logo
   Web Issue 3149 May 17 2008   
spacer
New breed of surgeon training to save rural hospitals
Exclusive by HELEN PUTTICK, Health CorrespondentFebruary 11 2008
WARNING: Professor Neil Douglas
WARNING: Professor Neil Douglas

Surgeons and anaesthetists will be specially trained to work in remote parts of Scotland for the first time under plans to save the country's network of rural hospitals.

Uncertainty has surrounded emergency medical care in the Highlands and islands for years as health boards have struggled to fill vacancies.

Now a long-awaited report commissioned by the Scottish Government on safeguarding the future of hospitals in these scattered communities has been submitted.

It recommends new training programmes to prepare consultants for the wide-ranging demands of working in small hospitals hours from specialists in city centres.

Hiring people to jobs perhaps a year in advance and honing their skills for the exact role is also suggested. There are six rural general hospitals in Scotland, covering communities from Fort William to Orkney and serving more than 150,000 residents, as well as holidaymakers.

However, as doctors have specialised in narrower medical fields NHS managers have struggled to replace consultants who leave. This and rules on doctors' working hours have already threatened services in Fort William, Oban and Wick.

A working group was set up to examine the issues in 2005 and it is understood discussions about how to staff rural hospitals have at times been tense.

The finished report states rural general hospitals should have at least three consultant surgeons, a three-strong consultant-led anaesthetic team and three medical specialists.

It also lists the core services patients can expect to have in their nearest rural general. These include resuscitation, initial fracture management, Caesarean sections, appendix removal and diagnostic tests such as CT scanning.

David Sedgwick, consultant surgeon at Belford Hospital in Fort William, said: "What this report does is define the rural general hospital. In particular, it confirms they have the vital 24:7 consultant-led service in medicine, surgery and anaesthesia."

Programmes for teaching staff the necessary skills have already been devised.

The report says anaesthetists should have experience in a range of areas including niches such as transporting very ill adults and children and resuscitating newborn babies. Surgeons should also study a broad spectrum of medical fields including gynaecology, ophthalmology and neurosurgery.

Mr Sedgwick said: "For the first time a blueprint for training consultants and GPs has been devised so that appropriately trained doctors can be recruited to provide community and hospital health care to these communities."

Professor Neil Douglas, chairman of the Academy of Medical Royal Colleges in Scotland, which brings health professional bodies together, warned there were still issues to be addressed.

He said: "We have a major job to do to make sure people want to work in these locations. One of the things that requires quite a lot more work is not only to make sure medical students get exposed to these settings but also trainees (junior doctors), because it is less likely you will want to work in these places if you have not enjoyed working there before."

Community health care is also examined in the report. It describes GPs, who can be isolated, joining forces to arrange the kind of pro-active care which can prevent people falling ill.

A Scottish Government spokeswoman welcomed the report, saying it "presents a model of safe and sustainable services for patients living in rural areas".


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.



Posted by: Cynica, Eaglesham on 6:29am Mon 11 Feb 08
Good heavens!
Are they about to resurrect the general surgeon?
The attempt by the government to meddle with medical training has been catastrophic - we now have medical students who can break bad news to you in five different ways but struggle with anatomy and physiology, which used to be the cornerstone of their eduxcation.
I'd rather have competence than empathy, thank you!
Posted by: Wardog, Buckie on 10:42am Mon 11 Feb 08
More Good News.....
Posted by: Exiled Aussie, Banff on 11:25am Mon 11 Feb 08
Wardog wrote:
More Good News.....
Before they shout its a Tartan Tory project -"long awaited report", ie commisioned by prev administration.

This practice has operated in Greece for over twenty years - except that Drs there are COMPELLED to spend time on an outlying mainland region or on one of the numerous islands.

So Scotland catching up !
Posted by: subrosa on 11:37am Mon 11 Feb 08
Cynica I can't decide if you think this is good or bad news. My local hospital has two general surgeons and I'm not in the Highlands or islands.

I think a posting to the Highlands and islands would be super for a young doctor. Why do they have such difficulty recruiting for these areas? Do all doctors want to be in centres of excellence nowadays?
Posted by: Ian on 12:46pm Mon 11 Feb 08
subrosa wrote:
Cynica I can't decide if you think this is good or bad news. My local hospital has two general surgeons and I'm not in the Highlands or islands. I think a posting to the Highlands and islands would be super for a young doctor. Why do they have such difficulty recruiting for these areas? Do all doctors want to be in centres of excellence nowadays?
Because young doctors want a life as well as a career. Anywhere out with Inverness in the Highlands and Islands is as dull as dishwater
Posted by: Buddie, Paisley on 2:15pm Mon 11 Feb 08
"Anywhere out with Inverness in the Highlands and Islands is as dull as dishwater"
But think about all that wonderful scenery, and all the fiddle and accordion music you could ever want.
Och, surely you don't need bars and girls and other distractions when you are out there serving your community, do you?
Whateffer is the world coming to?
Posted by: fraserkelly, singapore on 6:09pm Mon 11 Feb 08
think a posting to the Highlands and islands would be super for a young doctor. Why do they have such difficulty recruiting for these areas? Do all doctors want to be in centres of excellence nowadays?

yes!
Posted by: subrosa on 9:19pm Mon 11 Feb 08
Posted by: Ian on 12:46pm today

Well I think these young people are very badly informed. The Highlands and islands may not offer posh bars, expensive clubs but life is very rich in these areas and I owe a great deal of thanks to the people of these areas for broadening my social skills and educating me in many ways back in the 70s. Delightful times and far more enjoyable than living in the capital city today.
Posted by: leesome, Glasgow on 7:15pm Tue 19 Feb 08
The highlands are just not diverse enought. Lets face some facts. If you cannot work out family values as a health care professional, and so lean to settle down. Then obviously family life is not for you. And there arn't many clubs and bars out side the big cities offering a scene to that type of profile. Making those unwanted to family practices and rightly this should be.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use