The C Diff outbreak at Vale of Leven has been a serious issue for Labour to test its mettle as an effective opposition. This is precisely the kind of 'event' that government ministers fear, when they need to be seen as having taken action, as getting control of a situation long after it's too late, of showing appropriate contrition and empathy for the bereaved, and all while there is a little bug wreaking havoc, over which ministers can't hope to have any control.
While pressing home the Scottish Government's discomfort on the issue, it was odd that Wendy Alexander opted not to ask about it at First Minister's Questions last Thursday - while Annabel Goldie and Nicol Stephen did. Perhaps she felt enough had been said when her colleagues accused the government of a 'sinister' role and the mother of all cover ups. The SNP was lame in its outrage at Labour for playing party politics with this issue. As if an SNP opposition team wouldn't have done exactly the same as Labour. The only difference is that they would have done it better.
______________________
Scottish Labour has been filling some of the vacancies in its backroom team, particularly on the media front, but it is some way off being a model of message clarity. Gavin Yates, head of communications for the shadow cabinet (and MSP group?), was joined by Simon Pia, spokesman for group leader Wendy Alexander, and more recently Andrew MacFadyen has joined, from Channel Four News, as director of press and broadcasting, along with Rami Okasha, a former candidate and student leader, who is head of communications at party headquarters. Which of them speaks for the party? Take your pick. But on the evidence so far, it doesn't yet look a whole lot like joined up opposition.
_________________
It seems one of our regular contributors to The Herald's politics discussion forums has been moonlighting as a script-writer for the Stone of Destiny, premiered to a stellar audience at the Edinburgh Film Festival during the weekend. A fine cast was let down by screenplay as clunkily subtle as a Hillman Imp cobbled together on a bad day at Linwood. For instance, we learn, from Billy 'Hobbit' Boyd that the reason Scots are not fired up for the cause of home rule is because we don't think, and we're too busy. Yes, it really is that simple.
___________________
Labour has never been in the running for the Henley by-election, caused by Boris Johnson's departure for London city hall. But a new humiliation awaits if one high street bookmaker is correct in saying the Government's candidate is on course to lose its deposit.
_________________
As ithers see us, in the Jamaica Gleaner, where David Jessop of the Caribbean Council has been reflecting on a visit of High Commissioners to Holyrood earlier this month:
"The Scottish Parliament is unusually accessible and transparent to the Scottish people; it is socially driven and has a membership that is almost one-third female. Its members do not have the remoteness or, for the most part, the confrontational political style that Westminster has. Its chamber is U-shaped and the process is more given to consensus. The language of Parliament is not archaic, and it is strikingly family-friendly with large numbers of schoolchildren visiting and sitting in the public galleries of the chamber.
"For the Anglophone Caribbean locked into the Westminster model with all of its formality, confrontational style, arcane practice and its implied remoteness from the people, Scotland's parliamentary system and style offers a model worth studying, not least to see whether there might be ways in which adoption of best practice could rejuvenate Caribbean parliamentary democracy.
"Clearly, Scotland is not the Caribbean, but if the high commissioners' visit to Scotland indicated anything, it was that there are important devolved and modern consensual and socially oriented models of governance in the United Kingdom that any nation which has inherited the British model might usefully learn more from."
It seems one of our regular contributors to The Herald's politics discussion forums has been moonlighting as a script-writer for the Stone of Destiny, premiered to a stellar audience at the Edinburgh Film Festival during the weekend. A fine cast was let down by screenplay as clunkily subtle as a Hillman Imp cobbled together on a bad day at Linwood. For instance, we learn, from Billy 'Hobbit' Boyd that the reason Scots are not fired up for the cause of home rule is because we don't think, and we're too busy....
Ya rotten sod Duggie! That was one of the better lines of dialogue what I wrote!!!
It seems one of our regular contributors to The Herald's politics discussion forums has been moonlighting as a script-writer for the Stone of Destiny, premiered to a stellar audience at the Edinburgh Film Festival during the weekend. A fine cast was let down by screenplay as clunkily subtle as a Hillman Imp cobbled together on a bad day at Linwood. For instance, we learn, from Billy 'Hobbit' Boyd that the reason Scots are not fired up for the cause of home rule is because we don't think, and we're too busy....
Ya rotten sod Duggie! That was one of the better lines of dialogue what I wrote!!!
Below is a link to an online poll using the exact question proposed in the Scottish Government's White Paper, "Choosing Scotland's Future."
[bold]VOTE NOW[/bold]
scottishreferendum2008.blogspot.com
Please forward on this link to anyone eligible to vote in Scotland, the aim is to have a minimum of 1000 votes.
Thankyou
Below is a link to an online poll using the exact question proposed in the Scottish Government's White Paper, "Choosing Scotland's Future."
VOTE NOW
scottishreferendum2008.blogspot.com
Please forward on this link to anyone eligible to vote in Scotland, the aim is to have a minimum of 1000 votes.
By the way, Duggie, now that it's just you and me, maybe you could explain why all the posts on Calman wanting to know what we think were summarily removed. Some excellent posts they were too!
And while we're on the subject: why no posts allowed on your two fine articles: How oil would put Scotland ln the Black
Scotland's public finances would be in a better financial state than those of the UK if its offshore oilfields were included in tax revenue, according to Scottish Government statistics.
and
Number-crunching exposes Treasury sloppiness ?
Love the choice of "sloppiness", by the way....excelent connotation of "oops just a silly little mistake old boy", which diverts from the rather more sinister truth, which is that of deliberate deception on the part of a unionist institution to the detement yet again of Scotland, the ahem..equal partner in this most glorious of unions.
Good to see Gordy boy falling for a sailor this week - he does need some cheering up doesn't he? I'm the "Lord High Admiral of the English Naveee" he trilled wonderfully in the Chamber...at least he's dropped the pretence that Britain exists - after all we're all English now....
By the way, Duggie, now that it's just you and me, maybe you could explain why all the posts on Calman wanting to know what we think were summarily removed. Some excellent posts they were too!
And while we're on the subject: why no posts allowed on your two fine articles: How oil would put Scotland ln the Black
Scotland's public finances would be in a better financial state than those of the UK if its offshore oilfields were included in tax revenue, according to Scottish Government statistics.
and
Number-crunching exposes Treasury sloppiness ?
Love the choice of "sloppiness", by the way....excelent connotation of "oops just a silly little mistake old boy", which diverts from the rather more sinister truth, which is that of deliberate deception on the part of a unionist institution to the detement yet again of Scotland, the ahem..equal partner in this most glorious of unions.
Good to see Gordy boy falling for a sailor this week - he does need some cheering up doesn't he? I'm the "Lord High Admiral of the English Naveee" he trilled wonderfully in the Chamber...at least he's dropped the pretence that Britain exists - after all we're all English now....
[quote][bold]nostress[/bold] wrote:
Thanks Wardog, good to see the votes racking up eh? Just a pity it's not a Labour-run poll though - we could have placed multiple votes then :-)[/quote] Aye, it's coming along, would be great to get over 1000 votes.
[italic]Forward the link to anyone & everyone.[/italic]
nostress wrote:
Thanks Wardog, good to see the votes racking up eh? Just a pity it's not a Labour-run poll though - we could have placed multiple votes then :-)
Aye, it's coming along, would be great to get over 1000 votes.
Posted by: george alexander at 10:39pm on Mon 23 Jun 08
Anyone see the 'big' news item in Scottish politics, no not oil or Scotlands massive fiscal surplus but a disc of encrypted password protected 999 calls have gone missing.
Now, don't get me wrong, all data should be secure and people confident that their personal details cannot be used in identity fraud. But I get the feeling that the Unionist media are trying desperately to concoct a story of significance here.
The Herald have already started to 'balance' the revamped GERS figures with todays scare story suggesting violent criminals and paedophiles being set free. A story taken apart by an excellent comment from (I believe) Nostress.
What will Douglas's contribution to the 'journalistic balancing act' be?, I suspect we won't have to wait long to find out.
Anyone see the 'big' news item in Scottish politics, no not oil or Scotlands massive fiscal surplus but a disc of encrypted password protected 999 calls have gone missing.
Now, don't get me wrong, all data should be secure and people confident that their personal details cannot be used in identity fraud. But I get the feeling that the Unionist media are trying desperately to concoct a story of significance here.
The Herald have already started to 'balance' the revamped GERS figures with todays scare story suggesting violent criminals and paedophiles being set free. A story taken apart by an excellent comment from (I believe) Nostress.
What will Douglas's contribution to the 'journalistic balancing act' be?, I suspect we won't have to wait long to find out.
Posted by: Grassy Knollington at 11:26pm on Mon 23 Jun 08
More Trump anyone? There's a lot of mileage in it yet.
Incidentally I notice a theme developing amongst Scottish political journalists. They are finally losing patience with Labour for not being good enough. Brian Taylor, in his BBC blog is virtually telling Wendy the best course of action to take to be more effective , Douglas is beside himself with labour's ineptitude in opposition and his frustration with the Labour press office is palpable.
It's all slipping away and these chaps can only do so much after all they're just reporters. Who will rescue Labour in Scotland and put these hardworking journos out of their misery?
How much longer can they go on trying to make a silk purse out of the pig's ear they've been given to work with? They've been carrying Labour for too long and with scant thanks for their efforts. How would you like to have to try and make the current Labour lot look good every day when you're carrying Wendy like a dead weight and trying to make Salmond look bad at the same time ? It's a darned hard job and they've stuck at it despite the brickbats from the online vermin. Give these guys a break, some decent material to work with for a change and make their jobs enjoyable again.
p.s I like that term "clunkily subtle as a Hillman Imp" it reminds me of the pro Labour headlines on The Herald political stories.
More Trump anyone? There's a lot of mileage in it yet.
Incidentally I notice a theme developing amongst Scottish political journalists. They are finally losing patience with Labour for not being good enough. Brian Taylor, in his BBC blog is virtually telling Wendy the best course of action to take to be more effective , Douglas is beside himself with labour's ineptitude in opposition and his frustration with the Labour press office is palpable.
It's all slipping away and these chaps can only do so much after all they're just reporters. Who will rescue Labour in Scotland and put these hardworking journos out of their misery?
How much longer can they go on trying to make a silk purse out of the pig's ear they've been given to work with? They've been carrying Labour for too long and with scant thanks for their efforts. How would you like to have to try and make the current Labour lot look good every day when you're carrying Wendy like a dead weight and trying to make Salmond look bad at the same time ? It's a darned hard job and they've stuck at it despite the brickbats from the online vermin. Give these guys a break, some decent material to work with for a change and make their jobs enjoyable again.
p.s I like that term "clunkily subtle as a Hillman Imp" it reminds me of the pro Labour headlines on The Herald political stories.
Hi George, yeah looks like orders have come in from dahn saff to up the Scary Monster tactics - we've had crazed crims roaming free, oil too expensive now for us to manage, this crap about a disc lost by TNT by the way - not the Health Minister - class sizes, and now UK jobs loss at Govan - that's one of their more trusted favourites I believe - it was fun watching the tanned bespoke-suited well-fed westminster socialists creek their way to the front of the press conference and in collective smug tones gravely announce how the Clyde would die with independence...great stuff - they felt comfortable with it you felt, familiar old story territory for them all....they really are beyond contempt
Hi George, yeah looks like orders have come in from dahn saff to up the Scary Monster tactics - we've had crazed crims roaming free, oil too expensive now for us to manage, this crap about a disc lost by TNT by the way - not the Health Minister - class sizes, and now UK jobs loss at Govan - that's one of their more trusted favourites I believe - it was fun watching the tanned bespoke-suited well-fed westminster socialists creek their way to the front of the press conference and in collective smug tones gravely announce how the Clyde would die with independence...great stuff - they felt comfortable with it you felt, familiar old story territory for them all....they really are beyond contempt
Posted by: jim mitchell at 12:05am on Tue 24 Jun 08
Now now nostress, we must heed these warnings from our unbiased unionist MP's after all it's not as if any yards have closed under unionist governments, oh no wait a minute they have, ok then what about our other industries, they have always been safe, one's like coal mining, maybe not, steel, then again, I know fishing.
There must be something, I mean there not the sort of people just to make things up or tell lies, now are they?
Now now nostress, we must heed these warnings from our unbiased unionist MP's after all it's not as if any yards have closed under unionist governments, oh no wait a minute they have, ok then what about our other industries, they have always been safe, one's like coal mining, maybe not, steel, then again, I know fishing.
There must be something, I mean there not the sort of people just to make things up or tell lies, now are they?
You're right Jim, what was I thinking of...must get back to my cringe mode...thank you UK masters for all the pretty little baubles you've given us who are so unworthy, we're so unworthy, we're so unworthy....thank you for ascending from London to pat us on the heads again...and give us the benefits of your munificence...and wisdom...
You're right Jim, what was I thinking of...must get back to my cringe mode...thank you UK masters for all the pretty little baubles you've given us who are so unworthy, we're so unworthy, we're so unworthy....thank you for ascending from London to pat us on the heads again...and give us the benefits of your munificence...and wisdom...
Posted by: george alexander at 6:39am on Tue 24 Jun 08
I see The Herald front page headline is the same item that the BBC spashed on yesterday.........the 999 call disc, encrypted and password protected, lost by TNT (private firm).
I was going to post my earlier comment fro this blog, when guess what? No comments allowed on the latest front page scare story !!
Oh, by the way Grassy, not that I want to steal your thunder but I've posted many times that the real opposition in(to?) Scotland are the media.
I see The Herald front page headline is the same item that the BBC spashed on yesterday.........the 999 call disc, encrypted and password protected, lost by TNT (private firm).
I was going to post my earlier comment fro this blog, when guess what? No comments allowed on the latest front page scare story !!
Oh, by the way Grassy, not that I want to steal your thunder but I've posted many times that the real opposition in(to?) Scotland are the media.
Posted by: george alexander at 6:46am on Tue 24 Jun 08
Good grief, just had a quick look through todays Herald, the Unionist propoganda has been ramped up to a level that even surprises me !!!
I predicted a plethora of such articles this week, but the sheer intensity is almost unbelievable.
Good grief, just had a quick look through todays Herald, the Unionist propoganda has been ramped up to a level that even surprises me !!!
I predicted a plethora of such articles this week, but the sheer intensity is almost unbelievable.
Douglas
Why has the Herald not made any mention of Wendy Alexander's latest call for the independence referendum to be brought forward...again.
Surely this is news, given the magnitude of the issue.
Surely this is big news, given that she appears to have gone against her boss, Gordon Brown, yet again.
Douglas
Why has the Herald not made any mention of Wendy Alexander's latest call for the independence referendum to be brought forward...again.
Surely this is news, given the magnitude of the issue.
Surely this is big news, given that she appears to have gone against her boss, Gordon Brown, yet again.
Posted by: Grassy knollington at 8:54pm on Tue 24 Jun 08
Hi George, you're right that the media are the real opposition in Scotland and I have enjoyed your many excellent posts. I was just noticing that lately the journalists seem to be increasingly exasperated with Labour, they're still doing the labour party's job for them of course and just as well really as the current crop of MSP's don't seem capable themselves.
Their frustration with the calibre of the opposition seems at times to be on a par with their intense dislike of the Nationalist Government.
I get the impression that they're almost screaming "Yes we'll continue to do all we can to undermine the nats but for pity's sake give us some help here and at least look competent, we can't do it all on our own."
Hi George, you're right that the media are the real opposition in Scotland and I have enjoyed your many excellent posts. I was just noticing that lately the journalists seem to be increasingly exasperated with Labour, they're still doing the labour party's job for them of course and just as well really as the current crop of MSP's don't seem capable themselves.
Their frustration with the calibre of the opposition seems at times to be on a par with their intense dislike of the Nationalist Government.
I get the impression that they're almost screaming "Yes we'll continue to do all we can to undermine the nats but for pity's sake give us some help here and at least look competent, we can't do it all on our own."
Posted by: David Alexander at 10:04pm on Wed 25 Jun 08
[quote]Anyone for a twinning arrangement with Tobago?[/quote]
Trinidad maybe.
Coincidentally, this is where I am at the moment working in the burgeoning oil industry.
T&T gained their Independence from Britain in 1962 and is undergoing much transformation at the moment due to their oil revenues.
Isn't it amazing that this 50 mile by 30 mile island can be so prosperous and confident and yet Scotland has to get its aspirations trampled at every opportunity by our Westminster politicians and its supporters in the media.
Anyone for a twinning arrangement with Tobago?
Trinidad maybe.
Coincidentally, this is where I am at the moment working in the burgeoning oil industry.
T&T gained their Independence from Britain in 1962 and is undergoing much transformation at the moment due to their oil revenues.
Isn't it amazing that this 50 mile by 30 mile island can be so prosperous and confident and yet Scotland has to get its aspirations trampled at every opportunity by our Westminster politicians and its supporters in the media.
Posted by: ninemikemike at 12:09am on Thu 26 Jun 08
Jamaica is a long way from Tobago, and a different country and culture.
Surely you haven't had the advantages of a Nu-Liebour ejukayshun have you Dougie?
Jamaica is a long way from Tobago, and a different country and culture.
Surely you haven't had the advantages of a Nu-Liebour ejukayshun have you Dougie?