logo
   Web Issue 3271 October 6 2008   
spacer
GP suspended for six months over suicide
HELEN PUTTICK, Health CorrespondentJuly 25 2008

A GP who gave sleeping pills to an elderly patient so she could end her life was suspended for six months and may not return to his job.

Dr Iain Kerr, from Glasgow, was yesterday told his registration to practise medicine would be temporarily withdrawn by a panel of the General Medical Council, who said it was "necessary to send a message to the medical profession that this behaviour is unacceptable".

Dr Kerr, who used to be a member of the Voluntary Euthanasia Society of Scotland, gave the retired businesswoman known as Patient A sodium amytal tablets in 1998 to allow her to kill herself.

Later, in 2005, he visited her after she took an overdose of Temazepam in a failed suicide bid and did not admit her to hospital. He then prescribed her more Temazepam and she died of intoxification from this and other drugs within a fortnight.

John Donnelly, chairman of the panel, said: "The panel is of the opinion that you allowed your views in respect of physician-assisted suicide to influence your treatment of Patient A. You made a serious misjudgment and embarked upon a potentially criminal act."

Dr Kerr's failure to make a record of why he had prescribed sodium amytal to a small number of other patients was also a factor in the panel's decision.

In reaching a judgment Mr Donnelly said the panel took into account the broad range of testimonies from colleagues, patients and their families showing Dr Kerr is held in high regard.

The views of Dr Harry Burns, chief medical officer who reviewed Dr Kerr's practices when he was director of public health for NHS Greater Glasgow, were also considered.

Dr Burns and a colleague undertook an investigation in 2004 because Dr Kerr had admitted prescribing sodium amytal so a patient could take their life, in a staff appraisal.

Dr Burns said: "Dr Wallace and I are convinced that we are not dealing with a doctor who is systematically involved in supporting assisted suicide. He seems motivated by the principles of helping his patients."

The panel said in view of the mitigating factors a suspension of six months was sufficient to "maintain public confidence in the profession, protect the public and uphold proper standards of professional conduct and behaviour".

On Wednesday, Michael Mylonas, counsel for Dr Kerr, said if a suspension was imposed the GP would be obliged to pay for locum cover if he wanted to carry on practising at the end of the period. He told the panel Dr Kerr, who is 61 and works at Williamwood Medical Centre in Clarkston, would probably tell the NHS he could not maintain that. "That will be an end of this doctor's practise," he added.

After the panel announced their determination yesterday, Dr Kerr gave a short statement outside the GMC offices in Manchester.

He said: "The Fitness to Practise Panel has carefully considered all the facts and the evidence and I am grateful to them for taking into account the exceptional and unusual circumstances advanced on my behalf.

"I am particularly grateful to family, friends, colleagues and patients for their continuing support and in particular I would like to single out for praise the staff of the Medical and Dental Defence Union of Scotland.

"The only other person I really want to thank in my name is my wife who has been a great support to me during this period."


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Alkie, NYC on 12:58am Fri 25 Jul 08
6 months, that's it?

He killed a woman. Who gave this man the right and power to break the law, use public money to prescribe deadly drugs, and kill a woman?

He should never be allowed to practice again and he should be charged as an accomplice in a murder.

He is a criminal and everything a doctor is not.
Posted by: Bryce Curdy, Lanarkshire on 6:11am Fri 25 Jul 08
Grow up Alkie. There's a complex ethical debate to be had around this and simplistic, black-and-white comments like yours add nothing to it. You'll be comparing Dr Kerr to Harold Shipman next.

The GMC's stance on assisted euthanasia (similar to your own) are not representive of those of the general public or the medical profession, although I have some sympathy for the GMC as any other position would be a regulatory nightmare. Would I be concerned if Dr Kerr was my GP or the GP of a family member or friend? Not in the slightest.
Posted by: Westhighlander, West Highlands on 7:24am Fri 25 Jul 08
Well said, Bryce. I'd rather have Dr Kerr than a great many other GPs I could think of. And the fact he's been suspended for only 6 months tells a tale as well, in terms of public/medical opinion as opposed to the GMC's public stance.
Posted by: Rab The Ranter, Ayrshire on 7:56am Fri 25 Jul 08
Alkie wrote:
6 months, that's it? He killed a woman. Who gave this man the right and power to break the law, use public money to prescribe deadly drugs, and kill a woman? He should never be allowed to practice again and he should be charged as an accomplice in a murder. He is a criminal and everything a doctor is not.
I usually attack politicians, BUT I have never seen or heard anything as vile and low as this piece of sh!te.

He/She is truely the lowest piece of scum I have ever read.

Some people (like myself :o) like to EXAGERATE to maybe encourage debate. Some subjects are TOO emotional and raw to do that with, and this is one.

This person is sick.

Posted by: Buddie, Paisley on 9:07am Fri 25 Jul 08
Well said Bryce, but I am afraid your use of big words will be wasted on Alkie. His contributions here become more unacceptable every day. I complained about one of his posts yesterday concerning the MS story and it was removed. What will it take for The Herald to remove Alkie completely from these pages?
I too would be happy to put my family in Dr Kerr's care.
Posted by: PaulM, Glasgow on 10:26am Fri 25 Jul 08
He proscribed sleeping tablets to a patient so they could commit suicide. Isn't this against the law? He is guilty of murder as far as I'm concerned.
Posted by: Bryce Curdy, Lanarkshire on 11:28am Fri 25 Jul 08
Paul - would you also regard a shopkeeper who sold an individual paracetamol who then overdosed and died as guilty of murder? If someone is adament they wish to take their own life they will do so. At least with sleeping tablets it's not an unpleasant way to leave the world.
Posted by: JC on 1:34pm Fri 25 Jul 08
Buddie wrote:
Well said Bryce, but I am afraid your use of big words will be wasted on Alkie. His contributions here become more unacceptable every day. I complained about one of his posts yesterday concerning the MS story and it was removed. What will it take for The Herald to remove Alkie completely from these pages? I too would be happy to put my family in Dr Kerr's care.
Why would you be happy to put your family in the care of someone who prescribed sleeping tablets to someone who was not suffering from a terminal illness and who and who had expressed only a hypothetical wish not tobe a burden to her family in the future, also someone who also inappropriately prescribed tranquilisers to people suffering from depression and alcoholism, conditions which could cause lack of judgement of the patient? What he did was wrong.
Posted by: Alkie, NYC on 2:21pm Fri 25 Jul 08
It is a sad indictment on Scottish culture when the heroes of the medical profession are those who murder people (euthanasia and abortion doctors) and not the doctors who perform great healings and work hard.

Killing someone is easy. Taking care of them and healing them is hard.

That is why the medical profession is a respectable one -- because what they do takes years of training and a lifetime of hard work.

Any Joe off the street can kill someone. Killing is an easy, unartful, abhorrent thing.

The medical profession was establish to preserve, sustain, and heal life. This GP is not a doctor. He gave up that title the minute he gave a woman a deadly and unnecessary concoction. He is a murderer, plain and simple. I encourage you to write to your MSPs to have criminal charges brought against that scumbag.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use