logo
   Web Issue 3239 August 29 2008   
spacer
‘Every man and woman is born equal under gun law’
IAN BRUCE, Defence CorrespondentJune 19 2008

The death of a female Intelligence Corps soldier brings the total number of UK servicewomen killed in action in Iraq and Afghanistan since 2003 to five.

She is also the first British or American woman to die as a result of hostile action in Afghanistan.

A total of 216 British male soldiers and aircrew have lost their lives to bombs, missiles or bullets in the two operational zones, with another 66 dying in accidents or from disease.

However, Britain's female fatalities in forces which include 17,600 women of all ranks across the three services and represent about 9% of the total number in uniform, are dwarfed by America's 98 female combat deaths - all in Iraq so far.

A military source yesterday told The Herald: "The surprising thing is that so few women have been killed so far, given the numbers deployed by the UK and the United States.

"Rules about barring females from combat units are meaningless when there are no front lines and every road journey in either operational theatre carries the risk of booby-traps or ambush.

"As the old soldiers' saying goes: Every man - and woman - is born equal under the 7.62mm gun law."

Despite the United States' prohibition on employing women in direct combat roles in infantry, artillery or tank battalions, most casualties have come from logistics units ambushed while transporting supplies between bases.

Female soldiers are allowed to act as convoy escorts and drivers as well as in units directing traffic.

Women now make up more than 14% of the all-volunteer US forces and 11% of the troops in the two war zones, performing a long list of occupational specialties they were not qualified for or allowed to tackle 50 years ago.

The American mortality rate for all women soldiers stands at 2% of those committed to duty in Iraq.

Most previous female casualties were nurses. Now the female dead include military police, truck drivers, intelligence analysts, helicopter pilots, medics, mechanics, media escorts and kitchen managers.

At least 13 left behind children. More than half were younger than 25.

By comparison, 16 American women were killed in action in the Second World War.

In Vietnam, one woman's life was claimed by enemy fire and just five died in the 1991 Gulf War.

The British operational death toll includes an RAF flight lieutenant, three intelligence corps soldiers and a medic.

Two others have died from self-inflicted gunshot wounds and a third in a road crash in Qatar.

Second Lieutenant Joanna Yorke Dyer, a 24-year-old Intelligence Corps trainee officer from Yeovil, and Private Eleanor Dlugosz, Royal Army Medical Corps, aged 19, from Southampton, died together when their vehicle was hit by a roadside bomb blast west of Basra on April 5, 2007.

Staff Sergeant Sharron Elliott, 34, and intelligence specialist from Ipswich, was one of four UK personnel killed in an attack on a boat patrol on the Shatt al-Arab waterway on November 12, 2006.

Flight Lieutenant Sarah-Jayne Mulvihill, aged 32, an RAF flight operations officer, was killed along with four male colleagues when their Lynx helicopter was shot down over Basra on Saturday May 6, 2006. She is the highest-ranking female casualty to date.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: me, here on 11:45pm Wed 18 Jun 08
How many Afghani women have been killed since the operation began?
Posted by: Alkie, NYC on 2:03am Thu 19 Jun 08
Every man and woman is born equal under gun law. It is the same under alcohol law.

Guns are illegal, but alcohol, the nation's deadliest killer, is still legal? Makes a lot of sense.

Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 6:28am Thu 19 Jun 08
Bombing Iraq was illegal.
Posted by: Charles McGrory, Glasgow on 9:43am Thu 19 Jun 08
Re women soldiers on front line harm's way duty. I once met an Israeli woman paratrooper. She told me that eventually all women were taken out of the front line because the male soldiers were not longer as aggressive - they were hanging back to protect their women - a natural instinct. The trained female soldiers were re-assigned to village militia duty.

It is one thing to have women soldiers in diehard battles to protect their homes or the invaded motherland but to send them 5000 miles away to modernise a totally alien culture is quite another.
Posted by: sam, greenock on 11:38am Thu 19 Jun 08
Alkie wrote:
Every man and woman is born equal under gun law. It is the same under alcohol law. Guns are illegal, but alcohol, the nation's deadliest killer, is still legal? Makes a lot of sense.
But guns are legal in the good ol' USof A, the nations deadliests killer. S o why don't you go and bore the pants off some of your yank papers, getting guns made illegal. Ersewipe
Posted by: JBlackley, Florida on 3:17pm Thu 19 Jun 08
I'm not really sure what this article is about - apart from documenting the passing of these brave women (which has already been done a number of times in this paper).

Whatever the article is meant to be, my heart goes out to the families - particularly the children - of these women and I admire the women themselves for their bravery.

I have a close female friend who is currently trying to get accepted in the Marine Corps. Articles like this are reminders of what this woman is volunteering for and of why I should cherish her friendship while I can.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use