logo
   Web Issue 3191 July 5 2008   
spacer
Forget Sabbath ferries... islanders want golf
DAVID ROSS, Highland CorrespondentDecember 08 2007
SWING VOTE: Members of  Stornoway Golf Club voted at their AGM to challenge the terms of their lease. Picture: Leila Angus
SWING VOTE: Members of Stornoway Golf Club voted at their AGM to challenge the terms of their lease. Picture: Leila Angus

Stornoway Golf Club is willing to go to court to win the right to play golf on a Sunday after 117 years of Sabbath observance.

Its office bearers are seeking a meeting with the Stornoway Trust, the club's landlords, to negotiate over the clause in their lease that forbids golf being played on Sunday.

At the club's recent annual general meeting a vote was taken and it is understood that only four voted for the status quo out of the 130 members who were entitled to vote, although there were a considerable number of abstentions.

An unsuccessful attempt to persuade the Stornoway Trust to be flexible over the Sunday prohibition was made two years ago. However, the club has since taken counsel's opinion and believes it has grounds to mount a legal challenge to the clause, if necessary.

It is understood that the lease, which is around 20 years old, allows for arbitration in the event of a dispute. Any such arbitration is supposed to take account of any changes in circumstances and attitudes, and ensure that the terms of the lease do not impede the enjoyment of the club.

A spokesman for the golf club's committee, who wanted to remain anonymous, told The Herald: "The issue of playing on a Sunday comes up at virtually every AGM and this year the committee action was to pursue it.

"We took legal advice and had a special general meeting on Monday where we had a decision in favour. So we will be seeking a meeting with the Stornoway Trust, but haven't actually sent the letter off yet."

Iain MacIver, factor of the Stornoway Trust, said yesterday: "We have not yet received any request from the golf club for a meeting to discuss the clause prohibiting Sunday golf. One may well be on its way, but I cannot make any comment at this stage."

If the move is successful, it will be seen as another blow to those fighting to protect the last bastion of the Hebridean Sabbath, who already fear a possible Sunday ferry service next year.

In his widely-read column in the West Highland Free Press this week, Professor Donald Macleod, principal of the Free Church College in Edinburgh, referred to golf's part in the erosion of the Sabbath, and pointed the finger at some Church of Scotland ministers. "The ministers who ran the Kirk 50 years ago have a lot to answer for.

"It was they who introduced the notion of the Brighter Sunday', telling the nation God could as well be worshipped on mountain and golf course as in church. The people took them at their word and deserted the pews in droves." He concluded: "With the Lord's Day the church rises or falls."

It remains to be seen how strongly the Stornoway Trust still adheres to this Sabbatarian tradition.

The trust came into being five years after Lord Leverhulme bought the island of Lewis for £150,000 from the Matheson family in 1918. Leverhulme had made his fortune from soap having founded Lever Brothers. In 1923, he gifted Lews Castle and 64,000 acres of land to the people of Stornoway parish. The trust was established to manage this estate for the community.

The golf club predated the trust, being established in 1890. According to the Golfing Annual of 1890-91, it was situated on the Melbost links within three miles of the Burgh of Stornoway. The site is now Stornoway Airport.

The course was requisitioned during the war. The club pursued a claim against the Air Ministry through the Land Court and in 1946 an award of £9600 was made to cover the cost of the construction of an 18-hole course and a clubhouse.

The Stornoway Trust allotted the club an area of Lews Castle's land and construction of the course was completed in October 1947.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Huttcity, New Zealand on 6:27am Sat 8 Dec 07
Ah the wee free - never was there a more miserable bunch of grumpy old men.
Posted by: TaurangaCity, New Zealand on 6:55am Sat 8 Dec 07
Sabbath ovbservance?
a) The Sabbath is Saturday
b) The commandment to observe it is the only one not repeated in the New Testament
c) In fact, Colossians 2:16,17 will tell you its observance is not necessary
Posted by: donald, glasgow on 7:06am Sat 8 Dec 07
The Wee Free got a grip by opposing the Clearances and supporting the Gaeltacht, unlike the, then, Church of Scotland and the 'Society for the Propagation of Christian Knowledge. Unfortunately the Wee Frees imposed another kind of Tyranny on the Highlands and Islands.
Posted by: John, Leicester on 8:44am Sat 8 Dec 07
I'm not surprised. I used to live up there and Lewis has barely dragged themselves out of the 19th century, never mind entering the 21st century.

Wasn't that long ago (months) that the wee frees were still denouncing catholics and calling the pope the anti-christ. That's wee free MINISTERS saying that in church mind.
Posted by: Scunnert, Travelling in Nihlon on 2:36pm Sat 8 Dec 07
These wee, wee free men should get with the programme. This is golf we're talking about here. A game of Stratedic National Importance. Get to get 'The Donald" to put a scare into these blaady Jocks..
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 3:10pm Sat 8 Dec 07
I well remember the comment of the great Scots domine, A.S. Neill.

When out knocking fence posts into the ground around his property the meeneester dropped by on his Sunday stroll.

"Working on the Sabbath, Meester Neil?"
"Aye. I am. And where is your wife?"
"Cooking the dinner. Where else?"
"Well, you can f*ck off, then, Reverend!"

And he did, in disgust and humiliation.
Posted by: King Malky MacTurph-Braign on 3:39pm Sat 8 Dec 07
A compromise?

Golf okay on a Sunday as long as there are nae ferries?

Would that be a Wee Free Ferry?

Ferry Good MacBraign.
Posted by: David, Away on 4:23pm Sat 8 Dec 07
I vote we appoint Wee Gwendolyn Alexander to the post of Scottish UN delegate to Lewis.

On a serious note, I've only ever been in one community which took Sunday's off (it was in the Carribean of all places, they were all Methodists, I think..).
I reflect that it was certainly one of the most peaceful Sunday's I have ever spent....maybe we should be bringing the idea of rest once a week *back* into our hell-bent-for-leathe
r 21st century lives....

PS - the Pope isn't the Anti-Christ, he's the False Prophet and Rome is Babylon...when you see Rome cut a deal with a One World Government you know this age is nearly up......(Until I see a one world government, I'm not quitting my job.....)...Oh, and since the False Prophet also has to be at least half-Jewish by descent, unless they are going to make that Cardinal from southern France the next Pope....(and the current one looks pretty healthy for an old guy)...
Posted by: Scunnert, Travelling in Nihlon on 4:47pm Sat 8 Dec 07
King Malky MacTurph-Braign wrote:
A compromise?

Golf okay on a Sunday as long as there are nae ferries?

Would that be a Wee Free Ferry?

Ferry Good MacBraign.
A ferry interesting suggestion. Ferry fair for the island folk. Foreby all the freewheeling feibilit from Follyrood find fault forenent and we sair fall foul of foreign freemasons from far away in fair Americay .

A work in progress!
Posted by: Hugh Bishop, Illinois, USA on 8:12pm Sun 9 Dec 07
As a child I remember many miserable, boring Sundays on the Isle of Lewis as a child courtesy of the Wee Free.

The Wee Free is entitled to its views, and its members can act as they wish. If they wish to be hard core sabbatarians themselves - fine nobody is stopping them.

But, they do not have the right to foist their gloomy, joyless, authoritarian, medieval world view on others.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use