logo
   Web Issue 3203 July 19 2008   
spacer
Pub crawl leaflets raise fears over binge drinking
HELEN PUTTICK, Health CorrespondentApril 16 2007

Flyers promoting a Glasgow pub crawl with "drinks from one pound" have been ordered off information stands amid concern about binge drinking.

The leaflets which advertise a trip around five of the city's "cheapest" bars were displayed in Glasgow City Council racks despite its stance against the promotion of low-cost drinking.

Public health experts have expressed concern about the flyers which direct visitors to a website advertising a "weekender bender".

Professor Gerard Hastings, director of the Institute for Social Marketing run by the University of Stirling and the Open University, said: "The problem with this sort of promotion is it is reinforcing this notion that the only way to have a good time is to drink and drink to excess.

"The bigger picture here is public money is going into discouraging drinking and at the same time it is being undermined and therefore wasted because we are allowing the contrary message to be promoted."

Scotland's drinking culture has shot to the top of the agenda amid a series of alarming statistics about its toll on the nation's health.

This February a report revealed Scots are drinking themselves to death at twice the rate of people elsewhere in the UK. The mortality rate from cirrhosis of the liver north of the border increased 143% among men in a decade, 45 Scots are dying because of alcohol every week and at least 10% of admissions to A&E are drink-related.

Glasgow licensing board has described itself as setting an example after introducing a ban on happy hours and the "promotional sale of low cost alcohol in licensed premises" which can lead to binge drinking.

Jack Law, chief executive of Alcohol Focus Scotland, said he was concerned the crawl was being advertised given that the board's policy clearly ruled out irresponsible drinks promotions like two for one.

He added that it was particularly worrying that the leaflets were displayed at information points in city museums, saying: "This is surely not the image that Glasgow wants to project to visitors."

However, James Moore, who set up Glasgow's Best Bar Crawl - the company behind the promotion - said the guided crawls were "entirely responsible".

"Everyone is informed at the start of the night how it works," he said. "No-one under 18 is admitted, we are very strict about that. They have got bouncers at every venue we go to.

"Someone could go to a pub at 8pm and get legless all night, where as they (people on the crawl) are getting looked at every half hour or 45 minutes. Obviously they are going to enjoy themselves, but they are not going to get drunk to the point where they are not allowed admission to a premises.

"The fact it is a pub crawl where they are moving around gives them less time to drink."

Mr Moore, an undergraduate student due to start teacher training later this year, said he launched the guided crawls after encountering similar tours travelling in Europe.

He said they were targeted at visitors to Glasgow, offering travellers a chance to meet each other.

"We do not aim at Glaswegian customers, we aim at European travellers who have a totally different drinking culture," he said.

E-mailing the Glasgow bar crawl website generates an automatic reply saying "we are currently out having a blast" and "once we've sobered up someone will be in touch", but Mr Moore said this was a joke.

Professor Phil Hanlon, public health expert at Glasgow University, said the big drivers behind the growth in alcohol abuse were prices coming down, drink becoming more readily available and the drinking culture.

He added: "Should the local authority help to promote something that is so explicitly a bar-crawl-related activity? I think it is unwise."

A spokesman for Glasgow City Council said: "We have instructed the company who supply and fill the leaflet stands to remove the leaflets in question."


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Anon on 12:31pm Mon 16 Apr 07
aaaa
Posted by: Andy, Glasgow on 2:49pm Mon 16 Apr 07
I'm feeling curmudgeonly today so...

They started by banning fox-hunting.

Then they banned smoking in 'work spaces' including every pub in the country.

I don't know what precise form the next one will take, but I will eat my hat if it is not directed at drinking. Not a total ban, but happy hours or something like that. Those of us who like a drink and don't go mad will be made to pay for the excesses of a few.

Whatever happened to freedom of choice?

They have a taste for banning things and telling people what to do.

They are being advised by interfering doctors who, instead of simply patching people up and sending them on, think they have the right to pass judgement on other's lifestyles. I notice the smoking ban hasn't led to a miraculous reduction in taxes as the NHS treats less smokers...

You heard it here first...
Posted by: James Moore, Glasgow on 10:00pm Mon 16 Apr 07
As founder of Glasgow’s Best Bar Crawl I feel not only a need but a justification reply to the claims levelled against my company by the Herald.

Glasgow’s Best Bar Crawl (GBBC) agree with every point Ms Puttick makes in her article but feel that GBBC has been chastised unfairly. There undoubtedly is a drinking problem in Scotland with Glasgow and the West of Scotland feeling the brunt in particular. The figures speak for themselves. As the article states, Scots are dying at twice the rate of those elsewhere in the UK and as has been the case before, the government will not address the problem directly. Scotland (and the UK’s) drinking culture is ingrained within social problems which cannot be solved until the government tackles the real causes of the problem, namely the socio-economic problems which exist within our council schemes, electorate and society as a whole.

I am not going to defend my company as I feel that grown adults are more than capable of deciding how and where they drink and thus the company needs no justification but as a student of politics I will say this:

GBBC are fully behind Ms Puttick’s sentiment but if Glasgow City Council are so vehemently opposed to showing Glasgow to outsiders in a bad light with regards to its drinking culture then they would not openly endorse several thousand revellers drinking in George Square for the upcoming UEFA cup final as they did for the Champions League final in 2002 nor the New Years Eve celebrations as they do every year.

Also, the Scottish Executive would lend itself a tad more credibility with regards to fighting against Scotland’s drink culture if Mr Mc Connell and his associates did not feel the need to sing the praises and be photographed at a certain Scottish music festival every July which amounts to not much more than a weekend long drinking session for 100,000+ people and an advert for a brewery.

I could go on…

The flyers have been taken out of said promotional boxes in Glasgow’s tourist attractions with no argument from us and everyone at Glasgow’s Best Bar Crawl are fully behind any measures taken to curb Scotland’s drinking culture but, as stated in the article, our crawls are aimed at travellers who tend to have a different drinking culture and nature to the Scots and we do not feel that our company should face the sole attention of the Herald with regards to Scotland’s drink culture.

We will be more than happy to answer any e-mails sent to GBBC itself to infoATglasgowbarcrawl.com

James Moore
Glasgow’s Best Bar Crawl
www.glasgowbarcrawl.com

Posted by: David Ashe, Thailand on 9:01am Wed 18 Apr 07
The good people at the herald obviously never have a night out or indeed believe in a person’s right to do as they choose. People who want to drink can are better doing so in a supervised environment where it is kept under control or would the herald have people drinking in the street or in their houses. The pure and simple fact is this is a poor article trying its darndest to highlight the dangers of drinking for their easily outraged readership as they never have a good time.

James Moore is obviously an educated young man who has the mordacity to make money from one of Europe’s favorite pass times, I for one only wish I thought of it first. I say to **** with people telling us what to do and how to live our life’s I thought the government has a stance against tyrants, but when you have people like Helen Puttick who needs the government telling us what we can and cannot do.

Perhaps Helen would like to extend her outrage to the night clubs of Scotland who give us promo flyers every night of the week and leave this little business alone.

Well in my opinion.

Perhaps Helen would like to discuss this further?
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use