logo
   Web Issue 3186 July 6 2008   
spacer
Political Blogs
Political Blogs
Robbie DinwoodieRobbie's blog: FMQs
Posted by Robbie Dinwoodie at 12:05pm on Thu 8 May 08
AS I WRITE this blog the First Minister and opposition party leaders are being prepared for the weekly high noon ritual of FMQs. Very often the beauty of this is that something seriously left-field can be introduced, so that the FM cannot possibly be prepared for it. The former Green MSP Shiona Baird developed an expertise in obscure detail that was bound to discomfit Jack McConnell.

A couple of week's ago when Wendy Alexander chose not to go on the Grangemouth crisis it rebounded on her, making her look out of touch with the pressing issue of the day.

Having tried to set a new agenda this week with her call for an early independence referendum, she has little choice but to run with it today. If she chose not to go on the issue it would be interpreted as another u-turn and the SNP are already painting the Labour leader as “eccentric” and prone to changing her mind. As one senior Salmond aide said this week: “What we are saying is contingent on what Wendy Alexander is saying today, Tuesday, but who know what she will say come Thursday?”
So now it's Thursday, Ms Alexander had little choice but to go on what she herself has made issue of the week, and therefore has little chance of springing much of a surprise on the FM, who is on very firm ground given that all he is doing is sticking (for once, Labour may claim?) to a manifesto commitment.

Where is Ms Alexander going on all this? Here “bring it on” language shows that she wants to paint the SNP as lacking the courage of their convictions.

But she is also paving the way to back-track on her new strategy because she wants to contest the wording of the referendum question. This is a huge issue.

The Government's preferred wording as outlined in the White Paper is to ask voters whether they are for or against the following: “I agree that the Scottish Government should negotiate a settlement with the Government of the UK so that Scotland becomes an independent state.”

When opinion pollsters have asked that same question over the last year there has been steady growth in the numbers supporting the proposition, to the point that is now level pegging. But when the resolutely Unionist Daily Telegraph polled on the issue it asked the following question: “If there were a referendum on whether to retain the Scottish Parliament and Executive in more or less their present form or to establish Scotland as a completely separate state outside the Unite Kingdom but inside the European Union, how would you vote?”

The combination of a complex, somewhat convoluted question along with the negative connotations of “a completely separate state outside the UK” talks up the fear factor of Scotland “going it alone” and implying isolation in the international community.

Labour don't like the word independence. The United States and other countries around the world do not celebrate Separation Day. They celebrate Independence Day, which is why the SNP Government want to use a word seen as having positive connotations, and why their Unionist opponents are desperate to avoid that term.

The issue of the wording of the question is Ms Alexander's exit clause from her new pro-referendum strategy.

And with that, I'm off to watch FMWs.

Share this post on: Digg | del.icio.us | Furl | reddit | NowPublic | Yahoo!
Posted by: spagan at 1:30pm on Thu 8 May 08
Hope FMQ was as much fun for you as it was for us Robbie?
There weren't many smiling faces on the Northern British New Labour Party.
Its been a sad week for Labour - every one that passes is sadder and sadder for them.
On a cheery note - I'm off to place a small bet at William Hill's at 150 to 1 - for Scotland to be independent by 2012!
Slainte Mhor
Posted by: Charles Bisset at 2:15pm on Thu 8 May 08
Great blog Robbie I really do enjoy your writings. I have just watched FMQ's, I thought Wendy Alexander's body language fascinating she really sagged . She knows she has handled this issue badly, she knows she has annoyed the Prime Minister no end, and her constant reference to those around her supporting her tells it all. I think Wendy knows the game is up and her time is drawing to a close.
A gifted and intelligent woman, but what a lousy politician.
Posted by: spagan at 3:14pm on Thu 8 May 08
Charles
What exactly are her "gifts"? She's able to put both feet in her mouth at the same time - but not what Sir Alan Sugar would call "transferable skills"? ('tho it would be great TV to watch her in next year's 'Apprentice' show!)
She's been portrayed as "highly intelligent" - by a range of promoters and sycophants. The evidence suggests she's always been the class swot - even copying down and rote-learning the teachers' jokes.
You'll be telling me she's a socialist next. (Well kind of like George Galloway or Robertson perhaps?)
Slainte Mhor
Slainte Mhor
Posted by: megz at 5:29pm on Thu 8 May 08
Why is it on the bbc website they make FMQs make it sound like things went ok for wendy. Wendy got a kicking from each of the other leaders and she looked so flustered, red faced and quite honestly close to tears. Geez does one of the b's stand for biased in bbc?
Posted by: doonhamer at 11:37pm on Thu 8 May 08
I turned on the telly to watch FMQ and all they had on was a funeral. The sad faces behind Wendy were a testiment to the new situation that confronts Labour. Every time Alexander the Grate rose to speak, the crackling of the spines of Labour as they cringed lower in their seats could be heard all the way to Paisley.

It even got worse when Annabel and Nicol presented eulogies for Labour and Alex topped them with a eulogy for the entire union.

After previous incarnations, I was of the mind that Alexander the Grate and her party could go no lower.

I was wrong.

That descent seems to have no limit.
Posted by: ditchgazza at 2:13am on Fri 9 May 08
Spines, Labour, Doonhamer.
Surely a typo.
Posted by: ditchgazza at 3:06am on Fri 9 May 08
Spines, Labour, Doonhamer.
Surely a typo.
Posted by: Disgusted Dorothy at 2:48pm on Fri 9 May 08
Indeed the b in BBC is for bias ,and we pay for it which really makes me angry!

Did anyone else notice that there were'nt so many " Hooray Henrys " in the Labour ranks at yesterdays FMQs ?
Was Lord Foulkes not there to do his usual cheer/jeer leading ?
Posted by: Kinghob at 11:25pm on Sun 11 May 08
Robbie Dinwoody:
Where is Ms Alexander going on all this?


Hopefully she is going out the door.

Labour are a shambles of a party that have failed to put a foot right in the last year.
Posted by: Wardog at 2:26am on Tue 13 May 08
FAO ROBBIE DINWOODIE

Robbie, can the Herald explain why comments are being continual banned from story's relating to Wendy Alexander.

Can you confirm/deny rumours that Scottish Labour are making complaints to the Herald to try and minimise open discussion and criticism of her policies?

I think the blogging community on these threads really deserves some kind of explanation here.

Wardog
Posted by: Juan Kerr at 8:36am on Tue 13 May 08
Good call Wardog. Their has been a lot of news gerrymandering of late. I notice it was not this way with OTT censorship when the pretendy trump row errupted.
Posted by: Disgusted Dorothy at 12:19am on Wed 14 May 08
Indeed Juan , they allowed all sorts of comments on the Trump non story , which they made into a BIG story.
Posted by: dws at 9:42am on Wed 14 May 08
Wardog wrote:
FAO ROBBIE DINWOODIE Robbie, can the Herald explain why comments are being continual banned from story's relating to Wendy Alexander. Can you confirm/deny rumours that Scottish Labour are making complaints to the Herald to try and minimise open discussion and criticism of her policies? I think the blogging community on these threads really deserves some kind of explanation here. Wardog
Seconded.
Add your comment
Your name
Your email address *
**
Security Image. Registered site users are not required to enter Security Image Information.
 
 e.g. 123-123
Your comment
Please note: All HTML tags will be ignored.
Format Text:

 
* Your email address will not be displayed
Comments are unmoderated, but you must abide by our terms of use. We will react if anything that breaks the rules comes to our attention and we may delete inappropriate postings. Please treat other people with respect. You must not post anything that is abusive, indecent, unlawful or defamatory. Remember, you are personally liable for what you post on this site. If you wish to complain about a comment, contact us here.
spacer
 
RSS
Add this channel to My Yahoo!
Add this channel to My MSN!
What is RSS?
About this blog
Bloggers
Douglas Fraser
Robbie Dinwoodie
Douglas Fraser
SCOTTISH POLITICAL EDITOR
Michael Settle
Recent Entries
JULY
SMTWTFS
..12345
6789101112
13141516171819
20212223242526
2728293031..
More
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use