logo
   Web Issue 3203 July 19 2008   
spacer
Pupils ‘victimised by staff who claim dyslexia doesn’t exist’
JULIA HORTONOctober 23 2007

Scottish children with dyslexia are being "victimised and abused" by teachers who do not believe the condition exists, campaigners have warned.

According to Dyslexia Scotland, parents from across the country complain weekly that teachers are dismissive, ignorant and hostile towards affected pupils, despite the fact that one in 10 youngsters suffers from the condition.

As a result, it is feared that vulnerable youngsters' education is suffering and some are being driven to self harm.

In one case, the charity heard how a secondary school teacher confiscated a pupil's learning aid after calling the condition a "fad".

Dyslexia Scotland, which yesterday launched new guides to help teachers understand the condition, said the complaints highlighted the need for compulsory training for all teachers.

Moira Thomson, author of the guide and secretary of the Scottish Parliament cross-party working group on dyslexia, said: "I have spoken to parents across Scotland who are distraught because their children are being, in their view and in mine, abused and victimised by teachers who say they don't believe in dyslexia.

"I have heard of teachers being dismissive and unco-operative all over the country. The rest of the school can be supportive, but it only takes a single teacher who is not and it can really destroy a child.

"A lot of teachers are doing a wonderful job, but for every one of these really good teachers there are probably a couple who are mediocre, and a few who are so dismissive and hostile to the idea of dyslexia that children are totally miserable.

"These are the ones who start cutting themselves, or develop eating disorders."

Sir Jackie Stewart OBE, president of Dyslexia Scotland, helped launch the new booklets at Perth High School yesterday. He said: "I truly hope all teachers will embrace this publication. If they can put into practice the guidance offered, it will make a fundamental difference to the way dyslexic children are taught in school today. Young people in Scotland deserve this chance."

A spokesman for the EIS teaching union said: "Schools and teachers want to ensure that all pupils receive proper support, although there are significant challenges and resource implications in achieving this. For teachers, the resources must be put in place to allow them to support all pupils with additional support needs, and there is a clear need for appropriate training."

Despite statistics which show that around one in 10 people suffers from dyslexia, some still question the existence of the condition.

Earlier this year, Professor Julian Elliott, an educational psychologist at Durham University, said dyslexia was an excuse for middle-class parents who did not want children to be labelled low achievers.

Dyslexia is now a recognised condition, but Dyslexia Scotland argues that that has led to a common misconception that children get the support they need in school.

A survey by the National Union of Teachers in England found that 77% of teachers would like training on how best to support children with specific learning difficulties.

Dyslexia Scotland also says many children are still not recognised as dyslexic through their entire education.



I don't know why I'm like this, I'm unwell'


As a pupil in a class of only five children at a tiny village primary, Alexander Orr was always likely to feel unsettled moving to a bigger school.

But nothing prepared his parents for his switch from a happy, enthusiastic child to a disruptive class clown.

After a conversation with relatives who had dyslexia, Alexander's mother Aileen suggested to the school that her son's behaviour might be a sign that he had it and was desperate to hide it.

Mrs Orr, 52, said: "The (special needs) teacher said extremely bluntly, no, hand on heart, he doesn't have dyslexia, but parents are always looking for excuses'."

Not long afterwards Alexander, 12, from Berwickshire, was suspended for unruly behaviour.

One day, he burst into tears and told his mother that he thought he was mentally ill. She said: "He kept saying, All the teachers hate me' and I don't know why I'm like this, I think I'm unwell'."

Private tests showed that he did have dyslexia - as did his father, Andrew, 51.

But the revelation this summer, mirroring the experience of racing legend Sir Jackie Stewart, offered only temporary respite.

For, although two teachers were privately supportive, Berwickshire High School refused to recognise that Alexander had the condition.

Now Mrs Orr, a political adviser, and her farmer husband are considering legal action against the school to get support for their son.

She said: "His behaviour is his coping mechanism. Directors of education need to accept that dyslexia exists and they have a moral obligation to provide support."

A council spokesman said it was "strongly committed to initiatives to support all pupils with additional support needs".


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.



Posted by: Jim, Scotland on 8:46am Tue 23 Oct 07
Abuse by teachers, both physical and mental has to my personal knowledge and experience been going on for the last 65 years.
The education system since the 1944 education act has been the main contributing factor, the education given to the vast majority has been at best poor and at its worst abominable.
The violence and disrespect for the people and our history and social conditions, never mind the physical violence perpetrated upon the pupils have created the problems that are around to-day.
Solutions of the one size fits all will not and never has worked, as for measuring the so called results have meant that since 1944 education has been devalued since that time; look at the quality of entrants into university to-day.
Posted by: Fiona Sinclair, Ayrshire on 10:38am Tue 23 Oct 07
We readily acknowledge that children with special educational needs, including dyslexia, receive dreadful treatment from `the system`. However, accusing individual teachers, without addressing the behaviour of the financial gatekeepers who are employed at huge public expense, is absolutely useless. There is a `trickle down` culture of wilful incompetence and abuse within the educational hierarchy towards children who have special educational needs. Those who receive some of the worst treatment have another `invisible` disability - an Autistic Spectrum Disorder (ASD).

Try reading some of the stuff on the IPSEA website - www.ipsea.org.uk - particularly the Sunday Times article, for a flavour of how disabled children have their life prospects ruined by the maladministration and abuse of power by education officials in local authorities. IPSEA is the sister organisation of ISEA, which is Scottish and offers INDEPENDENT advice on special educational needs.

It is time that central government stopped using local authorities in the usual arms length (i.e. close) relationship to do their dirty work in putting the screws on the budget for special educational needs. Huge amounts of money are simply being wasted in a system that resolutely refuses to adopt standards, enforcement, rights or accountability.

For background on the treatment of children with ASD, please visit:-

http://www.autismrig
hts.org.uk/BriefingP
aperIndex.html
Posted by: Fiona Sinclair, Ayrshire on 10:47am Tue 23 Oct 07
I should have also posted the link within the Autism Rights' Briefing Paper to our weblinks on education, which give more detailed information about what is happening as regards educational provision for children with ASD:-

http://www.autismrig
hts.org.uk/Education
.html
Posted by: Digory, Narnia on 10:53am Tue 23 Oct 07
The "rolling together" of Services has not been beneficial for some children.

Children with other problems such as Autism have difficulties also.

School Nurses/Midwives may give Vaccinations but they are not necessarily competent to recognise symptoms such as Purpura.

Families are bullied and children are moved around including locations out of area where they are put in the "bespoke" Care of people who are not qualified to assess them.

I have met a young girl who clearly had significant difficulties who has recently - much later - been diagnosed as Schizophrenic.

The manner in which these children and young people (and their Families) are managed is such that if they did not have significant difficulties at the outset they most likely will after a few months of this process.

Parents are also bullied at short notice into signing forms.
Posted by: Digory, Narnia on 11:03am Tue 23 Oct 07
The current structure of the Public Services makes them almost impossible to deal with should any problem arise.
Posted by: Pete Wright, Deltaville, Virginia, USA on 11:08am Tue 23 Oct 07
The problems parents of children with dyslexia face are same same in the USA. As a dyslexic attorney, my parents had a difficult time securing an education for me. Here, in the USA, the special education law that defines specific learning disability (IDEA 2004 / 20 USC 1401(30)) expressly includes the word dyslexia, but despite that language, many educators say it does not exist. We have a website about special education law and advocacy - www.wrightslaw.com
Posted by: Digory, Narnia Scotland on 11:54am Tue 23 Oct 07
Here even High Achievers can struggle with Education and Health Services.
Posted by: Digory, Narnia Scotland on 11:58am Tue 23 Oct 07
They are supposed to support each other.

Across the Public Services generally functions are delegated out to others now it is proposed that Community Pharmacies play a Central Role.
Posted by: Alasdair Andrew, Bathgate on 6:22pm Tue 23 Oct 07
Statement from the Board of Dyslexia Scotland.

Dyslexia Scotland would like point out that the statement attributed to it that “ Parents from across the country complain weekly that teachers are dismissive, ignorant and hostile towards affected pupils, despite the fact that one in 10 youngsters suffers from the condition.” was not made by Dyslexia Scotland.

While it is true that within the educational system there has been some bad experience, it is also true that Dyslexia Scotland is also aware of extensive good practice in schools across the country.

Our objective as a charitable organisation is to work in close co-operation with local authorities to ensure that this good practice is extended as far as possible.

Alasdair Andrew
Director
Dyslexia Scotland
Posted by: Fiona Sinclair, Ayrshire on 8:23pm Tue 23 Oct 07
Pete Wright wrote:
The problems parents of children with dyslexia face are same same in the USA. As a dyslexic attorney, my parents had a difficult time securing an education for me. Here, in the USA, the special education law that defines specific learning disability (IDEA 2004 / 20 USC 1401(30)) expressly includes the word dyslexia, but despite that language, many educators say it does not exist. We have a website about special education law and advocacy - www.wrightslaw.com
Pete - thank you for posting here. Your website gives some excellent advice on special educational needs and parent advocacy, and I recommend that parents take a look at it to be able to see how much better things can be, if the system is set up to perform to some actual standards. The problem in the UK, and particularly in Scotland, is that there are no standards, enforcement, rights or accountability. I know that the quality of educational provision for children with ASD is patchy in the US, but there are at least the beginnings of a structure to implement what is needed, rather than endlessly talking around, but not about, how to `deliver` appropriate services. When parents try to stop the prevarication, denial sets in, as it did when the Scottish parliament's Cross Party Group on Autistic Spectrum Disorder was precipitately closed down
Posted by: Fiona Sinclair, Ayrshire on 8:41pm Tue 23 Oct 07
quote
Dyslexia Scotland, which yesterday launched new guides to help teachers understand the condition, said the complaints highlighted the need for compulsory training for all teachers.
quote


This is the real point. Guides from a voluntary organisation can be ignored, so therefore will be ignored where it suits a headteacher or local authority. Even guidance with the force of law behind it is useless, unless there are standards that have to be adhered to. If dyslexia training were a part of the 4 year B.Ed. course that all primary teachers take, then there would be no need for ongoing expenditure on CPD (Continuing Professional Development). Only children with the most severe dyslexia might then require additional support, beyond the expertise of the classroom teacher. This would represent a financial gain - but perhaps this is just too sensible and obvious?

As to victimisation - many politicians know and admit it goes on in private - but won't commit to the policies that are required to put a stop to it. The situation as regards children with ASD is much greater, but without media coverage, is impossible to bring to the attention of the public, or to put pressure on politicians.
Posted by: Susan and John Drummond, Cheshire on 11:16am Fri 26 Oct 07
As parents of a ten year old dyslexic son we have encountered inadequacies in understanding the wider implications of dyslexia, early recognition, assessment and provision of support for children with dyslexia.

We welcome this campaign to raise awareness of dyslexia and improved access by teachers to dyslexia education. The Dyslexia Scotland initiative is impressive and we will be drawing it to the attention of our local education authority in England.

We would like to have dyslexia seen as genetically determined neuro-diversity – that is, a neurological difference that may offer some advantages in thinking, but also involves difficulties in the way the brain processes certain types of information. This includes language information, but can also encompass difficulties with visual processing, auditory processing, motor processing, memory processing and social and behavioral difficulties.

If the wider implications of dyslexia are not recognised and adequate resources not provided by the education system, many children will continue to fail to meet basic literacy standards or fail to achieve their full potential. This failure will have wider implications for the UK’s workforce, for the economy and for social progress.

All children would benefit from dyslexia-friendly teaching and improved special educational needs resources, as would society as a whole.
Posted by: A. Wayne McFarlane, Cobourg, Canada on 8:07pm Fri 26 Oct 07
First of all, teacher shound not be listening to Professor Julian Elliott, he is an embarrassment to psychologist, Durham University and anything to do with UK education.
It seem to me some teachers are taking the easy way out by saying dyslexia is a myth, instead of taking little extra effort to work with student who are difficulties because of thier dyslexia. If these teacher can not put in the extra effort maybe they should not be teaching.
Posted by: e bingham, ayr on 11:32am Tue 30 Oct 07
In response to Mr Alasdair Andrew from Dyslexia Scotland. Some Children experience child abuse in their own homes while the majority of parents are decent competent care givers. However, because good practice exists within most families does that mean we should ignore the abuse experienced by many children? Certainly not, so why should we ignore the abuse of children in our education system? Children with dyslexia experience horrific abuse in the Scottish Education System. Its disgusting and deplorable. People in positions of authority should be speaking out and doing something about it. Praising good practice initiatives is one thing ignoring rampant child abuse in most schools in Scotland is another. Dyslexia Scotland should be at the forefront of addressing this and demanding change - or is the organisation an adopted member of the education system which in its inaction condones wide scale legalised child abuse.
Posted by: allancullen, glasgow on 10:07am Wed 31 Oct 07
i suffer from a disabilty and the police and local autherity dont care on 19th december i had 4police officers come out to my home and i was teroisede by them i was terifide as i am mentaly ill i am haveing help from my caree as i have problem with my wordes i was abducted by the police who removed me from my home illegaly and unlawfuly inprisond me for 24houres i was not aware why until next day they told my cares and myself that i had some woman who had been waching my home for year i was flabergasted why she was not in custady as she had commited a crime is peeping toming not a crome i am indeed a victim of victimized ation can you help me get justice for everyone out there sufering injustice becouse the police and local courts just want rid of us i atempted suicide on20thdecember2006as direct concerquncese to what i had to endure youres alisonandallan
Posted by: andrewcullen, partick on 9:36pm Thu 1 Nov 07
i am allans brothere andrew i have had it with police harasing allan as he has never broken the law and now the law has made it clear he has no rigth to live what do you the publick have to say is it ok to eradicate peple with mental health?or are you just folwing like sheep alans rigths to be safe from perverts who live at3kennowaydrive have launched a hate campaing against him i have no love of a law that condems peple on behalf of some person who obveusly dosent have a clue how to respect peples privicy this person has hounded allan since august1st2006 till now she is going to claim his life if we the decent peple of glasgow dont stand up for him andrew
Posted by: RITESH MEHTA, INDIA on 11:17am Fri 21 Dec 07
I THINK IT IS A GLOBAL PHENOMINON EVEN IN INDIA IT IS NOT RECOGNISED AS A PROBLM BY TEACHERS MORE AWARENESS SPECIALLY AMONG TEACHERS IS REQURIED ABOUT THIS SUBJECT ,PROPER & PROFESSIONL TRANING SHOULD BE A PART OF TEACHER TRANEING FOR THIS PURPOSE
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use