logo
   Web Issue 3271 October 13 2008   
spacer
Scots retailers feeling pinch from illegal tobacco trade
LUCY ADAMS, Chief ReporterAugust 23 2007

Illegal tobacco smuggling affects Scotland more than almost any other part of the UK, according to a new study.

The report, by Retailers Against Smuggling, a group with 16,500 retail members across the UK, found that one in five newsagents in Scotland is facing closure because of black market tobacco.

It found that the average newsagent in Scotland loses some £20,000 per year in sales to the illegal trade.

Smuggled and counterfeit tobacco products also cause the Treasury to lose £2.6bn each year in lost taxes - more than £7m each day - money which could be spent on public services.

More than 40% of all freight container seizures in 2002 contained counterfeit cigarettes.

The news comes just days after a Glasgow man was jailed for nine months for being caught in possession of more than 128,000 illegal cigarettes and 131kg of tobacco.

James Brien, 57, of Craigflower Road, Glasgow, pled guilty to the charges.

Kirsten Ferguson, defending, said Brien had been storing the goods for an unnamed individual, which would be sold off at the city's Barras Market. Jim Gilfeather, a senior detection manager with HM Revenue and Customs (HMRC) in Scotland, said: "This case sends out a significant warning to anyone tempted to smuggle illegal products. HMRC officers continue to work across the country to protect our communities by investigating, prosecuting, and removing the financial benefits from individuals and organisations involved in the illegal importation of tobacco.

"Tobacco smuggling undermines public health by creating an unregulated supply operated by criminals."

Scotland has one of the highest prevalence rates of counterfeit tobacco offered for sale of anywhere in the UK and 43% of retailers questioned said they have been offered black market tobacco.

Some 75% of shopkeepers in Scotland are aware of smuggled tobacco being sold in their area and feel the effects on their business.

Counterfeit cigarettes are mainly produced in the Far East and Eastern Europe. Made to order, they are often indistinguishable from the genuine article but carry an even greater health risk as they are unregulated. On average they contain five times the levels of arsenic and lead as normal cigarettes.

The profits from the smuggling and sales of counterfeit tobacco, much of which is sold in Scotland's street markets such as the Barras in Glasgow, are thought to go into organised crime.

Retailers are calling for tougher sentences for those who sell illegal tobacco and want extra customs officers at ports and airports to help combat the problem.

They also think that reducing or freezing tax on tobacco would ease the problem - as it would cut smugglers' high profit margins. Nine out of 10 retailers said they did not think the government is doing enough to combat the problem.

Fiona Barrett, an independent retailer from Glasgow and Scottish Representative for Retailers Against Smuggling, said: "For corner shops like ours, the wide availability of smuggled and counterfeit tobacco is a big threat. A lot of shops face closure because small retailers really depend on sales of tobacco for profits.

"I've had my shop for almost 40 years and over that time the problem has got worse and worse. It's impossible for legitimate retailers like myself to compete with the bargain tobacco products available at car boot sales, pubs and workplaces when the tax on them is so high. Until the price of tobacco is the same across Europe, this problem will only get worse."


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: George, Scotland on 9:46am Thu 23 Aug 07
When will HMG come down from their ivory towers and step back into reality?

Extortionally high regressive taxes on tobacco that financially punishes the poor, treating smokers as 3rd or 4th class citizens and expecting them to happily pay for the privilage, creating a business opportunity for criminals and expecting them to spurn the chance.

Morons.
Posted by: Senga Jean Cregg on 10:14am Thu 23 Aug 07
Who was the un-named individual? People who know who is dealing in illegal goods and won't give up the names should be severely punished, on top of the penallties for their original crime. And the papers should be investigating where the law enforcement authorities won't.

It's probably Well Respected Members Of The Local Business Community behind it all, you'll see. The kind of awntreprenoors who frequent boxing matches and "sporting dinners" and have a few large men in leather jackets on the payroll, but send the kids to Hutchie.
Posted by: chas, suffolk on 9:38am Sun 26 Aug 07
Whilst I don't like to see gangs making money from smuggling, I see no reason while the less well off shouldn't avoid paying taxes, afterall the ultra rich avoid paying tax.
Posted by: DaveA, London on 6:20pm Sun 26 Aug 07
If I went to France and brought 10 crates of wine £2000 and sold them at £3000 I would be considered a good businessman. All above board and tax paid. I buy a packet of 20 cigarettes for £1.20 and sell it for £3 I am a criminal. Can anyone tell me why if I buy any good or service in the EU and re-sell it in the UK, apart from tobacco. Pray do tell.
Posted by: DaveA, London on 6:25pm Sun 26 Aug 07
Why it is illegal, was what I meant to say.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use