logo
   Web Issue 3275 October 11 2008   
spacer
Is the future yellow for school buses?
Please ChooseJuly 13 2007
ROLL UP: Pupils from Robert Gordon's College, in Aberdeen, get off their new brightly coloured bus yesterday. Picture: Donald Stewart
ROLL UP: Pupils from Robert Gordon's College, in Aberdeen, get off their new brightly coloured bus yesterday. Picture: Donald Stewart

Every day across America 500,000 yellow buses weave their way from street to street, carrying 25 million pupils to and from school.

The high-visibility colour was decided in 1939 and since then the buses have become an unqualified success and an American icon, with the buses said to enjoy a safety record unequalled within the transportation industry.

Aberdeen-based First Group will soon own 63,000 of the American fleet and it is looking at the possibility of trying to transport the success story across the Atlantic.

At its annual general meeting in Aberdeen yesterday, it revealed new research which shows that 86% of British parents would like to send their children to school in dedicated, US-style, school buses.

As a result, First Group also announced plans to establish a Yellow School Bus Commission to review the use of the iconic yellow school buses in the UK, under the chairmanship of David Blunkett MP. It will examine and quantify the benefits of US-style home-to-school transport and review the yellow school bus model in the US along with similar schemes already being operated in the UK.

It will also examine ways of encouraging the use of the scheme here. Other members of the commission, still to be appointed, will bring experience of education, transport and the environment.

The research project on yellow buses, involving 1500 parents, was carried out by parenting website www.raisingkids.co.uk.

It found 38.7% of primary school children - almost four times more than their parents' generation - and 21% of secondary school children, more than three times their parents' generation, were taken to school by car. The survey also found 86% of parents would be willing to send their children to school on a dedicated school bus.

ROLL UP: Pupils from Robert Gordon's College, in Aberdeen, get off their new brightly coloured bus yesterday. Picture: Donald Stewart
ROLL UP: Pupils from Robert Gordon's College, in Aberdeen, get off their new brightly coloured bus yesterday. Picture: Donald Stewart

Moir Lockhead, chief executive of First Group, said he was personally convinced that yellow buses were the future for school transport in Scotland. "Our own experience of operating yellow school bus schemes both in the UK and in North America shows that this is a tried and tested way of delivering a high quality, safe and reliable home to school transport system. The schemes deliver benefits to a wide range of groups and offer a win-win situation for everyone involved. The buses are popular with children, who recognise them from American films and TV and enjoy travelling in them, and with parents and teachers, who value the quality and security of service they provide.

"There's a huge concern among parents about the environmental damage that is contributed to by the school run and an appetite to use school buses. Over 50% of children in North America travel to school in yellow buses, around 10 times the amount in the UK, and there's no reason we should not aim for that sort of figure on this side of the Atlantic."

He said the UK pilot schemes had proved very successful but that a recent evaluation by the Department of Transport had been inconclusive and the intention was for the commission to answer the unanswered questions.

The pilots had been funded in different ways, with one paid for jointly by parents, the local authority and businesses keen to see congestion eased.

"The kids think they are cool, the parents think it is brilliant because it is a secure door-to-door service, truancy levels in those trial areas have fallen dramatically and the schools like them," Mr Lockhead said.

However, he added: "For the system to work we would have to get the economics right and the commission can look at that. The cost of a bus in the US is $55,000 (£27,000) and to produce the same bus to European standards is more than double that."

He said they would shortly be buying 4000 or 5000 new buses a year in the US and he believed they could use that to reach a better deal for the UK market.

Councils in Scotland spend tens of millions of pounds a year ferrying children to and from school in taxis. They break into two main categories: those with disabilities or behavioural issues who cannot travel in a school bus; and those living in rural areas with no bus connections and where it is cheaper to use cabs.

Aberdeen City Council, where the US-style buses have been piloted, spends on average £2m a year on taxis for schoolchildren. The current total of children using taxis in the city is 629.

In the US, the yellow buses also take pupils on outings. The commission will look at how that could be achieved in the UK.

At least two-thirds of the fleet in America is wheelchair-accessible and all new stock would be built to accommodate disabled passengers.

Mr Lockhead said he wanted to understand exactly what happens now, where there are gaps and what would encourage parents to shift to a dedicated school bus.

"What would be the one thing, if you were taking a child to school, which would give you to trust in the system to hand over that child?" he said. "I have grandchildren and I would want to know it was safe and secure."

The 13 pilot yellow bus schemes running across the UK carry 8000 pupils a day on 185 buses.

One of the first was at the Robert Gordon's College in Aberdeen.

It started with a single yellow bus carrying pupils in from the Peterculter areas of the city.

It was so successful that yellow buses, funded by the school and parents, also run from Westhill and Ellon, carrying around 100 pupils in each morning.

Bob Leggate, school bursar, said at the request of parents they were constantly assessing the possibility of further routes. A more limited service is run after school because many pupils are involved in extra-curricular activities and demand was reduced.

He said: "The yellow buses reduce congestion in the city centre. If we can take 80 or 100 vehicles off the morning school run, it is beneficial not just to other parents but to other commuters.

"I think the pupils enjoy it and they like to get in early to see their pals and have time in the playground before the school days starts. The visibility of the yellow bus makes it a safer option, too."

Mr Blunkett said: "Yellow school buses offer a range of valuable benefits: providing a safe and high-quality means of carrying children to and from school; relieving congestion from our increasingly crowded towns and cities; and consequently making a real contribution to reducing our impact on the environment and climate change.

"With such powerful features in their favour we owe it to society to evaluate the best ways of delivering this sort of service and making recommendations on how we provide incentives to schools and local authorities to do so."


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.



   

Posted by: Simon on 11:47pm Thu 12 Jul 07
Why can't they just paint the existing buses yellow?

I love this comment from some tube working for the Robert Gordon's College - "I think the pupils enjoy it and they like to get in early to see their pals and have time in the playground before the school days starts." Complete bawlocks, that.
Posted by: Im not here on 1:13am Fri 13 Jul 07
Quite right Simon. Just paint the existing buses obviously hasn't occurred to them.

As for the kids using them - that's up to the attitude of the parents more than the kids.
Posted by: Jock Strap, Michigan, USA on 2:53am Fri 13 Jul 07
Will someone please explain why a bus, built to European standards, costs double that of the US bus ($110,000 versus $55,000), or is BAE handling the procurement :-)
Posted by: Scott, Glasgow on 9:32am Fri 13 Jul 07
The problem with the cost is that buses built for Europe now have to be low-floor or have some form disabled access, such as a wheelchair lift. This greatly adds to the engineering costs. The American ones are "high-floor" on the basis that school kids frankly are not bothered if there is a few steps so things like an existing truck chasis can be adapted - hence the price difference.

Painting an existing bus yellow is in option but given the fact that the US style school buses are no longer legal thanks to their entrance arrangements it means you have two options. Buy a new bus which is legal at the higher price (most operatours baulk at the though of buying an already expensive bus which may only be used once or twice a day) or painting an existing life-expired bus yellow. However, most local authorities require new vehicles and do not like the thought of a 20-year old double decker freshly painted yellow, no matter how funky it looks. Even importing them new from America is not an option as firstly you have to get exemption from the Disabled access regulations and then import taxes are added which means that the price becomes pretty uncompetetive

If we want to be serious about this - and everyone seems to think its a good idea - then the price of a new vehicle needs to be subsidised.
Posted by: stan, Glasgow on 1:36pm Fri 13 Jul 07
I think First Bus are making more than enough money (£3 for a day ticket!).

If they want public funds to buy new yellow buses for them, they are being more than a bit cheeky.

If they cut their ticket prices, I'll help out with some of the painting...
Posted by: Daffy_b, Glasgow on 1:52pm Fri 13 Jul 07
I think the buses are a great idea. However they need to be backed up by the rules that are strictly enforced in the USA. Namely - when the bus stops to let kids off - ALL vehicles must stop - and cannot pass the bus from any direction. The buses signal this by at each stop - their flashing hazard lights coming on, and a large sign is extended out from the side of the bus -alerting vehicles to stop. This allows the bus to safely let the kids get off, and allow them to cross the road safely also if necessary.
Posted by: jaycee, Canada on 5:21pm Fri 13 Jul 07
If you are going to adopt the yellow bus system please do it better than in North America. Here in Canada these buses are not safe as there are no seat belts for the children.
Posted by: AGM, Louisiana, US on 2:52pm Mon 16 Jul 07
This would be a complete disaster. As Jaycee points out, there are no seatbelts. Daffy-b reckons we should also follow the US system of never teaching a child how to cross a street, so that teenagers just wander out, assuming traffic will stop for them.

Buses pick up and drop off from almost every house, leaving the kids with no exercise at all.

Also, once firstbus figures out that the same bus can be used for three bus runs each morning and afternoon, Scotland will move to the disasterous 7.15 am starts for high school and letting teenage hooligans loose at 2.30 pm.
Posted by: smellie, Smellieville on 5:33pm Tue 17 Jul 07
1. Way back when Scotland was an industrial nation, people would have said: if we need buses, let's build them here. Maybe we can even export some to the USA... Now that thought doesn't even come remotely close to entering peoples' heads - they say "whoopee, let's buy some buses from the USA - the kids like them". Very very sad.

2. Yes school buses are used a lot in the USA (and in the little appendage called Canada... never mind) but try to keep in mind that North America is much much less urbanized and the population density much less than the UK. Maybe that's why they use school buses???

3. There are actually school buses used in rural areas of the UK. E.g. how do you think the kids on Arran get to the school? Ah but if only they were yellow and imported from the USA.... sheesh.

4. Maybe the kids should be told to walk or bike like their parents used to, to help the planet etc. Maybe they should not allow parent drop offs within two blocks of the school - as an anti-terrorism measure. Less fat kids, better environment. Nah ... buy yellow buses instead....
Posted by: smellie, Smellieville on 5:40pm Tue 17 Jul 07
Oh yah, while at it:

5. keep in mind your kid will now take 1hr to get to school instead of 15 minutes, since as AGM pointed out, the school bus stops at just about every house (though in Scotland I suspect it would have to be every block since UK blocks are about the same size as N American houses...)

6. AGM's point about the 7.15 am starts is correct. Believe it.

7. When it snows or is windy, the schools will close, because they will not want to run the school buses in case there is an accident and they would get sued big $$$ time. So be prepared to lose a day's work staying home with your kid or find day care for the day with 15 minutes notice. Good luck.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use