logo
   Web Issue 3277 October 13 2008   
spacer
Mugabe honorary degree set to be revoked
CAROLYN CHURCHILLJune 04 2007

Academics at a leading Scottish university are to strip Robert Mugabe, the President of Zimbabwe, of an honorary degree he was awarded 23 years ago.

Edinburgh University is expected to take the decision after a panel of three professors recommended revoking the honour.

Students, politicians and campaigners have all repeatedly called for the honorary degree to be withdrawn in light of Mr Mugabe's human rights record. The panel has decided that if the university had known the reality of Mr Mugabe's leadership in the early 1980s, he would never have been presented with the award.

At a meeting on Wednesday, the senate will be informed of the recommendation to withdraw the degree and, providing they vote in its favour, Mr Mugabe will be told of the decision and requested to return the certificate he received in 1984.

Jaison Matewu, organising secretary for the UK branch of the Movement for Democratic Change (MDC), Zimbabwe's opposition party, welcomed the decision.

"We are thrilled," he said. "When he was given this degree people were looking at him to turn Zimbabwe into a better country for his people.

"He has turned out to be a monster who is bent on destroying the economy of the country and killing his own people. He does not deserve anything at all."

‘He has turned out to be a monster … he does not deserve anything’

Mr Mugabe, 83, became President of Zimbabwe in 1980 and was awarded the honorary degree, for services to education, four years later.

Pressure on the university to strip Mr Mugabe of the award has intensified. In November 2005 students voted in favour of a motion which called on the university to strip Mr Mugabe of his degree. The motion was passed with 540 votes for and none against.

In April, Nigel Griffiths, MP for Edinburgh South, tabled a parliamentary motion calling on the university to withdraw Mr Mugabe's honorary degree.

Mr Griffiths said the decision should be made "in light of the recent oppressive and brutal regime over which he is presiding".

The panel of three senior professors from the university investigated Mr Mugabe's record and looked in particular at the massacre of up to 20,000 people in Matabeleland during the early 1980s.

They concluded that Mr Mugabe, who also holds honorary degrees from two universities in America, would not have received the degree if the facts were known at the time and now he should be stripped of the accolade.

Ross Neilson, vice-president of academic affairs at Edinburgh University Students' Association, said: "Hopefully this sends a message that his actions cannot be tolerated.

"It sends out a bad message internationally that people like him can be awarded such a prestigious honour.

"The students overwhelmingly voted for the degree to be revoked and they will stand proud of the decision."

Mr Griffiths, who recently met the Principal of the university to discuss the issue, added: "It is good news and reflects what both graduates and undergraduates want."

A spokesman for Edinburgh University said the senate would be informed of the panel's recommendation at a meeting on Wednesday.

He added: "The group is recommending that the degree conferred in 1984 should be withdrawn. This recommendation has been made after examining evidence relating to the situation in Zimbabwe in the early 1980s - evidence which was not available to the university at the time.

"If the senate decides that the honorary degree should be withdrawn the formal process for so doing will begin."


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Related Links

Posted by: Abel Magwitch on 5:14am Mon 4 Jun 07
It is tempting to reach a general conclusion from a specific case. Fifty years ago, the media were full of images of Biritish royalty cheerfully attending ceremonies in Africa where the UK flag was lowered and a new flag raised. Independence was the buzzword and the future looked bright. Today, the continent of Africa is in big trouble whether we look at health, poverty or human rights. Of course it is unfashionable to even think of going back to colonial days, and the European ex-colonial countries are standing well back from the mess. International charities and the UN are doing their best but losing the battle. Now would anyone dare to predict what Africa will be like in another 50 years?
Posted by: Clare, Glasgow on 2:44pm Mon 4 Jun 07
Well done Edinburgh, Mugabe's honorary degree should have been revoked by now
Posted by: neil, Dundee on 5:44pm Mon 4 Jun 07
So why did it take them so long? And did they really not know about the 'excesses' in the early 1980's when Lord Carrington the British Foreign Secretary apparently wrote to then Principal John Burnett on April 2, 1982 'asking Edinburgh whether it would consider bestowing a degree on the Zimbabwean leader'? Carrington - who had bugged every room during The Lancaster House negotiations (allegedly!) so as to strengthen the hand of the chairman in brokering a settlement and was also (allegedly!) in close touch with Sir David Steel as well
- also wrote apparently after meeting Mugabe in Harare that "I was struck by the intensely high regard that Mr Mugabe holds for our ancient institutions in the field of learning".

But why on earth was this Scottish university taking instructions from the British Foreign and Commonwealth Secretary - who was himself a graduate of Eton and Sandhurst - about alleged suitability of this external graduate of London University (Mugabe) for the award of an honorary degree at all? Is it not more normal for the university itself to initiate such degrees on the recommendation of former graduates who are Members of The General Council and/or existing staff and students rather than on the say-so of some 'here today, gone tomorrow' Foreign Office Minister (s)? Who nominated the guy?

Perhaps his junior Minister Malcolm Rifkind MP could enlighten us as he is an Edinburgh graduate and was indeed himself co-opted on to the Court of The University of Edinburgh as a Kensington MP and Chairman of Armscor (a private security firm) in 2003 after he was kicked out of Scotland by the electorate for dictatorial lapses?
Posted by: joell, usa on 1:54am Tue 5 Jun 07
"Africans in general and Zimbabweans in particular must know that the honours, degrees, medals, and so forth conferred on African leaders, past or present, by the West, were never sincere.

They are meant to flatter our leaders so that they can work to further Western interests at the expense of the majority of Africans.

Just look at how they praise past and present African leaders who have done virtually nothing to empower indigenous black people but whose "success" is rated by how well they maintain the status quo of minority white privileges."

ps .......who's worse, mugabe or bush?
Posted by: Asher Tarivona Mutsengi on 10:00pm Thu 7 Jun 07
Giving Mugabe that degree was a grave mistake in the first place. That dictactor has never been tolerant to any opposition since he got into power. Infact he got to the helm of his party by assasinating his possible rivals.

I am proud that I never supported this man from the on set,I come from the South of Zimbabwe,where we I witnessed 'Gukurahundi'-a crack down on the minority tribe,the Ndebele to which my mother belongs all because of their support of the popular and charismatic rival Joshua Nkomo.

In any case lets correct the mistake that was made,rescind the honor,he doesn't deserve it,he never did.
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use