
Scotland’s new politics begin with some gentle persuasion
Alex Salmond would have preferred the 100-day programme he had set out on the election campaign trail: an action-packed agenda for new laws, more spending, challenges to Westminster power and setting the independence ball rolling.
But the start to his administration was less a time for bold announcements than one for gentle persuasion. All his intentions as First Minister involved appealing for opposition support, and flattering opponents as he adopted their ideas.
"Scotland's new politics starts now," he said. Lacking a majority, his priorities would be a first draft and not a final position.
He would not be dogmatic or intransigent, but he challenged the opposition to be open to persuasion on what he is trying to achieve.
Much of the speech was dedicated to the economy, energy and the environment. This was partly to respond to the Westminster white paper on energy set out yesterday, confident he has enough support to block new nuclear power plants.
On the economy, he promised small businesses rates reductions, citing the need to help bring high streets back to life, with the money required to finance the cuts being identified this calendar year.
He promised to set up an independent Council of Economic Advisers, an idea borrowed from Washington DC, and he welcomed Green advice to include an environment expert on it.
There was only a brief mention of his commitment to share the benefits of econ-omic growth among all Scots.
Taking questions for the first time, he confirmed plans to reform Scottish Enterprise, bringing tourism into its more streamlined role, and handing local economic development to councils.
| ‘This is not a time to be timid ... but a time for Scotland to find its voice’ | |
|
On plans to abolish Forth and Tay bridge tolls, he refused to say how he would handle the estimated 20% increase in traffic that could generate, and appealed to Labour and LibDem MSPs in Fife to split from their parties' position and back his bill. Labour later made clear that it would not oppose toll abolition, which means it should sail through.
The economy will be the first in a series of Holyrood debates before its summer recess, drawing ideas from opponents and building consensus across public health, crime and education.
Mr Salmond had nothing to say about them, but he did pledge his independence cause will be pursued outside the Holyrood debating chamber, implicitly acknowledging it cannot be won inside it.
A "national conversation" is his new way to build the case and try to exert public pressure on the majority of MSPs who are opposed.
There was little mention of the much-hyped battles with Westminster. Nuclear power
is already acknowledged in London as facing a veto at Holyrood.
Only on Europe was there the first hint of a battle with Whitehall, where ministers jealously guard access to Brussels power. There is a "huge cultural challenge" for Scotland to be more outward-looking and more directly engaged with the world, said the First Minister, and it would be "a profound failure of leadership" not to assist that.
"We see, in the European Union, immense opportunity to influence the debate in the Scottish interest, whether that be on energy or on farming, fishing or ferries," he told MSPs. "This is not a time to be timid in an increasingly global world, but rather a time for Scotland to find its voice".
List of priorities
National conversation about
independence, appealing to the people over MSPs' heads.
Overarching aim of faster and more sustainable
economic growth.
Setting up Council of Economic Advisers for independent advice.
Reduce rates for small businesses, with funding identified this calendar year.
A bill to abolish tolls on the Forth and Tay road bridges.
Announcement of Green Energy Day in the next few weeks, the point when renewables capacity exceeds nuclear.
No new nuclear power stations, but support for clean coal and carbon capture technology.
Climate Change Bill, setting annual emission cuts targets.
Support for Tory ideas on increased police numbers and drug treatment.
Support for Labour on raising the smoking age and clamping down on alcohol abuse.
Promise of "the most outward-looking government Scotland has ever had", influencing debate in EU.
Debates on five key areas over coming weeks.
Less legislation. Parliament should be less intrusive and less interventionist.
© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without
permission is prohibited.
Posted by: Argentocoxus, Caledonia on 10:43pm Wed 23 May 07
Thank goodness the relentless press negativity of pre-3rd May has subsided as Labour come to terms with life in opposition after half a century. I sense a refreshing change in atitudes and confidence in Scotland. Let's not just hope it lasts, let make b****y sure it lasts.
Thank goodness the relentless press negativity of pre-3rd May has subsided as Labour come to terms with life in opposition after half a century. I sense a refreshing change in atitudes and confidence in Scotland. Let's not just hope it lasts, let make b****y sure it lasts.
Posted by: Jigger, ayr on 10:53pm Wed 23 May 07
You really think so, Argent? The Bias is alive and well and living in BBC Scotland.
I had the misfortune last Saturday to hear Derek Bateman interview 2 MSPs about the new political landscape. Who were these worthies? Only that scary shouty woman from Glasgow and the rabid Lord, Zebedee Foulkes. Both Labour, methinks.
And then tonight on Newsdrive they wheeled out that Midwinter wallah who tied himself up in contradictions in his desperation to paint the new Government in a bad light. They also had some reporter - Roderick Somebody - who couldn't bring himself to use the terms New Government or New Executive.
Seems to me if the BBC can't fulfil its remit to be impartial it's time they shut up shop!
[italic](Jeez, I feel better now.)[/italic]
You really think so, Argent? The Bias is alive and well and living in BBC Scotland.
I had the misfortune last Saturday to hear Derek Bateman interview 2 MSPs about the new political landscape. Who were these worthies? Only that scary shouty woman from Glasgow and the rabid Lord, Zebedee Foulkes. Both Labour, methinks.
And then tonight on Newsdrive they wheeled out that Midwinter wallah who tied himself up in contradictions in his desperation to paint the new Government in a bad light. They also had some reporter - Roderick Somebody - who couldn't bring himself to use the terms New Government or New Executive.
Seems to me if the BBC can't fulfil its remit to be impartial it's time they shut up shop!
(Jeez, I feel better now.) Posted by: Brian Blessed, Glasgow on 11:22pm Wed 23 May 07
Jigger - Which of the scary shouty women in Glasgow? Two to choose from:
Pauline McNeill: http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=kDdc-UshM
VQ
Margaret Curran: http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=FHbGCR6lu
tY
Looking at the tags attached to each video, no prizes for the guessing the guy/girl's thoughts on them!
Jigger - Which of the scary shouty women in Glasgow? Two to choose from:
Pauline McNeill: http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=kDdc-UshM
VQ
Margaret Curran: http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=FHbGCR6lu
tY
Looking at the tags attached to each video, no prizes for the guessing the guy/girl's thoughts on them!
Posted by: Gregor Addison, Scotland on 11:47pm Wed 23 May 07
Argentocoxus,
You must have missed this:
"proportional representation gave Germany Adolf Hitler and in Scotland to a lesser degree we've had the member for Banff and Buchan". (Ann Moffat, Labour MP for East Lothian, House of Commons, 23rd May, 2007)
http://news.bbc.co.u
k/1/hi/scotland/6685
279.stm
She tried to wriggle off the hook by saying she was referring to the voting system, not individuals; odd, then, that she chose to mention Hitler and then the member for Banff and Buchan, who we all know to be our First Minister, Alex Salmond.
If anyone is any doubt about the implications of what she said, or what she intended to be taken as her meaning, they might want to watch the following:
http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=kA771gLgw
EA
Why is it that voting for the SNP means that we have to put up with allusions to Nazis? What is it about Ann Moffat, and people like her, that makes her/them think that comparisons of this sort are either reasonable or a sensible contribution to our democracy. These kinds of analogies are so wide of the mark! I often wonder if those who make these comments realise how offensive their comments are. Perhaps they do and they just don't care!
Argentocoxus,
You must have missed this:
"proportional representation gave Germany Adolf Hitler and in Scotland to a lesser degree we've had the member for Banff and Buchan". (Ann Moffat, Labour MP for East Lothian, House of Commons, 23rd May, 2007)
http://news.bbc.co.u
k/1/hi/scotland/6685
279.stm
She tried to wriggle off the hook by saying she was referring to the voting system, not individuals; odd, then, that she chose to mention Hitler and then the member for Banff and Buchan, who we all know to be our First Minister, Alex Salmond.
If anyone is any doubt about the implications of what she said, or what she intended to be taken as her meaning, they might want to watch the following:
http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=kA771gLgw
EA
Why is it that voting for the SNP means that we have to put up with allusions to Nazis? What is it about Ann Moffat, and people like her, that makes her/them think that comparisons of this sort are either reasonable or a sensible contribution to our democracy. These kinds of analogies are so wide of the mark! I often wonder if those who make these comments realise how offensive their comments are. Perhaps they do and they just don't care!
Posted by: Alex Porter, Madrid on 12:10am Thu 24 May 07
I think this youtube footage should be shown to their constituents so that they know what they have voted in. Pauline McNeill really is a cracker.
I think this youtube footage should be shown to their constituents so that they know what they have voted in. Pauline McNeill really is a cracker.
Posted by: Iain, Edinburgh on 3:47am Thu 24 May 07
I'm ashamed to admit that Moffat is my MP, although I've never voted for her. It is just the sort of idiotic comment one would expect from a mindless Blairite loyalist who has been a cheer leader for the illegal war in Iraq. She has been notable for two things - firstly as the MP with the poorest voting record in Scotland, ans secondly as the MP with the highest expenses claim in the whole of the UK. A local party member tells me that rage at the 10.1 % swing from Labour to the Scottish National Party in East Lothian on the 3 rd of May and the loss of control of East Lothian Council to an SNP/Liberal Democrat administration culminated in Moffat soiling herself in the House of Commons.
I'm ashamed to admit that Moffat is my MP, although I've never voted for her. It is just the sort of idiotic comment one would expect from a mindless Blairite loyalist who has been a cheer leader for the illegal war in Iraq. She has been notable for two things - firstly as the MP with the poorest voting record in Scotland, ans secondly as the MP with the highest expenses claim in the whole of the UK. A local party member tells me that rage at the 10.1 % swing from Labour to the Scottish National Party in East Lothian on the 3 rd of May and the loss of control of East Lothian Council to an SNP/Liberal Democrat administration culminated in Moffat soiling herself in the House of Commons.
Posted by: MacShimmy on 5:09am Thu 24 May 07
There must be some members of the Labour party who are ashamed of both McConnell and Moffat at this moment.
There must be some members of the Labour party who are ashamed of both McConnell and Moffat at this moment.
Posted by: Macuistean, Isle of Tiree on 6:38am Thu 24 May 07
Unfortunately we still have people who think that the Labour Party supports the working people of this country. Stick a red rose on a dog turd and it would be voted into office.
Unfortunately we still have people who think that the Labour Party supports the working people of this country. Stick a red rose on a dog turd and it would be voted into office.
Posted by: donald anderson, glasgow on 6:41am Thu 24 May 07
The Nazi/fascist/Racist jibe is always worth a calp at Labour meetings. Every now and again a numpty actually believes it and make a public utterance and then show's their empty heids by trying to say "What I meant was ..."
Their loyalist supporters in the so called Brit "Left" spread the same lies. I have heard several factions in the SSP and Solidarity come the same nonsense about the SNP and members supporting Independence
.
The Nazi/fascist/Racist jibe is always worth a calp at Labour meetings. Every now and again a numpty actually believes it and make a public utterance and then show's their empty heids by trying to say "What I meant was ..."
Their loyalist supporters in the so called Brit "Left" spread the same lies. I have heard several factions in the SSP and Solidarity come the same nonsense about the SNP and members supporting Independence
.
Posted by: donald anderson, glasgow on 7:16am Thu 24 May 07
And they say "Igonarance is Bliss". Not if you are a Labour numpty looking for a pat oan the heid. Sounds as if she was talking to Loyalist, Brian Wilson.
And they say "Igonarance is Bliss". Not if you are a Labour numpty looking for a pat oan the heid. Sounds as if she was talking to Loyalist, Brian Wilson.
Posted by: Colin Chilton, Glasgow on 8:01am Thu 24 May 07
I'm in Pauline McNeils constituency and yes she is one scary woman. Funny though how I never saw her out canvassing. How I would have loved her to knock at my door so I could ask her soem tough questions. Mind you she is, like the rest of the female Labour MSP's, a total munter.
I'm in Pauline McNeils constituency and yes she is one scary woman. Funny though how I never saw her out canvassing. How I would have loved her to knock at my door so I could ask her soem tough questions. Mind you she is, like the rest of the female Labour MSP's, a total munter.
Posted by: stonehaven on 8:47am Thu 24 May 07
I for one will be complaining to Labour about Moffat's comments and demanding that she takes responsibility for them and maybe a public apology.....
I for one will be complaining to Labour about Moffat's comments and demanding that she takes responsibility for them and maybe a public apology.....
Posted by: The Petemeister, Falkirk on 9:02am Thu 24 May 07
The labour party are shown in their true colours. What they really believe in is party before the Scotland, ungracious in defeat, and sniping from the sidelines. They have managed to achieve the impossible, making the Conservatives and the Lib Dems look good. We can see where not having a mind of our own has left Scotland. Labour would rather keep us as supplicant victims who cannot flourish without UK largesse rather than let us thrive using the talents of all our people.
The labour party are shown in their true colours. What they really believe in is party before the Scotland, ungracious in defeat, and sniping from the sidelines. They have managed to achieve the impossible, making the Conservatives and the Lib Dems look good. We can see where not having a mind of our own has left Scotland. Labour would rather keep us as supplicant victims who cannot flourish without UK largesse rather than let us thrive using the talents of all our people.
Posted by: Argentocoxus, Caledonia on 9:25am Thu 24 May 07
Jigger & Gregor Addison - thanks for the link. I see some things don't change (sigh). About 30 years ago the Labour candidate for East Kilbride, Dr Maurice Miller was on this vile track. It is why the term "nat" is so popular with unionists - sounds like nazi. Often the joke is on them as most people think it is "gnat" from the black and yelloe SNP rosettes!
Sad to say, EK failed to dislodge that numpty Kerr on 3rd May and as other posters have observed, there's still a long way to go.
Jigger & Gregor Addison - thanks for the link. I see some things don't change (sigh). About 30 years ago the Labour candidate for East Kilbride, Dr Maurice Miller was on this vile track. It is why the term "nat" is so popular with unionists - sounds like nazi. Often the joke is on them as most people think it is "gnat" from the black and yelloe SNP rosettes!
Sad to say, EK failed to dislodge that numpty Kerr on 3rd May and as other posters have observed, there's still a long way to go.
Posted by: Mr Lachie Todd, Edinburgh on 9:59am Thu 24 May 07
Gallus Salmond looked and sounded as if he had been First Minister
for years! Both McConnell and Goldie appeared unable to grasp the reality of the situation? Stephen just sat gloating! In reply to Salmond's statement, McConnell and Goldie seemed unable to fully express themselves? The sooner they both go the better for the Union! In his alleged conciliatory mood, Salmond slapped down Goldie after she asked him if he intended to drop the Independence Referendum, and he will just bully this pair of has-beens and steam-roller through his party's views at every opportunity! Lachie Todd
Gallus Salmond looked and sounded as if he had been First Minister
for years! Both McConnell and Goldie appeared unable to grasp the reality of the situation? Stephen just sat gloating! In reply to Salmond's statement, McConnell and Goldie seemed unable to fully express themselves? The sooner they both go the better for the Union! In his alleged conciliatory mood, Salmond slapped down Goldie after she asked him if he intended to drop the Independence Referendum, and he will just bully this pair of has-beens and steam-roller through his party's views at every opportunity! Lachie Todd
Posted by: Mac, Dundee on 10:43am Thu 24 May 07
I see that Gordon Brown and Tony Blair are still refusing to personally congratulate Alex Salmond on becoming Scotland's First Minister. Such crass behaviour simply plays into the hands of the nationalists.
I see that Gordon Brown and Tony Blair are still refusing to personally congratulate Alex Salmond on becoming Scotland's First Minister. Such crass behaviour simply plays into the hands of the nationalists.
Posted by: Argentocoxus, Caledonia on 12:10pm Thu 24 May 07
Brown and Blair are too busy cosying up to Sarkozy of France - the new president who called the poor of Paris, "scum". Put these three right-wingers in the same cafe and they'd pass for an episode of "Allo, Allo". Moffat could have a walk on part as the [italic]Madonna with the the three big boobies.[/italic]
Brown and Blair are too busy cosying up to Sarkozy of France - the new president who called the poor of Paris, "scum". Put these three right-wingers in the same cafe and they'd pass for an episode of "Allo, Allo". Moffat could have a walk on part as the
Madonna with the the three big boobies. Posted by: Barry on 7:08pm Thu 24 May 07
Sarkozy calls criminal rioters scum and I agree with him. The new President has said he will continue to call criminal scum scum and thugs thugs and if the PC Left don't like it then tough. It's time we had someone like that in control over here.
Sarkozy calls criminal rioters scum and I agree with him. The new President has said he will continue to call criminal scum scum and thugs thugs and if the PC Left don't like it then tough. It's time we had someone like that in control over here.
Posted by: Mike Simpson, Glasgow on 12:36am Fri 25 May 07
Not a great start for wee Eck, more of a whimper than the "wind of change" we were promised, looks as if he's already back-tracking and scaling down the (dubious) SNP pre-election promises; one senses further u-turns and non-delivered commitments. Come to think of it on greater analysis of the 2007 election result, the SNP have not won this election.. if they did, they would have a majority in the Scottish Parliament. maybe some people should take cognisance of this instead of being blinded by their own hyperbole!
Not a great start for wee Eck, more of a whimper than the "wind of change" we were promised, looks as if he's already back-tracking and scaling down the (dubious) SNP pre-election promises; one senses further u-turns and non-delivered commitments. Come to think of it on greater analysis of the 2007 election result, the SNP have not won this election.. if they did, they would have a majority in the Scottish Parliament. maybe some people should take cognisance of this instead of being blinded by their own hyperbole!
Posted by: Steve McDonald, Glasgow on 12:58am Fri 25 May 07
Ann who?
Posted by: LA, Los Angeles on 12:32pm Fri 25 May 07
Mike Simpson's last words before disappearing under the waves of independence fervour were: [quote]the SNP have not won this election[/quote] so no one felt obliged to rescue him until he admitted he was in trouble.
Mike Simpson's last words before disappearing under the waves of independence fervour were:
the SNP have not won this election
so no one felt obliged to rescue him until he admitted he was in trouble.
