you want to re-gauge the whole of Ireland
Posted by: Reprieved, waiting for trains on 10:17am Sun 9 Dec 07
WHo is sponsoring these optimists?
This is the counrtry which has just junked a major air/rail interchange hub (EARL)in favour of branches to nowhere, (GARL) which tolerated the rerouting of mainline connections into tortuous bottlenecks (Stranraer) and tolerates disconnection at the UK's centralised bottleneck (London).
WEe need consultants who can write Business Cases and get viable projects implemented, not PipeDreamers.
And we need analytical journalists, not headline jockeys
Posted by: Brad, Not waving but drowning on 1:57pm Mon 10 Dec 07
"a tunnel would be the next logical step following the reopening of St Pancras Station". EH?!
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use