logo
   Web Issue 3240 September 7 2008   
spacer
Flashman creator, Herald writer: George MacDonald Fraser dies
MARTIN WILLIAMSJanuary 03 2008

He was the war veteran turned reporter who rose to become a Hollywood scriptwriter and best-selling novelist.

George MacDonald Fraser, creator of the much-loved Flashman series of adventure yarns, has died of cancer. He was 82.

Born in Carlisle in 1925, the son of a Scottish doctor and nursing sister, he was a pupil of Carlisle Grammar School, of which he once said: "I performed so indifferently that they decided to send me to Glasgow Academy, where my examination showing was, if anything, worse."

He once said he won "two prizes, for English and general knowledge, learned to play rugby and cricket with cunning if not enthusiasm, received a cup for throwing the cricket ball, read impressive quantities of historical fiction, and became probably the only Laertes in theatrical history to defeat Hamlet - admittedly, only at a rehearsal.

"These qualifications were not considered sufficient for entrance to the medical faculty of Glasgow University and I went into the Army, a willing conscript, in 1943."

He served with the British Army in India and Burma during Second World War, and in the Middle East after the war. His service was the basis for his humorous short stories about Private McAuslan, the "dirtiest soldier in the British Army".

After the war he became a reporter with the Carlisle Journal and married Kathleen Hetherington, a reporter from another paper.

They travelled to Canada together and after a brief period in Toronto they got jobs as reporters in Saskatchewan.

After a year they returned to England where their first son Simon was born. Fraser worked as a reporter and sub-editor on the Cumberland News before the family moved to Glasgow in 1953. His daughter, Caroline, and second son, Nicholas, were born in 1953 and 1957.

On the Glasgow Herald he worked as a sub-editor before becoming features editor and then deputy editor from 1964 till 1969. He briefly held the position of acting editor.

Fraser recalled: "I had been writing on and off since the age of five, and thanks to my wife's encouragement I persevered in the hope of becoming a novelist. My first book, Flashman, was published in 1969, and I gave up newspaper work and devoted myself to being a freelance author."

The irrepressible antihero Harry Flashman was born.

Fraser became a tax exile on the Isle of Man where he lived there for the rest of his life.

His writing skills caught the attention of Holywood and he wrote nearly 40 screenplays, some of which were made into films, including Red Sonja in 1985 , starring a young Arnold Schwarzenegger and Bridget Nielsen, and The Prince and the Pauper in 1977, which starred Oliver Reed and Raquel Welch.

But it was the Musketeer series of films that became the big money-spinner.

It started in 1972 when he wrote the screenplay for Dick Lester's The Three Musketeers, featuring a galaxy of stars. The film, and sequel The Four Musketeers, were a huge success.

In 1988, the same team hoped to repeat their seventies success with The Return of the Musketeers, but one star, Roy Kinnear, died during filming when he fell off his horse.

Some readers and critics found Flashman's 19th- century racism and sexism off-putting. But by the time the final Flashman book, Flashman on the March, appeared in 2005, the critical tide had turned in Fraser's favour.

Fraser thought Flashman's appeal was not surprising. "People like rascals, they like rogues," he said in 2006. "I was always on the side of the villain when I was a child and went to the movies."

He once wrote that he styled himself as a "sentimental Presbyterian ... firmly opposed to all party politics".

Murray Ritchie, 66, former political editor of The Herald, was a young reporter on the Dumfries Standard when he first met Fraser in the 1960s.

He said: "George Fraser went around Scotland with the other journalists to the outposts giving tuition and that's how I met him.

"In journalism, he was great in all respects. He was a great writer, great sub-editor, great layout man, great headline writer, he was just a very talented individual.

"He rose effortlessly to become deputy editor in the 1960s and when he went home at night he was writing for himself and he had this idea that he would write a sequel to Tom Brown's Schooldays and took the character Flashman and wrote the first of those novels.

"It was such an instant success that he made a lot of money. He had a choice - to bank his money or lose it to tax. So there and then he gave up his very glittering career on the Glasgow Herald.

"I do not think it pushed him away but it certainly kept him away. I do not think it had the same attraction for him."


Flashman, the anti-hero who had it all


FLASHMAN, published in 1969, introduced readers to an enduring literary anti-hero: the roguish, irrepressible Harry Flashman.

The novel imagined Flashman, the bullying schoolboy of 19th-century classic Tom Brown's School Days, by Thomas Hughes, grown up to become a soldier in the British Army. In the book and 11 sequels, Flashman fought, drank and womanised his way across the British Empire, Europe and the United States, playing a pivotal role in the century's great historical moments. A vain, cowardly rogue, Flashman nonetheless emerged from each episode covered in glory, rising to the rank of medal-garlanded brigadier-general.

Fraser was the author of screenplays including The Three Musketeers (1973), an adaptation of his novel Royal Flash (1975), and the James Bond movie Octopussy (1983).

He also wrote several works of non-fiction, including a wartime memoir, Quartered Safe Out Here, Steel Bonnets: The Story of the Anglo-Scottish Border and The Hollywood History of the World.

His final book, The Reavers, is a historical tale featuring espionage and intrigue during the reign of Elizabeth I.

In The Observer, reviewer Simon Beckett called Flashman on the March, published in 2005, "bawdy, offensive and unrepentantly entertaining."

Fraser had heavyweight literary supporters: Kingsley Amis called him "a marvellous reporter and a first-rate historical novelist," and PG Wodehouse was also a fan.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: aberdeen1, west o' Aberdeen on 2:13am Thu 3 Jan 08
What a wonderful author. Harry Flashman and Private McAuslan were, and still are, two of my favourite characters in fiction. Fraser's attention to detail, and his interweaving of Flashman's exploits into actual historical background, were simply amazing. One actually felt as though Flashy's exploits were real. Fraser's books brought a smile to me in good times and bad.

Fraser's talent is one that will be greatly missed. There were few like him. Thank you, Mr. Fraser, for your talent and sense of humour.
Posted by: Mercutio, Falkirk on 2:16am Thu 3 Jan 08
The Light's on at Signpost and alas he has now passed it.
Posted by: pete flodden on 5:23am Thu 3 Jan 08
The Steel Bonnets is a strong contender for best ever Scottish history book. Very much in the same vein as the great (and sadly also late) John Prebble.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 5:58am Thu 3 Jan 08

I always rated his books McCauslan - The Dirtiest Soldier In The Briish Army superior to his Flashman novels, based as they were on his actual experiences as an army officer in the Gordon Highlanders, inTripoli, 1946.

They are still hilarious to read, full of clever observation of the Scottish soldier abroad.

A congeneal pale-blue in politics who took refuge in the Isle of Man as a tax exile and didn't have too much to say about the UK that was printiable. Still, he deserves applause for having made a living from writing in spite of both BBC and ITV ignoring his skill and a blanket box of great stories that could have been commercially dramatised for a television series. Instead, we got It Ain'T Half Hot, Mum.
.

Posted by: Colin Rosenthal, Denmark on 7:03am Thu 3 Jan 08
Wasn't there a brief BBC Flashman series? I agree with LA about the McAuslan series. They deserve to be at least as well known as Flashman. (Fraser hinted very strongly that almost everything in them is true, in which case real life, or at least army life, really is much stranger than anything you could invent.)

It's a sad day.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 8:26am Thu 3 Jan 08


Colin wonders
Wasn't there a brief BBC Flashman series?
A Flash In the Pan, so to speak? If there was I missed it, Colin. But you might be right.
Posted by: Malcolm, Edinburgh on 9:59am Thu 3 Jan 08
Hi, there was a Flashman film, (starring Oliver Reed if I recall correctly), but I never heard of a series. I guess with CGI techniques, maybe it would be feasible to do a job on them these days.

Not sure who we could select to play Flashie though, let alone the Flashman women....

Obviously sorry to hear of the death of GMF, but appreciative of his work, and delighted he maintained such high standards throughout the series. I'm hopeful that he left a few manuscripts of his own, but I doubt we could be so lucky.
Posted by: ALASTAIR DERRICK, Dundee on 10:01am Thu 3 Jan 08
Fraser`s war memoir, "Quartered safe out here" is a stunning piece of work, and I have gifted it several times over ,to friends and students of that particular conflict.
It conveys the fear and hardship endured , but also the grit and humour of the remarkable men with whom he fought such a frightening enemy.

The book should be a first port of call for anyone wishing to gain knowledge of the war in which Fraser fought, and what it was like to be there, because he certainly gets that over better than any other author that I know of. What a piece of writing !
Posted by: Malcolm, Edinburgh on 10:06am Thu 3 Jan 08
My apologies, film had Malcolm McDowell playing Flash:

http://www.imdb.com/
title/tt0073639/

Not sure if any other books made it, will try to find out. There is a US format DVD available (just about) from Amazon.
Posted by: dws on 10:21am Thu 3 Jan 08
"The General danced at dawn" was one of the few books which had me laughing out loud. The man was a cracking writer.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 10:24am Thu 3 Jan 08
"The General danced at dawn" was one of the few books which had me laughing out loud. The man was a cracking writer.
Agreed. Fond memories of that story. Worth a read again.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 10:34am Thu 3 Jan 08

Hud oan a wee minute, sur! Whit's awe this aboot Gleska peculamentaries? Ye sayin' that fowk canne mak' oot whit Ah'm sayin'? Whit's wrang wi' the way Ah'm sayin' whit Ah'm sayin'? Sure ye kin unnerstan' me, aye, an' so kin Fletcher an' Forbes an' the boys an' the Colonel, even-
Yes, I know, McCauslan, but I'm Scottish too which makes it easier, but some people can't make it out and-
Ye mean yon Yanks?
Well ... not only the Americans ... some people in London, perhaps-
Haw, them?! Zarrafact, sur? Stuff them! Ah think it's a bliddy liberty!


Private McCauslan -
Posted by: maragdubh, lewis on 11:32am Thu 3 Jan 08
Los Angeles wrote:
Hud oan a wee minute, sur! Whit\'s awe this aboot Gleska peculamentaries? Ye sayin\' that fowk canne mak\' oot whit Ah\'m sayin\'? Whit\'s wrang wi\' the way Ah\'m sayin\' whit Ah\'m sayin\'? Sure ye kin unnerstan\' me, aye, an\' so kin Fletcher an\' Forbes an\' the boys an\' the Colonel, even- Yes, I know, McCauslan, but I\'m Scottish too which makes it easier, but some people can\'t make it out and- Ye mean yon Yanks? Well ... not only the Americans ... some people in London, perhaps- Haw, them?! Zarrafact, sur? Stuff them! Ah think it\'s a bliddy liberty! Private McCauslan -
Yes, I have had exciting journeys with flashy And my poor wife many a sleepless night with me laughing and making the bed shake I just could not put the"The general danced at dawn" down I remember soldiers like McAuslen and the Pipe Sergent etc. Im sure every regiment had them. I thought I had read all of GMF's books so thanks for the titles of two I didn't. Thank you George Macdonald Fraser.
Posted by: ebeneezer macalwham, glasgow on 11:46am Thu 3 Jan 08
The Flashman novels were suberb reading, I think I learned more history from those novels than I did at school. You find yourself looking up reference books to see if Flashy had actually been there and his work on John Brown at Harpers Ferry is so accurate it's used as a reference book in the USA. GMF will be sadly missed.
Posted by: Ronald, Glasgow on 12:14pm Thu 3 Jan 08
If only history teachers had GMF's gift for making their subject as exciting and addictive as he did. I enjoyed all the Flashman series
of books but it was with Quartered Safe Out There that his skills
really came to the fore. Arguably the finest book to emerge from the conflict, allbeit 50 years later. Superb!
Another tomb worth tracking down is his "Black Ajax", a stunning acount of the life - and death - of an eighteenth centuary prizefighter.
RIP Sir!
Posted by: Scunnert, Travelling in Nihlon on 2:56pm Thu 3 Jan 08
I just started rereading "Flashman's Lady" a couple of days ago. GMF - wherever you are- you gave me many a laugh over the years - thanks mate.
Posted by: martin, edinburgh on 3:16pm Thu 3 Jan 08
sad passing of a fine borderer who refused to accept the military-enforced division of the border people into english and scots. The Steel Bonnets was his masterwork, not the flashman nonsense. To say we will rise again implies we fell at some point. We didn't. Hail to the border nation.
Posted by: Paul O'Leary, Ottawa on 3:47pm Thu 3 Jan 08
As one who made history live, GMF ranks with Patrick O'Brian, my highest complement. His biographical accounts of his service in Burma, and with 2nd Gordans are simply outstanding. The later has given me so much pleasure that I have purchsed several copies for friends-I think however that the humour comes through best if one has had the great honour of serving, particularly in a Highland Regiment; you just can't make this sort of thing up!
Posted by: Carlung, Haddington on 4:58pm Thu 3 Jan 08
Mercutio wrote:
The Light's on at Signpost and alas he has now passed it.
One of the most intelligent books I have ever read!
Posted by: steve, usa on 5:43pm Thu 3 Jan 08
I dearly love the "Flashman" books, but I urge all those who have not read his short memoir of his service in WWII in Burma, "Quartered Safe out Here," to do so. He was a true hero, and the world is more poorer due to his passing.
Posted by: steve, use on 5:50pm Thu 3 Jan 08
The late Mr. Fraser would no doubt deservedly criticize me for saying "more poorer" in my previous posting, so I apologize to all who enjoy good writing and just note (as a former US Army officer) that his McAuslan stories, and other writings about military life, give the best and truest picture of it I have ever read.
Posted by: nick on 7:37pm Thu 3 Jan 08
GOOD BYE GMF , THANK YOU , I GUESS THATS OLD FLASHY AWAY TO GET HIS WINGS (UNDESERVED) AND GET UP TO HIS OLD MISCHEVE WITH THE ANGELS (AS USAUL).
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 7:39pm Thu 3 Jan 08


Steve - No Regrets
The late Mr. Fraser would no doubt deservedly criticize me for saying "more poorer" in my previous posting
I'm not so sure, Steve. Perhaps McCaulan would use that phrase.

"Captain, whuar more poo'er fir no openin' the bottle an' drinkin' it, afore it was thieved aff us!"
Posted by: Patrick Brogan, Washington USA on 7:56pm Thu 3 Jan 08
Murray Ritchie gets it slightly wrong talking about George Fraser's time at the Herald. George used to entertain us with his plans for Flashman (the first episode was to be set in Borneo) and his enthusiasm for James Bond. He was the outstanding younger member of the paper's staff and became acting editor when management fired Jimmy Holburn. George immediately introduced various changes and demonstrated that he would be a brilliant editor. So management passed him over, appointing a tired old hack to the job who would keep the paper dull and declining. That provoked George to go off and write 'Flashman'. It was the Herald's loss and everyone else's gain.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 8:17pm Thu 3 Jan 08


The Patrick Brogan
It was the Herald's loss and everyone else's gain.
Fascinating insight. Thanks, Patrick.

Would love to meet you one day and plan how we can dramatise the McCauslan series for television .... LA
Posted by: Ralph Strickland, Tennessee on 9:23pm Thu 3 Jan 08
I just finished the Flashman series a few days after Christmas (I finished with his book on the Taipang rebellion and the burning of the Summer palace in China).

I was hoping that he would tell us the tale of Flashman during the U.S. Civil War, but that is now not to be.

RIP Mr. Fraser, I'm sure you will be continue to be read for some time.
Posted by: jamseyboy, Stranraer on 10:45pm Thu 3 Jan 08
Heartily agree with above, especially the McCauslan appreciation society.
I believe time will only enhance Gmacs reputation and rightly so.
Posted by: Ken McCormick, Bristol, UK on 11:01pm Thu 3 Jan 08
Now we'll never know how Flashy came to fight (or avoid fighting) on both sides in the American Civil War or hear the full story of his adventures in Mexico.
Yet I learned more about 19th Century history from his adventures than I ever did at school (where it was seen as rather passe!).
In the Flashman books Fraser opened minds to some of previously- forgotten but fascinating historical episodes, put some of the more famous in a new light and created the most lovable cowardly cad in literature.
Black Ajax, the story of prizefighter Tom Molineaux, is another fascinating read that brings near-forgotten figures from the past to life.
Fraser will be missed.
Posted by: Douglas Eckhart, Edinburgh on 11:45pm Thu 3 Jan 08
Yes, this is a great loss. Flashman is one of the best literary creations ever!

Everyone wouls secretly like to get away with half the stuff Flash does!

All we can say is thank you Mr Fraser, or as Flashy would say: 'THANK E' KINDLY!'

Posted by: Ian McKellar, Wirral on 12:07am Fri 4 Jan 08
in March 1972 the BBC did a one-off Comedy Playhouse called, "The Dirtiest Soldier in the World" with (Sir) John Standing as Lt Dand McNeil. Nae bad as the they might say in the Lt's. Company Shame the rest of the McAuslan saga was never followed up.

GMF was a first rate historian- the notes in each of the Flashman papers would do any serious historian no harm while Quartered Safe out Here is an ourstanding recollection of the life the Forgotten Army. "Grand Arse" and the other Border Regiment squaddies are going to have some great stories to exchange in the next few months

Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 6:04am Fri 4 Jan 08


Thanks, Ian
in March 1972 the BBC did a one-off Comedy Playhouse called, "The Dirtiest Soldier in the World" with John Standing as Lt Dand McNeil.
A great pity they didn't follow it up.
Posted by: Gary Elliot, Glasgow on 2:02pm Fri 4 Jan 08
I have been a fan of the Flashman books since reading the first novel ( aged thirteen) in the early Seventies and still have the original paperback which I borrowed from an older cousin ( sorry Tony I will return it eventually )

A very belated thank you to the late Mr MacDonald Fraser for his fantastic books and kindling my continuing interest in History, you will be sadly missed sir
Posted by: Jeff Wood, Stirling on 11:32am Sat 5 Jan 08
Ian McKellar

Congratulations on your excellent memory. Reading these comments and tributes, I was remembering the Beeb's version of Guard at the Castle, and had forgotten they had renamed the story. I recall it was hilarious, and can still visualise the scene where John Standing's Dand discovers gleaming brass rounds in McAuslan's .303. Just before Royalty turns up.

Having once paraded at the Castle, I found the scene hit home.

Can I test you again to see if you can remember who played McAuslan, and the RSM who saved the situation? John couldn't have carried the play on his own.
Posted by: Steve Lambert, San Diego, California on 4:27pm Thu 10 Jan 08
GMF's military characters were timeless. I met many of them in the U.S. Navy in the 1960s. He had the ability to epitomize military barracks life that was uncanny.
Posted by: Ian McKellar, West Kirby, Wirral on 11:39pm Thu 10 Jan 08
I know I'm a bit late in replying but in the 1972 Comedy Playhouse, McAuslan was played by the late Freddie Earlle while the Colonel was played by the late Allan Cuthbertson.(who if you remember played Col. Hall in the Gourmet Night Episode of Fawlty Towers
I'm fairly certain it was filmed at Edinburgh Castle rather than Stirling-I was born in Stirling and lived there at that time - the Castle was being used to film Colditz
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use