logo
   Web Issue 3273 October 8 2008   
spacer
Trainee doctors pressured to work extra hours unpaid, says BMA
HELEN PUTTICK, Health CorrespondentMarch 31 2008

Trainee doctors in Scotland are being pressured to work extra hours without pay because of staff vacancies, the British Medical Association said today.

Across the UK almost a third of the junior doctors surveyed by the body said they were working on a rota with at least one vacancy.

Dr Alan Robertson, chair of the Scottish Junior Doctors Committee, described hospitals north of the Border where three or more staff were missing from a team.

This, he said, meant the doctors were having to work more frequent night shifts and the day crew were potentially short-handed.

Dr Robertson said: "The knock-on for patients might be an increase in waiting times for procedures or clinics running slower because the usual staff are needed to do a night shift. That will mean patients spend longer waiting.

"I do not think care will be impacted on because dealing with emergencies will always be a priority.

"But the worry is that is increasing as a problem."

According to the BMA, the situation has been caused by changes to the way junior doctors are trained to become consultants.

Under the old system, juniors were recruited to training posts twice a year. The association say people unsuccessful the first time would work as locums until the next opportunity to apply came around. Under the new system - dogged by problems when it launched last year - there is only one entry point, August.

Dr Robertson said: "The way it worked last year those who did not get a training post, left. People who did not get a job went to Australia or New Zealand. We do not have the same group sitting about."

This, and changes to immigration rules restricting employment opportunities, means fewer medical staff are available to act as locums or fill vacancies, according to the BMA. It says the pressures could lead to bullying and harassment of junior doctors.

Dr Robertson said hospitals were running the risk of breaching European working hours legislation which limits junior doctors to a 56-hour working week.

A Scottish Government spokesman said: "There are opportunities for NHS boards to advertise for and appoint junior doctors outwith the annual appointment round."

He added: "Furthermore, we are also considering the possibility of a second formal annual appointment round.

"Remuneration of junior doctors for hours worked is a matter for HR departments at individual NHS boards.

"However, there are rules in place that we would expect to be followed."


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Cynica, Eaglesham on 8:08am Mon 31 Mar 08
And one of the reasons they are not being remunerated is that it would reveal that NHS boards are not adhering to the European Working Times directive and would face punitive action.

So, in order for management to save face, the junior doctors are disadvantaged.
Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 9:18am Mon 31 Mar 08
Who wants to be treated by young doctors dead on their feet, no matter how dedicated and skilled they are. Basic health laws and working conditions should be universal.
Posted by: PeteS, Sheffield on 11:17am Mon 31 Mar 08
Who wants to be treated by any doctor who is dead on their feet, whether its a junior doctor doing extra hours or a GP who has worked over 50 hours that week.

The NHS is being degraded, from top to bottom, by this government.

The public need to be aware that the underlying reason is privitisation.
Posted by: George Laird, Glasgow on 4:42pm Mon 31 Mar 08
Dear Helen

There are no trainee doctors working in the NHS, you are either a qualified doctor or you are not.

If you mean junior doctors then say junior doctors.

Yours sincerely

George Laird
The Campaign for Human Rights at Glasgow University
Posted by: ubergeek, glasgow on 7:55pm Tue 1 Apr 08
You have a government that managed to do something quite spectacularly inept. They created a glut then a shortage of doctors within the space of a few years. Their selection policy tore down a perfectly adequate system to ensure safe delivery of healthcare and good working practices of all staff while shortages were moped up by locums. Sure it wasnt perfect, but it was infinitely better than the debacle we have now. How much money was wasted on setting up MTAS? How much was spent on replacing it? Why this isnt gettin more press ccoverage i dont know.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use