logo
   Web Issue 3186 July 6 2008   
spacer




Time for questions thanks to the non-resident tax-averse supporter
IAN BELLNovember 30 2007

By all accounts, Paul Green is a traditional, long-standing, property-developing, racehorse-owning, tax-averse, non-resident, dyed-in-the-wool Scottish Labour supporter. Thanks to him, the people's flag - mauve when last sighted - is flying high. Though not, sadly, on Jersey.

We owe Mr Green a debt, nevertheless (but not in the way you think). Because of him, we can ask profound questions.

Questions such as: couldn't Wendy Alexander find anyone actually living in Scotland who was keen to funnel a whole £950 to her non-campaign for her non-election to the Labour leadership?

Questions such as: can't Scotland, land of Buttons, Peanuts, and Small Change, ever manage a proper scandal? Down south, careers are at stake over a not-inconsiderable £650,000 in donations. Here we do taxi chits, wee offices, and this: the equivalent of beer money and a couple of season tickets.

Sorry, my mistake. We also do opposition transport spokespersons, Charlie Gordon in this instance, falling under the political bus after mooching cash from Mr Green in a manner known technically as non-legal. They'll be calling it a personal tragedy next.

Still, it's all very, very serious. The judgment of Ms Alexander, patron saint of suffering spin doctors, has been called into question. Quite right, too.

Call me old-fashioned, but shouldn't she know the difference between First Minister's Questions and a 150-word personal statement that had nothing whatever to do with the topic at hand?

Bizarre wasn't the word for it. No, on second thoughts, bizarre was exactly the word. To visitors in the gallery from Ukraine and Gabon, it must have seemed as though the Labour leader was saying: "Hang on. I'll get around to domestic abuse after I've dealt with the crucial issue of my latest embarrassment."

To be fair, Alex Salmond started it. Labour's difficulty is his opportunity, and all that. The Presiding Officer can meanwhile explain why he let Ms Alexander plough on ("Question" is the usual blunt reminder to the wandering orator). The impression remained that domestic brutality was not the most pressing topic of the day.

Mr Salmond poked his rivals with a stick by contrasting the alleged optimism "still sweeping the nation" and the "mood of despondency" afflicting Labour in London. Ms Alexander ignored that and described an increase in violence in the home.

The First Minister tried again, congratulating his opponent "on her success in dominating the news agenda in Scotland". Labour's benches seethed, a neat trick when your gas is at a peep. Strangely, Ms Alexander grinned.

"I will return to the issue of domestic violence in a moment," she warned. In fact, many moments passed while she said - which is to say read - her piece.

The quick version: the SNP didn't file returns to the Electoral Commission when they held leadership elections, so they can lay off.

Strange logic. Either Ms Alexander was saying that her party is only as bad as the other lot, or she was inviting us to conclude that if Labour had done nothing wrong, neither had the SNP.

The trouble was, as Labour's tactical geniuses may have noticed, the Nationalists had no donations to declare. And Labour had done wrong.

It fell to Annabel Goldie to rescue the situation with a serious point. Checks are made into the criminal histories, if any, of those seeking to work with children and the vulnerable, she noted, but only if applicants are from the UK. Applicants from overseas face little or no scrutiny.

Ms Goldie found this deeply troubling. Ms Goldie was right. Mr Salmond promised to look into the matter. Sanity was restored, briefly. All together: How much is that Labour Party in the window?


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: John J. Sheridan, Z'ha'dum on 12:12am Fri 30 Nov 07
I can almost taste the distaste Ian.

I like the flavour.
Posted by: Scunnert, Travelling in Nihlon on 12:47am Fri 30 Nov 07
Once again, a fine article from Mr. Bell. Wee Wendy is surely for the chop.
Posted by: Alejandro Portero, Madrid usually - anywhere but Scotland on 1:41am Fri 30 Nov 07
"the SNP didn't file returns to the Electoral Commission when they held leadership elections"

Whit? Why ever not? Well, I assume they'll be doing that first thing in the morning then - just to make sure they have nothing to hide.

They will, won't they?
Posted by: doonhamer on 2:16am Fri 30 Nov 07
Alejandro Portero wrote:
"the SNP didn't file returns to the Electoral Commission when they held leadership elections" Whit? Why ever not? Well, I assume they'll be doing that first thing in the morning then - just to make sure they have nothing to hide. They will, won't they?
No, they won't because as the story indicates, they did not raise any donations. No donations means you have nothing to report. A small point so obviously lost on Labour Parody members and Wailing Wendy as she sought to blame others.
Posted by: Vronsky, Svotland on 8:15am Fri 30 Nov 07
"They'll be calling it a personal tragedy next."

Yes. And in the Herald, too - see Gerry Braiden's little eulogy to the saintly Charlie. Charlie was only trying to do good, you see. Corrupt alliance with Paul Green? Nah, that Court of Session ruling was overturned. He already has a splendid legacy in all those shopping malls, and the billion pound money sinks called PFI schemes.
Posted by: John Leven, Leven Fife on 11:37am Fri 30 Nov 07
Ian

I am confused about this. One party leader resigned over a few quid of taxi fares. One other one is mixed up in illegal acts (her campaign her responsibility) Why is the Scottish media not demanding her resignation. Are they all secret nationalists who want her to stay since she is doing a great job making the SNP look even better every day.

She also learned from Broon,disappearing again, she did not even have the guts to attend her own press conference. Hope the press hound her about this if she turns up today to deliver Broons address to the colonies.
Posted by: Scotsman, Edinburgh on 2:50pm Fri 30 Nov 07
Hurray for Ian Bell. Meanwhile, another Herald journo shows a more typical Herald side by leaving to join the sinking ship that is HMS Darling:

http://www.guardian.
co.uk/media/2007/nov
/30/pressandpublishi
ng.newsquest
Posted by: Alejandro Portero, Madrid on 5:51pm Fri 30 Nov 07
doonhamer wrote:
Alejandro Portero wrote:
"the SNP didn't file returns to the Electoral Commission when they held leadership elections" Whit? Why ever not? Well, I assume they'll be doing that first thing in the morning then - just to make sure they have nothing to hide. They will, won't they?
No, they won't because as the story indicates, they did not raise any donations. No donations means you have nothing to report. A small point so obviously lost on Labour Parody members and Wailing Wendy as she sought to blame others.
So who paid for all the leaflets, the meetings, transport, accommodation, etc. Does 'no donations' mean it was all just slipped into Eck's back pocket.

Elections cost money. Someone somewhere had to pony up. Why is it all such a big secret if there's nothing to hide.

Posted by: Vronsky, Scotland on 6:17pm Fri 30 Nov 07
Hola Alejandro,

żEres tonto? Eck - mola un pegote - żno es verdad?
Posted by: wullie on 8:32pm Fri 30 Nov 07
Rotten to the core - and the party of sleaze. There is no other conclusion to be drawn.

Bung bung and more bung. Line your pockets and fill your boots - thats the way and don't bother about the small people. New Labour the party of fraud, fraud and mor fraud.

Better have an investigation, can't speak, lets get get it kicked into the long grass. That's what Wendy said today.

And if you think we did wrong - of course not. We only thake bungs in good faith!

Ya boo suckers there ain't anything you can do about it. Pay tour taxes and shut up.
Posted by: Wassissname, Thingummyjig on 9:05pm Fri 30 Nov 07
wullie wrote:
Rotten to the core - and the party of sleaze. There is no other conclusion to be drawn. Bung bung and more bung. Line your pockets and fill your boots - thats the way and don't bother about the small people. New Labour the party of fraud, fraud and mor fraud. Better have an investigation, can't speak, lets get get it kicked into the long grass. That's what Wendy said today. And if you think we did wrong - of course not. We only thake bungs in good faith! Ya boo suckers there ain't anything you can do about it. Pay tour taxes and shut up.
WULLIE..............
.......fae Aiberdeen???
Don't try yer wee bout o' decency wi' us........yer Wullie fae Aberdeen an' ah've jist sent a wee donation aff tae the Madrid polis for a' their guid work last night...............
...pity yer no' in Europe a bit longer.............w
e coulda asked some ithir continental polis tae hae a wee reception fur ye, .....plus some digs (in every sense o' the word) .
Posted by: Guru Gordon, US on 2:15am Sat 1 Dec 07
Alejandro Portero wrote:

So who paid for all the leaflets, the meetings, transport, accommodation, etc. Does 'no donations' mean it was all just slipped into Eck's back pocket. Elections cost money. Someone somewhere had to pony up. Why is it all such a big secret if there's nothing to hide?

Alejandro, I don't want to rain on your parade, but did it never for one second cross that mind of yours that perhaps they paid for these expenses out of their own pockets. Wow, what a concept? Integrity in politics. These new guys could go far with such revolutionary thinking!
Posted by: You know it makes sense on 11:08am Sat 1 Dec 07
Want to read how Gordon Brown responded to tough questions on the donations row currently engulfing the Labour Party?
If yes, don't bother visiting the official Downing Street website.

Civil servants have removed all mention at this week's PM press conference of David Abrahams, Jon Mendelsohn and other players in this complex drama


Ho, ho, ho ho, - its like the Nazi's denying the past - but hey that is what you do when you abuse power and are above the law
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:




spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use