
After six months of disaster... still time to fit in another couple
 |
| UNDER FIRE: Gordon Brown was barracked and berated at the Commons dispatch box over last week's EU summit |
Analysis
As MPs today say a cheery farewell to Westminster for another year and turn their minds to carols, mince pies and all things Christmassy, Gordon Brown will be praying for some Yuletide respite from six months of fire, flood, pestilence and ineptitude.
On the evidence of yesterday's events the spirit of
kindness and goodwill to all men does not extend to the lugubrious inhabitant of 10 Downing Street.
Another day of woe began with journalists asking awkward questions about the PM's faith in Mervyn King, governor of the Bank of England, who is supposedly at loggerheads with the UK Government over Northern Rock and changes to the so-called
tripartite arrangements to avert another banking disaster.
It was claimed a senior official at the Bank - no names mentioned - felt ministers were "unable to focus because morale in the government is so low".
No 10 insisted: "The Prime Minister's morale is very good as you would expect." As for Mr King, Mr Brown had "full confidence" in him and thought he was doing a "first- rate job". Asked if Alistair Darling, the Chancellor, felt the same, the PM's spokesman replied: "I'm sure he does."
But sources are suggesting that, with the Northern Rock drama still to run its uncertain course, Mr King might go before he is pushed; the renewal of his tenure at Threadneedle Street remains conspicuously absent.
If that were not enough, Mr Brown's fortunes were less than helped by the lunch-
time appearance of Charlie Falconer, one-time flatmate of Tony Blair who was quickly dumped as Lord Chancellor when the MP for Cowdenbeath took over the reins of power.
The ex-minister popped up to insist that the PM's drive for a 42-day terror detention limit was simply not needed. "If it is not necessary because you don't need it to fight terrorism effectively, then you shouldn't do it," he told the BBC.
Within an hour, Mr Brown was being barracked and berated at the Commons dispatch box over last week's EU summit. David Cameron used the opportunity to launch another personal broadside at the Prime Minister, accusing him of being "shifty and untrustworthy" as the Conservative leader renewed demands for a referendum on the European Reform Treaty.
An hour later, Mr Darling was updating MPs on the HM Revenue and Customs data security blunder, admitting police still had not recovered the missing computer disks, which contained the personal details of 25 million people.
Embarrassment was piled on embarrassment when Ruth Kelly, Westminster's Transport Secretary, joined the ministerial queue to make a statement, admitting that the personal details of some three million learner drivers had gone Awol.
This, she assured colleagues, was not as bad as the HMRC scandal because this time banking details were not among the missing information. MPs were not impressed.
Of course, it allowed opposition members to pile on the pressure and talk of "systemic" failure and ministerial "incompetence" even though politicians were not personally responsible for the lost information.
If all that were not enough, David Harnett, the acting head of HMRC, under cross-examination by MPs, confirmed police were investigating the disappearance of 1.5kg of cocaine from a supposedly secure lock-up in Coventry. Thankfully, he assured back benchers that guns, ammunition and passports were not involved in the disappearance.
| Within an hour, Mr Brown was being barracked and berated at the Commons dispatch box over last week’s EU summit | |
|
Just to cap a wonderful day for Mr Brown, a parliamentary written answer revealed that a member of security staff at the Home Office was arrested on Friday after being exposed as an illegal immigrant.
The illegal worker was identified and arrested the day after Jacqui Smith, the Home Secretary, revealed that more than 11,000 illegal immigrants could have been cleared by the authorities to take on sensitive security jobs since 2004.
And last night, the Tories claimed there was an effective "stealth amnesty" after it was revealed that only around 52,000 cases had been dealt with in a backlog of asylum seekers numbering between 400,000 and 450,000.
Add to all this the outbreaks of foot-and-mouth and blue tongue, the failed terror attacks, the criticism of lack of resources and Army overstretch by former military chiefs, the political bungle of the General Election that never was, the police probe into the party funding row, the controversy over police pay, the prospect of an economic downturn with rising inflation next year and the little matter of the Tories hitting 45% in the polls, then one can understand how Mr Brown is looking somewhere - anywhere - for solace.
Recently, the PM was asked what he wanted for Christmas and replied: "A day off." He should be so lucky.
After all, there are still two weeks of 2007 to fit in another disaster or two.
First came the rain and the terror ... then foot-and-mouth ... then Northern Rock ... then Donorgate ... and finally missing data
June and July
Within days of becoming Prime Minister, Gordon Brown was dealing with a major flooding crisis after unprecedented rainfall, and two failed terror plots in London and Glasgow.
August
A new outbreak of foot-and-mouth disease linked to a government laboratory in Surrey brought a new crisis. Later the country was also gripped by an outbreak of blue tongue disease.
September
Northern Rock was hit by the first run on a major bank since the Depression of the 1930s as savers queued for hours to withdraw their money after the troubled mortgage giant announced that it was being bailed out of a cash crisis by the Bank of England.
November
Property developer David Abrahams sparked the so-called Donorgate scandal after it emerged that he gifted nearly £400,000 to the Labour Party through third parties, breaking electoral laws which state that the source of such donations must be identified.
November 20
The missing data crisis broke with revelations that the personal details of 25 million people went missing after a clerk at HM Revenue and Customs breached protocol by sending two discs, each containing the entire child benefit database, to the National Audit Office through the internal mail. A series of similar cases followed.
December 11
It was revealed that two computer discs with details of more than 7000 motorists in Northern Ireland disappeared after they were sent by Parcelforce from the Northern Ireland Driver and Vehicle Agency (DVA) to the Driver and Vehicle Licensing Agency in Swansea.
Yesterday
It was revealed that personal details of more than three million driving test candidates have been lost by a private contractor in Iowa working for the Driving Standards Agency.
© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without
permission is prohibited.
Posted by: WJ, Ayrshire on 12:40am Tue 18 Dec 07
Let's not restrict it to the last six months;
the Qinetiq sale
the Iraq war
cash for honours
the Scottish elections
MOD underfunding of personal protective equipment
RAF planes so old and underfunded they are falling out of the sky
the European referendum that never was
the election that never was
reneging on an independently agreed police pay review
Let's face it - the Labour party can't even act corruptly with any degree of competence!
Let's not restrict it to the last six months;
the Qinetiq sale
the Iraq war
cash for honours
the Scottish elections
MOD underfunding of personal protective equipment
RAF planes so old and underfunded they are falling out of the sky
the European referendum that never was
the election that never was
reneging on an independently agreed police pay review
Let's face it - the Labour party can't even act corruptly with any degree of competence!
Posted by: WJ, Ayrshire on 12:46am Tue 18 Dec 07
How could I forget the missing cocaine and passports also?
How could I forget the missing cocaine and passports also?
Posted by: martin, dundee on 1:59am Tue 18 Dec 07
Labour in turmoil and the Tories at their highest poll rating since Thatchers hey-day.
Brown has not got long to go.His cabinet colleagues must soon realise he is no Tony Blair and sense the fact that he cannot win the next election.
When that happens he will be told to go.Likewise Wendy Alexander in Scotland.
Bye bye Labour.....
Labour in turmoil and the Tories at their highest poll rating since Thatchers hey-day.
Brown has not got long to go.His cabinet colleagues must soon realise he is no Tony Blair and sense the fact that he cannot win the next election.
When that happens he will be told to go.Likewise Wendy Alexander in Scotland.
Bye bye Labour.....
Posted by: BrianW, Renfrew on 4:45am Tue 18 Dec 07
I think it's pretty clear that GB is being knobbled by his old Etonian civil service and whitehall big-wigs who dont see him as being "the proper kind" to be Prime Minister. All these sudden blunders , leaks and bad press coverage giving the impression of a government out of control. He doesnt stand a chance , I'm sure Cameron will be a shoe in at the next election unless Labour can convince Hilary Benn or someone with the right accent to step in to the breach.
I think it's pretty clear that GB is being knobbled by his old Etonian civil service and whitehall big-wigs who dont see him as being "the proper kind" to be Prime Minister. All these sudden blunders , leaks and bad press coverage giving the impression of a government out of control. He doesnt stand a chance , I'm sure Cameron will be a shoe in at the next election unless Labour can convince Hilary Benn or someone with the right accent to step in to the breach.
Posted by: donald, glasgow on 6:24am Tue 18 Dec 07
Call in Scotland Yard. It was named after all the Scottish traitors and placemen who followed Jamie The Saxt doon tae the London Court.
Call in Scotland Yard. It was named after all the Scottish traitors and placemen who followed Jamie The Saxt doon tae the London Court.
Posted by: Neil, Aberdeenshire on 6:57am Tue 18 Dec 07
Brian W,
[quote]giving the impression of a government out of control[/quote]
It's not an [italic]impression[/italic] , the government [italic]is[/italic] out of control.
Brian W,
giving the impression of a government out of control
It's not an
impression , the government
is out of control.
Posted by: R MacLeod, Glasgow on 8:10am Tue 18 Dec 07
Stuff Broon it is making this my best ever Christmas !!!
Stuff Broon it is making this my best ever Christmas !!!
Posted by: BM, Glasgow on 8:30am Tue 18 Dec 07
Brown is no worse than Blair, but lack's Ton's teflon coating.
Brown is no worse than Blair, but lack's Ton's teflon coating.
Posted by: maximus, aberdeen on 9:47am Tue 18 Dec 07
half of this stuff was done when TB was in charge..looks like the Teflon coated one escaped at the right time, leaving his mate to hold the baby. Sometimes you get what you wish for and then it turns to crap
half of this stuff was done when TB was in charge..looks like the Teflon coated one escaped at the right time, leaving his mate to hold the baby. Sometimes you get what you wish for and then it turns to crap
Posted by: BrianW, Renfrew on 10:08am Tue 18 Dec 07
[quote][bold]Neil[/bold] wrote:
Brian W, [quote]giving the impression of a government out of control[/quote] It's not an [italic]impression[/italic] , the government [italic]is[/italic] out of control.[/quote] agreed , but this hasnt just happened in the last few months.
How much of the mess is specifically down to Broon and how much of it is a result of the way his predicessor ran the country and the Labour party and more importantly had the Press in his pocket. Can Broon really be blamed for heavy rainfall , failed terror attacks and a contained outbreak of foot n mouth ?
The difference is the London press are putting the blame on Broon cos they dont like him because he's Scottish, as with TB they were so far up his ar_se they could see the blue interior !!!
Neil wrote:
Brian W, giving the impression of a government out of control
It's not an impression , the government is out of control.
agreed , but this hasnt just happened in the last few months.
How much of the mess is specifically down to Broon and how much of it is a result of the way his predicessor ran the country and the Labour party and more importantly had the Press in his pocket. Can Broon really be blamed for heavy rainfall , failed terror attacks and a contained outbreak of foot n mouth ?
The difference is the London press are putting the blame on Broon cos they dont like him because he's Scottish, as with TB they were so far up his ar_se they could see the blue interior !!!
Posted by: R MacLeod, Glasgow on 10:26am Tue 18 Dec 07
Who cares the reason or with whom the blame lies .
the bottom line is this the Labour party is ,and always has been corrupt and oblivious to the electorate.
They deserve everything they get especially Brown , The Alexander sisters , Darling and Browne ,only wish that little turd Wilson was still around would love to see his seat fall
Who cares the reason or with whom the blame lies .
the bottom line is this the Labour party is ,and always has been corrupt and oblivious to the electorate.
They deserve everything they get especially Brown , The Alexander sisters , Darling and Browne ,only wish that little turd Wilson was still around would love to see his seat fall
Posted by: Charles McGrory, Glasgow on 10:48am Tue 18 Dec 07
Le Broon driven out of office by London Elite for gross incompetence in maintaining the corrupt status quo.
Nu Liebour implodes.
DeCameroon wins Middle England while giving English Votes for England and tries to reassert London Elite Central Control over the whole UK and antagonises the Scots.
Independence becomes the Default Option.
The Time is coming...
Le Broon driven out of office by London Elite for gross incompetence in maintaining the corrupt status quo.
Nu Liebour implodes.
DeCameroon wins Middle England while giving English Votes for England and tries to reassert London Elite Central Control over the whole UK and antagonises the Scots.
Independence becomes the Default Option.
The Time is coming...
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 10:56am Tue 18 Dec 07
Couldn't agree more R MacLeod - This is NEW LABOUR in terminal decline. They are not only a collective of vile, evil, scumbags, but they are simply not up to the job.
I share your feelings about that turd Brian - a firey leftie according to bbc years ago - Wilson. But there are still a shed load of the vermin
whose removal will, I am sure, delight us all. His Highness, The Baron Geordie Von Der Foulkes, Herr Eric von der Joyce to name but two! Its time that the New Labour snouts were removed from the
trough!!
Couldn't agree more R MacLeod - This is NEW LABOUR in terminal decline. They are not only a collective of vile, evil, scumbags, but they are simply not up to the job.
I share your feelings about that turd Brian - a firey leftie according to bbc years ago - Wilson. But there are still a shed load of the vermin
whose removal will, I am sure, delight us all. His Highness, The Baron Geordie Von Der Foulkes, Herr Eric von der Joyce to name but two! Its time that the New Labour snouts were removed from the
trough!!
Posted by: Hamish, Argyll on 10:59am Tue 18 Dec 07
Hey Broon!
Gonnae no stop daein that!
Hey Broon!
Gonnae no stop daein that!
Posted by: preddo53, leeds on 12:51pm Tue 18 Dec 07
You forgot to mention that Brooooooon 's just given the sodding country away to the French and Germans without a mandate, and how many people voted for him, 12,000.
You forgot to mention that Brooooooon 's just given the sodding country away to the French and Germans without a mandate, and how many people voted for him, 12,000.
Posted by: dws on 1:15pm Tue 18 Dec 07
Gordon Brown's political career is dead in the water.
It's just that no-one's told him yet.
Gordon Brown's political career is dead in the water.
It's just that no-one's told him yet.
Posted by: CJM, west lothian on 1:27pm Tue 18 Dec 07
Northern Rock now guaranteed one hundred billion pounds of tax payers money ,but not one penny for the people robbed by Fairpak .
If you have money you will be protected if not bu**er off .
Whatever happened to the donation grabbing Ms. Wendy Alexander is she still being escorted around Scotland by labour party heavies ?.
Northern Rock now guaranteed one hundred billion pounds of tax payers money ,but not one penny for the people robbed by Fairpak .
If you have money you will be protected if not bu**er off .
Whatever happened to the donation grabbing Ms. Wendy Alexander is she still being escorted around Scotland by labour party heavies ?.
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 1:59pm Tue 18 Dec 07
[quote][bold]preddo53[/bold] wrote:
You forgot to mention that Brooooooon 's just given the sodding country away to the French and Germans without a mandate, and how many people voted for him, 12,000. [/quote] Very interesting point preddo53. It would be interesting to go around his constituemcy to find any who will ADMIT to voting for him.
preddo53 wrote:
You forgot to mention that Brooooooon 's just given the sodding country away to the French and Germans without a mandate, and how many people voted for him, 12,000.
Very interesting point preddo53. It would be interesting to go around his constituemcy to find any who will ADMIT to voting for him.
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 2:02pm Tue 18 Dec 07
For an insight to Brown's past and character, read this ...
http://www.gu
ardian.co.uk/co
mment/stor
y/0,,2227340,00.h
tml
For an insight to Brown's past and character, read this ...
http://www.gu
ardian.co.uk/co
mment/stor
y/0,,2227340,00.h
tml
Posted by: pehman, sussex on 3:43pm Tue 18 Dec 07
WJ @ 12;40,
You missed out reneging on the compensation for Scottish farmers after foot and mouth.
And Brian W, Renfrew, thats something that definetly can be placed at maggie's door.
But come May 1st 2008 the local elections will take place in England and Wales. By the end of May liebour will have a new leadership election in full swing with maggie dithering about going saying it's all someone elses fault.
WJ @ 12;40,
You missed out reneging on the compensation for Scottish farmers after foot and mouth.
And Brian W, Renfrew, thats something that definetly can be placed at maggie's door.
But come May 1st 2008 the local elections will take place in England and Wales. By the end of May liebour will have a new leadership election in full swing with maggie dithering about going saying it's all someone elses fault.
Posted by: iain morrison, nairn on 4:09pm Tue 18 Dec 07
What can you say it's beyond satire
What can you say it's beyond satire
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 6:12pm Tue 18 Dec 07
[quote][bold]pehman[/bold] wrote:
WJ @ 12;40, You missed out reneging on the compensation for Scottish farmers after foot and mouth. And Brian W, Renfrew, thats something that definetly can be placed at maggie's door. But come May 1st 2008 the local elections will take place in England and Wales. By the end of May liebour will have a new leadership election in full swing with maggie dithering about going saying it's all someone elses fault. [/quote] Brown's replacements are already squaring up to each other ... this from the online edition of the Italian newspaper, La Stampa on 3rd December by Richard Newbury. A piece entitled "The Battle for after-Brown". He goes on about Balls undermining Miliband.
[quote]Brown has never won an election. He avoided contesting the Party leadership in 1992 against his political “father” John Smith [who like his predecessor Neil Kinnock preferred Blair] and in the 1994 Granita Pact Tony Blair was generous to Brown since the polls showed Blair 47%, Prescott 15% and Gordon Brown trailing at 11% for the Party Leadership. In three attempted coups in March, May and September 2005 and indeed almost annually since 1997, Brown has, in his closest adviser Ed Balls’ words, “bottled it”. Balls screamed at him “Gordon is a moron” as he did again over Brown’s “bottling out” of an Election he would have won on 1 November this year, which would have destroyed David Cameron in the process.[/quote]
pehman wrote:
WJ @ 12;40, You missed out reneging on the compensation for Scottish farmers after foot and mouth. And Brian W, Renfrew, thats something that definetly can be placed at maggie's door. But come May 1st 2008 the local elections will take place in England and Wales. By the end of May liebour will have a new leadership election in full swing with maggie dithering about going saying it's all someone elses fault.
Brown's replacements are already squaring up to each other ... this from the online edition of the Italian newspaper, La Stampa on 3rd December by Richard Newbury. A piece entitled "The Battle for after-Brown". He goes on about Balls undermining Miliband.
Brown has never won an election. He avoided contesting the Party leadership in 1992 against his political “father” John Smith and in the 1994 Granita Pact Tony Blair was generous to Brown since the polls showed Blair 47%, Prescott 15% and Gordon Brown trailing at 11% for the Party Leadership. In three attempted coups in March, May and September 2005 and indeed almost annually since 1997, Brown has, in his closest adviser Ed Balls’ words, “bottled it”. Balls screamed at him “Gordon is a moron” as he did again over Brown’s “bottling out” of an Election he would have won on 1 November this year, which would have destroyed David Cameron in the process.
Posted by: dws on 6:58pm Tue 18 Dec 07
Gordon Brown, nearing the end.
When he's down, they're booting his rear end,
Millibands there, thinks he's a clown,
Always a frown, with Gordon Brown.
With apologies to the Stranglers. ;-)
Gordon Brown, nearing the end.
When he's down, they're booting his rear end,
Millibands there, thinks he's a clown,
Always a frown, with Gordon Brown.
With apologies to the Stranglers. ;-)
Posted by: Duns Scotus, The Borders on 8:19pm Tue 18 Dec 07
BREAKING NEWS:
[bold]Wendy Alexander found busking in Tokyo.[/bold]
http://w
ww.reut
ers.com/new
s/video?videoId=72
177&newsChan
nel=scienceNews
BREAKING NEWS:
Wendy Alexander found busking in Tokyo.
http://w
ww.reut
ers.com/new
s/video?videoId=72
177&newsChan
nel=scienceNews
Posted by: Gr8 on 10:25pm Tue 18 Dec 07
I bet you Brown is kicking himself that he didn't leave Blair in power for the last 7 months so he could now stride in and "save" the party after all of these horrors had already come to fruition. Well Mr Brown as they say... be careful what you wish for, you might just get it!
The hunger you have shown and impatience in ousting the old leader to take the reigns yourself may have actually completely backfired, now you will be remembered for all these troubles and not him, his personality and quick wit may have softened the blows but your clunking fist and ever droopier eyes cannot. Now to remind you of another saying... patience is a virtue. One you evidently don't have and you will pay the price for it in the history books I feel...
I bet you Brown is kicking himself that he didn't leave Blair in power for the last 7 months so he could now stride in and "save" the party after all of these horrors had already come to fruition. Well Mr Brown as they say... be careful what you wish for, you might just get it!
The hunger you have shown and impatience in ousting the old leader to take the reigns yourself may have actually completely backfired, now you will be remembered for all these troubles and not him, his personality and quick wit may have softened the blows but your clunking fist and ever droopier eyes cannot. Now to remind you of another saying... patience is a virtue. One you evidently don't have and you will pay the price for it in the history books I feel...
Posted by: TheWiseOne, Glasgow on 9:53am Thu 20 Dec 07
From Stalin to Mr Bean to a has-been. The man totally lacks charm, personality and sincerity and must be a PR's nightmare.
I suspect people like Jack Straw and Harriet harman are relishing what is happening and are secretly planning their move for the PM post when it inevitably becomes vacant in the NEAR future. The only real question is will he go voluntarily or will he be pushed.
From Stalin to Mr Bean to a has-been. The man totally lacks charm, personality and sincerity and must be a PR's nightmare.
I suspect people like Jack Straw and Harriet harman are relishing what is happening and are secretly planning their move for the PM post when it inevitably becomes vacant in the NEAR future. The only real question is will he go voluntarily or will he be pushed.
Posted by: tpaz, herts on 12:03am Tue 25 Dec 07
put simply labour built on lies and deceit are finished they now have the audacity to ask for above inflation pay increase when the the rest of us are having to cut back, as well as the police. they ought to be ashamed of themselves instead we get ponces like steve pound who does nothing but preen himself on tv talking rubbish this man does nothing for politics many people even wander how he got his seat. and they wander why people dont vote!!
put simply labour built on lies and deceit are finished they now have the audacity to ask for above inflation pay increase when the the rest of us are having to cut back, as well as the police. they ought to be ashamed of themselves instead we get ponces like steve pound who does nothing but preen himself on tv talking rubbish this man does nothing for politics many people even wander how he got his seat. and they wander why people dont vote!!
