logo
   Web Issue 3186 July 6 2008   
spacer




Green light for airport rail link plan
ROB ROBERTSONMarch 14 2007

The controversial £610m project to provide direct rail links to Edinburgh Airport from all over Scotland was given the green light yesterday.

However, SNP politicians pledged to stop the project in its tracks if they win power in the Scottish elections in May.

Transport Minister Tavish Scott spoke in support of the Edinburgh Airport Rail Link project (Earl) and although he conceded the final cost may rise to £650m, pledged it would not spiral out of control as the construction of the Scottish Parliament had done.

However, SNP politicians said it was a waste of money and the cash would be better spent improving public transport and repairing the roads.

Mr Scott denied this and claimed the time was right to push ahead with the plan, rather than prevaricate, which was what he accused opposition politicians of doing. His comments came during the final stage debate on the Edinburgh airport rail link at the Scottish parliament, after which the plan was approved by 86 to 29 with three abstentions.

Royal Assent for the bill is likely to follow in the coming weeks. Preparatory work is expected to start later this year, with trains serving the airport by the end of 2011.

Mr Scott said: "The airport will be linked directly to 14 local authority areas with a total population of 3.2million people and 64% of the total Scottish population.

"The rail link will remove 1.7million car trips from the roads, helping to tackle the environmental and economic impacts of congestion.

"Businesses which compete in the global market such as tourism, financial services, bio and life sciences will find access easier both into and out of Scotland."

Mr Scott said that because Edinburgh Airport was predicted to grow from eight million passengers in 2004 to potentially 23 million by 2030 there was a need for a genuine public transport alternative to the car.

However, SNP transport spokesman Fergus Ewing said the project did not represent best value for taxpayers' money. He said the estimated cost of £610m was made in 2005 and that "very few" commentators now believed that it could be delivered for less than £1bn, despite Mr Scott's assurances on finance.

"The money can be better spent on other projects," said Mr Ewing. "We urgently require to improve our rail and road systems in Scotland."

Tory transport committee member David McLetchie said he was sceptical about the need for both a rail link to Edinburgh airport and a tram line, considering a good bus service was already in place.

Meanwhile, the Glasgow Airport rail link has already been given Royal Assent. Construction will start next year.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: John Hamilton, Stirling on 12:13am Thu 15 Mar 07
A *disgusting waste of Scottish taxpayers money* and a blatant attempt to socially engineer Scotland's second largest city's airport into becoming the Scottish hub.

The hopeless bias of the Edinburgh-centric Executive is there for all to see, pampering their own backyard little city at the expense of the rest of the country. It makes me sick.

Social engineering because Turnhouse airport is desperate to tap into the largest population centre in Scotland (Greater Glasgow) to prop up their little airport serving the joke 'capital'. Glasgow has two perfectly good airports of its own, it doesn't need to be connected by this overblown tunnelled link to Mickey Mouse airport.

This will only further the widespread contempt that exists towards Edinburgh in the rest of Scotland, especially the west.

Shame on the west/rest of Scotland MSPs who have allowed this to go ahead. The pretend capital does not need this rail link AND a tram line to its second rate airport. Disgusting!

Posted by: Chris Paterson, Toronto , Canada on 1:04am Thu 15 Mar 07

John Hamilton, previous message, is absolutely right on. What a waste of money and likely to turn out to be even further over-budget than the Scottish Parliament building. Special and much cheaper bus/transporters with convenient luggage drop-off/pick-up capabilities could easilly provide access to the nearby railway lines serving the North and West. Fast access into Edinburgh could also be provided in this way - if you couldn't wait on the tram. With cheap airline flights melting away as fuel prices begin to go sky-high, Scotland will be left with one more boondoggle - incurring interest charges well into the future. Is Scotland going to be known as the land of follies?
Posted by: Iain Steven, Renfrewshire, currently working Dalian, China. on 5:08am Fri 16 Mar 07
Agree to both the earlier postings. I must add this..... politically whom ever is in power come future elections, there is pressure to reduce air travel for genuine environmental reasons. There are even political noises about taxing frequent flyers. Where is making it easier and more attractive to fly, at tax payers expense, not in conflict with cutting carbon / green house gas emissions. Why cant we the people get say as to what we want.
In the US I believe they refer to actions like this as Pork Barelling.
A note to our Holyrood Politicians, make no mistake, someone will make very good political 'capitol' out of this. You have side lined many cities which need investment and support for your own backyard schemes. Only last week you turned your back on Port Glasgow and the last of the commercial shipbuilding upon which this nation owes a great past and has provided the financial bed for the present. What will history say of an airport rail link?
Posted by: Trish Niblock, Edinburgh on 8:35am Sat 17 Mar 07
In Scotland we cannot afford proper care for the elderly.

We have schools that need up-grading and a re-thing about education as our younger generations are increasingly ignorant.

We have other priorities.

Who actually considers the money in the Scottish purse and has the remit to say 'NO'

Trish Niblock Edinburgh
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:




spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use