Mexican duped by ‘college’ ordered out of UK
A Mexican student ordered to leave the country by the immigration authorities faces the prospect of returning home without recouping thousands of pounds paid to the man behind a bogus Scottish college.
Magali Angeles Camacho, 32, paid more than £3000 for a course at a "college" in Glasgow which an investigation by The Herald has exposed as a sham institution.
David Morrison, the man behind the Kelvin Business School (KBS), has vanished owing thousands of pounds to vulnerable students from poor countries around the world.
Police and trading standards officers launched an inquiry into the activities of Mr Morrison, from Cumbernauld, his girlfriend Jin Wang, and KBS last week after The Herald's investigation into the burgeoning unregulated private college industry in Scotland.
One overseas student, Juliana Vasquez, whose parents forwent holidays and sold the family car to raise the money to send her to KBS, was left £1200 out of pocket and stranded in Scotland after Mr Morrison disappeared.
The Herald also uncovered two other Glasgow "colleges" with dubious credentials which falsely claim affiliation to reputable professional organisations in the UK, mislead students with deliberately inaccurate descriptions of their staff and facilities, and offer courses which are of little, if any, worth.
They specifically target overseas students and it is feared that the so-called colleges could be enabling the trafficking of illegal immigrants into Scotland by equipping them with student visas.
Miss Camacho is the latest victim to fall prey to Mr Morrison's sophisticated scam, which involves the use of a professional-looking website.
He then signs them up for courses, some of which do not exist, offering huge discounts if they pay up front with cash.
Miss Camacho, from Morelia, paid Mr Morrison £3404 for a course for an advanced diploma in business administration. When she turned up for the first day of the full-time course at the "college" within the Templeton Business Centre in January she immediately knew something was amiss.
She said: "I was the only person there, except for David. Eventually two other students - I think they were Kenyan - turned up.
"The teacher, who was also African, arrived late then told us there would be no teaching that day. Over the next week it got worse. The teacher was always late and always left early, he never prepared anything, he put things up on the board and never explained a thing.
"When I challenged him and asked him where he was educated and why he did not seem able to teach us anything he became rude and angry and aggressive."
The two African students seemed unconcerned about the quality of the teaching. Miss Camacho said: "I was there because I wanted to learn. They only seemed to be concerned about getting their visa."
After just one week Miss Camacho, who was already in possession of a student visa as she had previously been studying English in Glasgow, was informed by the Home Office that an application for renewal had been denied and she must leave the UK.
She said Mr Morrison gave ger a cheque for the amount owed, but when she went to cash it the bank said he had called ahead to cancel it. The "college" is now locked up.
Speaking from his home in Cumbernauld last night, Mr Morrison's father said: "I don't know where he is. I think he might have gone to China, but I'm not sure."
Letters Page 12
© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without
permission is prohibited.

Posted by: Archie on 4:54am Mon 9 Jul 07
"I don't know where he is. I think he might have gone to China"
CLASSIC.
"I don't know where he is. I think he might have gone to China"
CLASSIC.
Posted by: Archie2 on 6:31am Mon 9 Jul 07
I think he is in china. still there
I think he is in china. still there
Posted by: Age of Reason, BOARDING on 7:48am Mon 9 Jul 07
Archie - listen china that's not helpful. lol
Seriously this is a time to show our compassionate and caring social attitude. Clearly anyone using a scam college as a visa route should be repatriated. But if a con isperpetrewted on genuine potential students, they should not be sent home emptyhanded.
Dirt sticks and every unhappy customer tarnishes the dish for the hole buines. Once a reputation is lost it takes centuries to rebuild. So Scotland's cilleges & universities should be rallying to this. It won't require a deep dig in the pockets and the PR and integrity benefit is un-valuable.
Archie - listen china that's not helpful. lol
Seriously this is a time to show our compassionate and caring social attitude. Clearly anyone using a scam college as a visa route should be repatriated. But if a con isperpetrewted on genuine potential students, they should not be sent home emptyhanded.
Dirt sticks and every unhappy customer tarnishes the dish for the hole buines. Once a reputation is lost it takes centuries to rebuild. So Scotland's cilleges & universities should be rallying to this. It won't require a deep dig in the pockets and the PR and integrity benefit is un-valuable.
Posted by: david scott, boarding on 7:54am Mon 9 Jul 07
Archie - listen china that's not helpful. lol
Positive action required.
Seriously this is a time to show our compassionate and caring social attitude. Clearly anyone using a scam college as a visa route should be repatriated. But if a con is perpetrated on genuine potential students, they should not be sent home empty-handed.
Dirt sticks and every unhappy customer tarnishes the dish for the whole business. Once a reputation is lost it takes centuries to rebuild. So Scotland's colleges & universities should be rallying to this. It won't require a deep dig in the pockets and the PR and integrity benefit is un-valuable.
Archie - listen china that's not helpful. lol
Positive action required.
Seriously this is a time to show our compassionate and caring social attitude. Clearly anyone using a scam college as a visa route should be repatriated. But if a con is perpetrated on genuine potential students, they should not be sent home empty-handed.
Dirt sticks and every unhappy customer tarnishes the dish for the whole business. Once a reputation is lost it takes centuries to rebuild. So Scotland's colleges & universities should be rallying to this. It won't require a deep dig in the pockets and the PR and integrity benefit is un-valuable.
Posted by: BIG JOHN on 10:40am Mon 9 Jul 07
yes i agree that something has to be done, this is scandalous. The Scottish Exec should step in and compensate this poor girl and allow her to stay as her case is genuine, it would put some intergrity back into our system. Those who perpetrated this should be brought before the courts.
yes i agree that something has to be done, this is scandalous. The Scottish Exec should step in and compensate this poor girl and allow her to stay as her case is genuine, it would put some intergrity back into our system. Those who perpetrated this should be brought before the courts.
Posted by: west coaster, madrid on 12:28pm Mon 9 Jul 07
Maybe a fund should be set up by the herald. Then we could all help to compensate those who can prove (through bank records) they were defrauded.
Maybe a fund should be set up by the herald. Then we could all help to compensate those who can prove (through bank records) they were defrauded.
Posted by: west coaster, madrid on 12:34pm Mon 9 Jul 07
Maybe a fund should be set up by the herald. Then we could all help to compensate those who can prove (through bank records) they were defrauded.
Maybe a fund should be set up by the herald. Then we could all help to compensate those who can prove (through bank records) they were defrauded.
Posted by: G Lauder, West Fife on 12:57pm Mon 9 Jul 07
"After just one week Miss Camacho, who was already in possession of a student visa as she had previously been studying English in Glasgow, was informed by the Home Office that an application for renewal had been denied and she must leave the UK."
Perhaps she would have been wise to have checked the place out when she was studying English in Glasgow. I can't really see why she should not leave the country.
The authorities should crack down on these bogus colleges, I would imagine that someone running such an enterprise will have broken a number of laws. Hopefully, if they have defrauded people, they will be caught, and their assets seized and used to reimburse the victims.
Worryingly, when I googled "Kelvin Business School " and there is still a web site there, so perhaps the authorities could close the web site down.
"After just one week Miss Camacho, who was already in possession of a student visa as she had previously been studying English in Glasgow, was informed by the Home Office that an application for renewal had been denied and she must leave the UK."
Perhaps she would have been wise to have checked the place out when she was studying English in Glasgow. I can't really see why she should not leave the country.
The authorities should crack down on these bogus colleges, I would imagine that someone running such an enterprise will have broken a number of laws. Hopefully, if they have defrauded people, they will be caught, and their assets seized and used to reimburse the victims.
Worryingly, when I googled "Kelvin Business School " and there is still a web site there, so perhaps the authorities could close the web site down.
Posted by: Tom on 1:06pm Mon 9 Jul 07
Home Office needn't pay those students back; instead they can give them a visa with an expiry date with a few years and a work permit for making them re-earn the money. There must be jobs that need workforce.
Home Office needn't pay those students back; instead they can give them a visa with an expiry date with a few years and a work permit for making them re-earn the money. There must be jobs that need workforce.
Posted by: joe, inverness on 1:31pm Mon 9 Jul 07
thats fine about miss camacho but what about the rest that got ripped off. The KBS school was listed as 'recommended' by the UK education authorities. This is what people obviously followed when they did their research. Is it also noticed that when you google english school KBS tops the number of hits. It is obvious that much time was put into ensuring this (ie by the KBS owner). Also, who has heard of ABLEenglish, someone has put together very professional web pages to make it all look official.
thats fine about miss camacho but what about the rest that got ripped off. The KBS school was listed as 'recommended' by the UK education authorities. This is what people obviously followed when they did their research. Is it also noticed that when you google english school KBS tops the number of hits. It is obvious that much time was put into ensuring this (ie by the KBS owner). Also, who has heard of ABLEenglish, someone has put together very professional web pages to make it all look official.
Posted by: Oscar on 1:58pm Mon 9 Jul 07
These bogus colleges were given credence by the DoE. They should be compensating the victims.
These bogus colleges were given credence by the DoE. They should be compensating the victims.
Posted by: G Lauder, West Fife. on 2:08pm Mon 9 Jul 07
"These bogus colleges were given credence by the DoE. They should be compensating the victims."
If that were to happen then we, as taxpayers, would be footing the bill, for the alleged criminality of those running the bogus college.
"These bogus colleges were given credence by the DoE. They should be compensating the victims."
If that were to happen then we, as taxpayers, would be footing the bill, for the alleged criminality of those running the bogus college.
Posted by: Aelle on 2:50pm Mon 9 Jul 07
Just compiled a list of resuls for
everything called [bold]BOGUS[/bold] in Europe alone.
Bogus STUDENT 161.000
Bogus COLLEGE 210.000
Bogus INSTITUTION 555.000
Bogus DOCUMENTS 751.000
Bogus BATCH 171.000 No clue what it means
Bogus (E)- MAIL 1.560.000
Bogus S**T 232.000 even that!
More BOGUS 1.760.000
One exception is that there are only 20 bogus Terrorist, the rest are genuine.
Mind yer steps, laters. . .
Just compiled a list of resuls for
everything called
BOGUS in Europe alone.
Bogus STUDENT 161.000
Bogus COLLEGE 210.000
Bogus INSTITUTION 555.000
Bogus DOCUMENTS 751.000
Bogus BATCH 171.000 No clue what it means
Bogus (E)- MAIL 1.560.000
Bogus S**T 232.000 even that!
More BOGUS 1.760.000
One exception is that there are only 20 bogus Terrorist, the rest are genuine.
Mind yer steps, laters. . .
Posted by: Thomas Cochrane, Glasgow on 8:25pm Mon 9 Jul 07
How did we ever get into this state?
It is a national disgrace.
Glasgow City Council, Trading Standards, DoE and whatever other bunch of muppets are responsible for these colleges being allowed to exist should step in immediately and close them down.
There should be sepperate educational arragements mede for Scotland through the Executive.
Scotlnd once had the finest educational system in the world - perhaps it is time to aim for that staus again.
How did we ever get into this state?
It is a national disgrace.
Glasgow City Council, Trading Standards, DoE and whatever other bunch of muppets are responsible for these colleges being allowed to exist should step in immediately and close them down.
There should be sepperate educational arragements mede for Scotland through the Executive.
Scotlnd once had the finest educational system in the world - perhaps it is time to aim for that staus again.
Posted by: Ruth, Glasgow on 3:44pm Tue 10 Jul 07
Someone has removed all the Kelvin Business School's websites as of Tuesday July 10. Someone must be reading The Herald!
Someone has removed all the Kelvin Business School's websites as of Tuesday July 10. Someone must be reading The Herald!
Posted by: Alejandra Findlay, Glasgow on 6:25pm Tue 10 Jul 07
I think it is unfair people like Mr. Morrison take advantage of foreign people who come to Glasgow to improve their education and better their lives. After working very hard and long hours in their own countries to save money to pay for a college course, only to have this parasite steal their cash and their future live-li-hoods. Some people have no conscience whatsoever and truly don't care about there fellow human beings one can only he hope that the following old proverb is true " what comes around goes around" Mr Morrison shame on you................
I think it is unfair people like Mr. Morrison take advantage of foreign people who come to Glasgow to improve their education and better their lives. After working very hard and long hours in their own countries to save money to pay for a college course, only to have this parasite steal their cash and their future live-li-hoods. Some people have no conscience whatsoever and truly don't care about there fellow human beings one can only he hope that the following old proverb is true " what comes around goes around" Mr Morrison shame on you................
Posted by: arnold, 903-343 on 5:59am Wed 11 Jul 07
yes i agree, shame on you mr morrison, preying on the innocent. I sincerely hope you go down for what you have done. Some of these people have dreams and you have completely shattered them, you and your girlfriend. You are a sad case for a human being!
yes i agree, shame on you mr morrison, preying on the innocent. I sincerely hope you go down for what you have done. Some of these people have dreams and you have completely shattered them, you and your girlfriend. You are a sad case for a human being!
Posted by: joe, inverness on 6:04am Wed 11 Jul 07
www.ableenglish.com
who ever removed kelvin business school, you may want to remove this website as well. This is an artificial product Mr Morrison seemed to have invented, it links back to kelvin business school. This muppet is trying to rip people off from all angles!
www.ableenglish.com
who ever removed kelvin business school, you may want to remove this website as well. This is an artificial product Mr Morrison seemed to have invented, it links back to kelvin business school. This muppet is trying to rip people off from all angles!
Posted by: joe, inverness on 6:11am Wed 11 Jul 07
yes i agree with west coaster, a fund should be set up to help this girl get back into britain and study and fulfil her dreams.
yes i agree with west coaster, a fund should be set up to help this girl get back into britain and study and fulfil her dreams.
Posted by: Danielle J, East Sussex on 10:36pm Wed 11 Jul 07
Everybody has got a dream, So these Africans did it to get something man. We hope it wont affect them. Later.
Everybody has got a dream, So these Africans did it to get something man. We hope it wont affect them. Later.
Posted by: Nicola on 1:58pm Wed 29 Aug 07
Just for the record, he also didn't pay his staff. After reading this (£200 out of pocket) I'm not holding out much hope of ever seeing my money but I sincerely hope he gets what's coming to him
Just for the record, he also didn't pay his staff. After reading this (£200 out of pocket) I'm not holding out much hope of ever seeing my money but I sincerely hope he gets what's coming to him