logo
   Web Issue 3245 September 6 2008   
spacer
Today's most viewed
MPs snub reform of their ‘John Lewis list’ expenses
TORCUIL CRICHTON, Chief UK political correspondentJuly 04 2008

MPs have rejected proposals that would lead to a radical reform of their expenses system thought necessary to restore trust in democracy and clean up Westminster's "snouts in the trough" image following a series of financial scandals.

By a narrow majority of 28 in a free vote, MPs agreed to retain the controversial Additional Costs Allowance (ACA) that funds second homes in London, with the proviso of having their spending scrutinised once every parliamentary term by internal auditors.

The unexpected move means the infamous "John Lewis list" of approved prices for furnishing claims that has allowed some MPs to claim expenses of up to £10,000 for a new kitchen and £2000 for furniture for their second homes will continue. The ACA allows MPs to claim up to £24,006 a year against mortgages, rent or hotel bills leading to accusations of profiteering on property investments.

The vote drew immediate condemnation from within Westminster and beyond. Highland LibDem MP Danny Alexander said those who voted to block reform should be utterly ashamed. "These were self-serving and cynical votes. By keeping their snouts in the trough those mainly Labour MPs, along with some Tories, have shown total contempt for public demand for a more open and accountable system."

Senior LibDem MP Nick Harvey earlier warned that rejecting the reforms in defiance of public opinion would be "utterly catastrophic" for the image of parliamentarians and Matthew Elliott, of the Tax Payers' Alliance, said MPs had missed a crucial opportunity to restore faith in Westminster.

He said: "By clinging on to the plasma screen TVs and luxury kitchens allowed by the John Lewis list they have shown astonishing arrogance and disregard for people's concerns."

The Conservatives accused the government of making a "shabby deal" with its backbenchers, allowing them to vote to retain their expenses in return for accepting a below inflation salary increase. Of the 172 votes to retain the John Lewis list, 146 were Labour. They included some cabinet ministers such as Home Secretary Jacqui Smith, Culture Secretary Andy Burnham and Housing Minister Caroline Flint.

A "root and branch" review of allowances, unveiled last month by a committee chaired by Speaker Michael Martin, had recommended an immediate end to the furnishings allowance, a full external audit of expenses, all claims to be receipted and limits on overnight and daily allowances.

The proposals to end the "gentleman's club" system of a MP's signature being enough to authenticate a claim, followed a series of financial scandals involving MPs allowances and drew heavily on the experience of the Scottish parliament where MSPs expenses are regularly published. Following a Freedom of Information campaign all MPs expenses are due to be published regularly from this Autumn.

But in the unwhipped vote in the Commons yesterday MPs threw out the reform proposals, accepting only one recommendation for a new office allowances, a move that could increase the annual bill for constituency offices from £2.8m to potentially £6m.

The decision diminished an earlier vote in which MPs bowed to the Prime Minister's advice to show restraint by awarding themselves a 2.25% rise for the next year. The decision to accept a below inflation rise was taken without a vote after a backbench move to raise salaries by up to 2.3% this year and about 4.7% next year was rejected by 196 votes to 155, a majority of 41.

An amendment to boost salaries with £650 a year "catch-up" payments over the next three years was also rejected by a 101 vote majority.

It will be the last time MPs debate and vote on their own pay rise after they agreed to link future increases to those given to other public sector workers like doctors and teachers.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Astonished, Inverclyde on 10:27pm Thu 3 Jul 08
Another union dividend ?


































Did anyone honestly expect the labour party to do the decent thing ?
Posted by: subrosa on 10:28pm Thu 3 Jul 08
So they've voted to continue to keep their snouts in the trough. Mainly labour MPs too. Shameful.
Posted by: Karin, glasgae. on 11:07pm Thu 3 Jul 08
By a narrow majority of 28 in a free vote

A free vote

a flippin free vote. on wether they get to keep their expenses.

a free vote. seriously?
Posted by: John Clark, glasgow on 11:48pm Thu 3 Jul 08
I honestly believe the Labour Party and Gordon Brown are now finished. That vote was surely the death knell for them. Brown allowed a free vote. In short he allowed that vote to happen. They are now a defeated Party. They will never get back into power now.

The UK public are being hammered in taxes - as per for petrol. And they are keeping expenses that will allow them to buy luxury TVs for their second homes KITCHEN. These people are FILTH. Think of the poor people in this country. These MPs are no more than trash.

How can they possibly point at dole scroungers? The real scroungers are in the Labour Party. They have even targeted people on incapacity benefit - the most vulnerable people in the UK. Yet they vote the way they did?

They are nothing BUT trash. Mr. Brown, you look as if you have NO AUTHORITY. You are going the same way as your pal Wendy Cronyism Alexander. Your party is a disgrace. Socialism, Mr. Brown? Middle class trash bags, more like.

And as for the expenses for luxury TVs, my son is in Afghanistan just now. What expenses does he get, Mr. Brown. Is he fighting for the people that voted that way last night? Is he laying is life on the line for such dung as that? IS HE? The morale of our troops must be at an all time low.
Posted by: soloman, Stirling on 11:53pm Thu 3 Jul 08
AND HEAD LINES FROM THE TIMES.

National Audit Office rejects Treasury accounts
Dramatic collapse in department’s morale.

There goes another of Mr Browns little Darlings!
Posted by: Seannair, Oban on 12:38am Fri 4 Jul 08
As a serious newspaper can you not inform your readrs of who voted and how they voted?
Posted by: nostress, grangemouth on 12:43am Fri 4 Jul 08
I think this just proves once and for all who the real "subsidy junkies" are....
Posted by: clochoderic, renfrashur on 12:43am Fri 4 Jul 08
Tried to find out if Dougie Alexander voted for this - Theyworkforyou.com not yet updated - anyone have any info on WHO, exactly, voted for this?
Posted by: TamHickey, Glasgow on 12:57am Fri 4 Jul 08
These people are a total disgrace. For Brown to allow a free vote on such an issue shows complete disregard for the rest of us who fund these parasites.
Put them on minimum wage for a while. Maybe then the message will get through to them. Whilst they are at it, any profit made on a secondary home should go back to the treasury, something which would benefit us all, not just their alreafy swollen bank accounts.
Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 1:08am Fri 4 Jul 08

From the tone of comments on this and other forums discussing their resistence to accountability, it's clear they have no idea of the public mood, or how deep it runs.

Posted by: Colin McKay, Coatbridge, Lanarkshire on 1:48am Fri 4 Jul 08
Quick! Get your snout in the trough!
Posted by: Colin McKay, Coatbridge, Lanarkshire on 1:51am Fri 4 Jul 08
Or maybe we should stop moaning. The British Parliament is the greatest in the universe, so whatever anyone does is OK. They should fiddle expenses - they're British. that's how we do things.
Posted by: DouglasT, kirkintilloch on 1:51am Fri 4 Jul 08
Well, there you go. If anyone was in any doubt about voting SNP, there's your reason. Westminster is a den of iniquity; they have just shown the taxpayers two fingers yet again. The only way we can reply to them is with our votes.
Posted by: Colin McKay, Coatbridge, Lanarkshire on 1:53am Fri 4 Jul 08
I don't like the snp. they will end up spoiling it for us all. why shouldnt we get a few perks? typical snp - trying to be goody-goodies.
Posted by: wisnaeme, wisnae there on 2:00am Fri 4 Jul 08

It is now apparent that the snouts in the trough have more considerations for their own well being than the well being of the public purse. it is yet to be confirmed who voted for the status quo and no change to the fiscal arrangements that's so agreeable to themselves. One has been accustomed to being kept in comfort and ease, in the manner they have become accustomed to.

No doubt the Lewis lists of comforts will be bring out a new line in merchandise,,, gold plated troughs for discerning clientele, complete with chateau cost a lot whatever on tap. ...and a second home with more dining rooms than bathrooms to accommodate and house in a manner befitting gold plated troughs and expensive sundry extras; At public expense, naturally.
It's time these self serving politicos had lessons in humility and thrift by removing them from this gravitas they've become acustomed to by booting out their sorry @rses at the nearest opportunity available to us, the long suffering public.
.
Posted by: Steve A, Independence for Scotland! on 2:30am Fri 4 Jul 08
Anybody notice the liebour party activist on question time tonight?
What A pr!ck spouting out that 70% Scottish people against independence how would he know ?did he ask everyone?

Posted by: El Syd on 2:37am Fri 4 Jul 08
'Ere ye go. From the Daily Mail Online:

There were loads of Tories who voted to retain their expenses as well but I guessed that they are kind of irrelevant in Scotland - No SNP. Tom Clarke the MP from another deprived Glasgow East constituency gets the double whammy vote- He voted for the higher than inflation pay rise as well.
My MP - don't get me started on him!!!
MPs who voted to keep their snouts firmly in the trough:

Nick Ainger (Carmarthen West & Pembrokeshire South),
Graham Allen (Nottingham North),
David Anderson (Blaydon),
Janet Anderson (Rossendale & Darwen),
Ian Austin (Dudley North),
Adrian Bailey (West Bromwich West),
Gordon Banks (Ochil & Perthshire South),
Kevin Barron (Rother Valley),
Margaret Beckett (Derby South),
Clive Betts (Sheffield Attercliffe),
Liz Blackman (Erewash),
Roberta Blackman-Woods (Durham, City of),
Bob Blizzard (Waveney),
David Borrow (Ribble South (South Ribble)),
Nick Brown (Newcastle upon Tyne East & Wallsend),
Richard Burden (Birmingham Northfield),
Colin Burgon (Elmet), Andy Burnham (Leigh),
Stephen Byers (Tyneside North),
Alan Campbell (Tynemouth),
Ronnie Campbell (Blyth Valley),
Ben Chapman (Wirral South),
David Chaytor (Bury North),
Tom Clarke (Coatbridge,
Chryston & Bellshill),
David Clelland (Tyne Bridge),
Ann Clwyd (Cynon Valley),
Ann Coffey (Stockport),
Harry Cohen (Leyton & Wanstead),
Michael Connarty (Linlithgow & Falkirk East),
Rosie Cooper (Lancashire West),
Ann Cryer (Keighley),
John Cummings (Easington),
Jim Cunningham (Coventry South),
Tony Cunningham (Workington),
Wayne David (Caerphilly),
Ian Davidson (Glasgow South West),
Janet Dean (Burton),
Frank Dobson (Holborn & St Pancras),
Brian Donohoe (Ayrshire Central),
Jim Dowd (Lewisham West),
Angela Eagle (Wallasey),
Maria Eagle (Liverpool Garston),
Jeff Ennis (Barnsley East & Mexborough),
Bill Etherington (Sunderland North),
Caroline Flint (Don Valley),
Paul Flynn (Newport West),
Michael Foster (Worcester),
Michael Jabez Foster (Hastings & Rye),
Mike Gapes (Ilford South),
Dr Ian Gibson (Norwich North),
Linda Gilroy (Plymouth Sutton),
Nia Griffith (Llanelli),
Andrew Gwynne (Denton & Reddish),
Mike Hall (Weaver Vale),
David Hamilton (Midlothian),
Dai Havard (Merthyr Tydfil & Rhymney),
Stephen Hesford (Wirral West),
Sharon Hodgson (Gateshead East & Washington West),
Jimmy Hood (Lanark & Hamilton East),
George Howarth (Knowsley North & Sefton East),
Beverley Hughes (Stretford & Urmston),
Joan Humble (Blackpool North & Fleetwood),
Dr Brian Iddon (Bolton South East),
Eric Illsley (Barnsley Central),
Adam Ingram (East Kilbride, Strathaven & Lesmahagow),
Brian Jenkins (Tamworth),
Diana Johnson (Hull North),
Kevan Jones (Durham North),
Martyn Jones (Clwyd South),
Tessa Jowell (Dulwich & West Norwood),
Eric Joyce (Falkirk),
Alan Keen (Feltham & Heston),
David Kidney (Stafford),
Peter Kilfoyle (Liverpool Walton),
Bob Laxton (Derby North),
Tom Levitt (High Peak),
Ivan Lewis (Bury South),
Tony Lloyd (Manchester Central),
Ian Lucas (Wrexham),
Tommy McAvoy (Rutherglen & Hamilton West),
Stephen McCabe (Birmingham Hall Green),
Christine McCafferty (Calder Valley),
Kerry McCarthy (Bristol East),
Sarah McCarthy-Fry (Portsmouth North),
Siobhain McDonagh (Mitcham & Morden),
James McGovern (Dundee West),
Anne McGuire (Stirling),
Shona McIsaac (Cleethorpes),
Rosemary McKenna (Cumbernauld, Kilsyth & Kirkintilloch East),
Tony McNulty (Harrow East),
Denis MacShane (Rotherham),
Khalid Mahmood (Birmingham Perry Barr),
Rob Marris (Wolverhampton South West),
Gordon Marsden (Blackpool South),
Alan Meale (Mansfield),
Gillian Merron (Lincoln),
Andrew Miller (Ellesmere Port & Neston),
Madeleine Moon (Bridgend),
Jessica Morden (Newport East),
Elliot Morley (Scunthorpe),
George Mudie (Leeds East),
Denis Murphy (Wansbeck),
Paul Murphy (Torfaen),
Mike O'Brien (Warwickshire North),
Eddie O'Hara (Knowsley South),
Sandra Osborne (Ayr, Carrick & Cumnock),
James Plaskitt (Warwick & Leamington),
Bridget Prentice (Lewisham East),
Gordon Prentice (Pendle),
Gwyn Prosser (Dover),
Ken Purchase (Wolverhampton North East),
Nick Raynsford (Greenwich & Woolwich),
John Robertson (Glasgow North West),
Terry Rooney (Bradford North),
Chris Ruane (Vale of Clwyd),
Christine Russell (Chester, City of),
Alison Seabeck (Plymouth Devonport),
Barry Sheerman (Huddersfield),
Jimmy Sheridan (Paisley & Renfrewshire North),
Angela C Smith (Sheffield Hillsborough),
Angela E Smith (Basildon), Jacqui Smith (Redditch),
Anne Snelgrove (Swindon South),
John Spellar (Warley),
Phyllis Starkey (Milton Keynes South West),
Gavin Strang (Edinburgh East), Gisela Stuart (Birmingham Edgbaston),
Gerry Sutcliffe (Bradford South),
Mark Tami (Alyn & Deeside),
Gareth Thomas (Harrow West),
Emily Thornberry (Islington South & Finsbury),
Don Touhig (Islwyn),
Derek Twigg (Halton),
Kitty Ussher (Burnley),
Keith Vaz (Leicester East),
Lynda Waltho (Stourbridge),
Claire Ward (Watford),
Tom Watson (West Bromwich East),
Dave Watts (St Helens North),
Phil Wilson (Sedgefield),
Rosie Winterton (Doncaster Central),
Shaun Woodward (St Helens South),
Phil Woolas (Oldham East & Saddleworth),
David Wright (Telford),
Iain Wright (Hartlepool),
Derek Wyatt (Sittingbourne & Sheppey)
Posted by: Edward, Edinburgh on 2:37am Fri 4 Jul 08
Amusingly the MP's interviewed on the BBC or featured in the commons supporting the continuation of the 'expenses' were all Scottish Labour MP's
Its time to rid ourselves of these leeches!
Posted by: clochoderic, renfrashur on 2:44am Fri 4 Jul 08
The Trough Party ?
Posted by: El Syd on 2:54am Fri 4 Jul 08
Interstingly - if the 17 Scottish Labour MPs had voted the other way the result would have been entirely different.
Posted by: clochoderic, renfrashur on 3:05am Fri 4 Jul 08

REMEMBER JOHN MacLEAN

You working of Scotland all you who want her free
Remember John MacLean right well or free you'll never be
What freedom you call is not freedom at all, till tyranny is done
Not the English alone, but the tyrants at home must go before we've won
What good's your flags and banners, what good's your Bannockburn
When Scotland's full of moneymen, who will rob you in their turn
What freedom you call is not freedom at all, till tyranny is done
Not the English alone, but the tyrants at home must go before we've won
We'll proudly build a Scotland where landlord's fences fall
Where in the streets for you and me, where each can work for all
What freedom you call is not freedom at all, till tyranny is done
Not the English alone, but the tyrants at home must go before we've won
Posted by: Traquir, Alba on 4:02am Fri 4 Jul 08
Apologies for posting on the wrong thread, but apparently Glasgows
Leading Quality Newspaper The Herald does not allow
comments on the local interest story the Glasgow East
by-election. Apparently Labour sycophant Dougie Fraser
continues his Pravda style censorship. I bet he can't wait
to leave The Herald and join the "Anglocentricity and London-centricity" of the Unionist mouthpiece the BBC
- see tinyurl.com/6md9t5

Anyhow ignoring Dougie yet again, and getting back to
the Glasgow East By-Election :

"David Cairns, the Scotland Office Minister, said: "If a by-election is not called now, the earliest possible date would be late October."

see - tinyurl.com/6979x3

Angus Robertson SNP MP
"The 1975 Recess Election Act allows for parliamentary by-elections to take place when Parliament is not in session,"

see - tinyurl.com/5wclvt

Oops, Labour caught out to be liars yet again :)

"The deadline for getting a postal vote is
5.00 pm on Wednesday, 9th July 2008"

"The issuing of postal ballot papers will commence on or after 14 July 2008"

see - tinyurl.com/63djyo

Glasgow Trades holidays are the week of the election
19th to 25th July. So basically to have a chance
to vote anybody that is going on holiday needs
to fill in the postal ballot and hopefully
receive the postal ballot form before they
head off on holiday. I wonder what the chance are
that they will get posted out after the 14th
July and won't arrive in mailboxes until people
have left for vacation the 18th July ?

From the Guardian

"Polling day has been deliberately placed during the summer holidays - Scottish schools have already broken up. It is also midway through the Glasgow fair holiday, when the city traditionally empties and the more politically volatile C2 demographic - backbone of many a byelection swing - are safely away on vacation."

"Today, humiliatingly, Labour's view is that the fewer people who vote, the better. Glasgow East - like Brown's premiership - is now entirely about survival."

see - tinyurl.com/66cr87

Clearly this is democracy British style - apparently
there is only a level playing field if
you are wearing a Unionist strip.
One silver lining though the SNP win in Glasgow East
will be even sweeter when it wins against
this type of underhand abuse.

Saor Alba

P.S. Not that easy to find but the postal ballot
application form is at http://tinyurl.com/5
9spkb

PLEASE PLEASE pass this around so the people of
Glasgow East at least have the chance to vote.
Posted by: dave, north on 6:17am Fri 4 Jul 08
Remember this is a byelection.Those who are away on holiday and thus denied their democratic rights will get the chance to vote again at the general election.And a lot of them will remember this Labour Party tricking them out of their vote.
Gordon Brown said he would do anything to keep Scotland in the union.The campaign by Labour will be dirty.Thats the kind of them.The SNP must stay positive.Labour have nothing they can be positive about.As to the expenses vote....Typical
Posted by: haud me back, glasgow on 6:23am Fri 4 Jul 08
They obviously don't give a monkeys what people think of them and have decided to rip the pish out of the system.
I hope MP's read these comments because if they do then they will be under no illusion about what we all think of them...thieving, robbing b@stards!!!!
Posted by: haud me back, glasgow on 6:32am Fri 4 Jul 08
Credit crunch? recession? increased fuel costs? broken fridge? windows need replaced?, garden needing landscaped? lightbulbs need replaced? .....nope! doesn't affect any of our MP's they just whack it in on expenses...no receipt required, just a shiny brass neck and no conscience....oh and by the way just keep voting them in as they are Labour men and have your interests at heart........muppets
!!!!!
Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 6:34am Fri 4 Jul 08
The John Maclean March

Hey Mac did ye see him as he cam in by Gorgie,
Awa ower the Lammerlaw and north o’ the Tay?
Yon man is comin’ and the hale toon is turnin’ oot,
We’re aa’ sair he’ll win back tae Glasga the day.

The jiners and hauders-on are marchin’ fae Clydebank,
Come noo an’ hear him, he’ll be ower thrang tae bide.
Turn oot Jock and Jimmie, leave yer cranes an’ yer muckle gantries
Great John Maclean’s comin’ back tae the Clyde.

Argyle Street and London Road’s the route that we’re mairchin’
The lads frae the Broomielaw are oot tae a man.
Hey, Neil, whaur’s yer hoderums, ye big Hielan teuchter?.
Get yer pipes, mate, and march at the heid o’the clan!

Hallo Pat Malone, I knew ye’d be here, son
The red and green, my lads, we’ll wear side by side,
The Gorbals is his the day and Glasgae belangs tae him,
Noo great John Maclean’s comin’ hame tae the Clyde.

It’s forward tae Glasga Green we’ll mairch in guid order,
Will grips his banner weel, that boy isna blate,
Aye there man, that’s Johnny noo, that’s him, aye, the bonnie fechter
Lenin’s his fere, Mac, and Leibnecht’s his mate.

Tak tent when he’s speakin’ for they’ll mind whit wis said here
In Glasgae our city and the hale world besides.
Tha’s richt, lads, the scarlet’s bonnie, here’s tae ye Hielan’ Shonie!
Oor John Maclean has come hame to the Clyde.

An weel when it’s ower, I’ll awa hame tae Springburn,
Come hame tae yer tea noo, John, we’ll soon hae ye fed!
It’s hard wark the speakin’, an I’m sair ye’ll be tired the nicht,
I’ll sleep on the flair, Mac, and gie John the bed.

The hale city’s quiet noo, It kens that he’s restin’
Hame wi’ his Glasga freens, the fame and their pride.
The red will be worn, my lads, and Scotland will rise again,
Noo great John Maclean has come hame tae the Clyde.

John MacLean, 1879-1923, Stood for a Scottish Workers Republic

Q. What does Labour stand for?
A. The Queen.
Posted by: steve4349, larbet on 7:01am Fri 4 Jul 08
once again the mps refuse to listen to the voters of britian as they wallow in the trough at westmister,they behave with the morals of the rulers of banana republic,lies,bribes for honours, bribes for votes,manipulation of bye election dates,the corruption and dishonesty knows no bounds and that just the labour party,we also could have rent boys libs, pay your nanny from expenses con, is there no end to this blatant theft of taxpayers money
Posted by: bluenose, Glasgow on 7:40am Fri 4 Jul 08
Brown has lost his authority completely , he was not even in the commons to vote never mind to organise that his troughers voted the "moral compass" way.
apparently 32 of the government including cabinet ministers voted to keep the expenses.
If people ever needed a reason to get rid of Westminster this is it .
Posted by: El Syd on 7:50am Fri 4 Jul 08
bluenose wrote:
Brown has lost his authority completely , he was not even in the commons to vote never mind to organise that his troughers voted the "moral compass" way. apparently 32 of the government including cabinet ministers voted to keep the expenses. If people ever needed a reason to get rid of Westminster this is it .
32?

146 Labour MPs (17 Scottish Labour) voted to continue their shameless fleecing and cheating of the tax payer.
They are the government, Bluenose.

Posted by: Jimmy the Pie, Orkney on 7:50am Fri 4 Jul 08
These are the Scottish MP's who voted for their place at the trough.

See if you can guess which party they represent?????


Gordon Banks (Ochil & Perthshire South),
Tom Clarke (Coatbridge),
Michael Connarty (Linlithgow & Falkirk East),
Ian Davidson (Glasgow South West),
Brian Donohoe (Ayrshire Central),
David Hamilton (Midlothian),
Jimmy Hood (Lanark & Hamilton East),
Adam Ingram (East Kilbride, Strathaven & Lesmahagow),
Eric Joyce (Falkirk),
Tommy McAvoy (Rutherglen & Hamilton West),
James McGovern (Dundee West),
Anne McGuire (Stirling),
Rosemary McKenna (Cumbernauld, Kilsyth & Kirkintilloch East),
John Robertson (Glasgow North West),
Jimmy Sheridan (Paisley & Renfrewshire North),
Gavin Strang (Edinburgh East),

Posted by: Jimmy the Pie, Orkney on 7:53am Fri 4 Jul 08
Here's another one I missed

Sandra Osborne (Ayr, Carrick & Cumnock),
Posted by: El Syd on 7:54am Fri 4 Jul 08
My apologies. There are only 16.
Posted by: El Syd on 7:55am Fri 4 Jul 08
Hooray!! Thanks Jimmy the Pie. I was sure I had counted 17!!
Posted by: jomellon, Lodève, France on 7:56am Fri 4 Jul 08
I suppose the NuLabor MPs claim all that money on expenses so they can give it to disadvantaged children? Thats probably what Bendy collected the money for too during her uncontested leadership election...
Posted by: mt on 8:14am Fri 4 Jul 08
The MP's have retained their TAXFREE expenses in return for accepting a below inflation TAXABLE salary increase but are unable to assist the remaining million or so lower paid who are still effected by the 10p tax when the tax system was adjusted to take money from them to give to the better off.

They are clearly in office to tax everything and everyone with the exception of themselves.

Posted by: frank mcbride, lusitania on 8:24am Fri 4 Jul 08
The actual majority was over 300. Thos who didn't vote, in this case, can be deemed spineless supporters of this decision!!!

Why was a free vote allowed on MPs expenses, and not on 42 days detention & the Iraq War, in particular?

Everyone should be aware that the "2nd homefitting allowance" is the equivalent to the GROSS INCOME OF 4 (FOUR) SINGLE PENSIONERS!!!!!!!!!

FOR A FAIRER AND MORE PROSPEROUS SCOTLAND: VOTE SNP.
Posted by: The Wise One, Glasgow on 8:28am Fri 4 Jul 08
This is the same lot of chancers who cheered wildly when Gordon Brown doubled the 10p tax rate for the lowest earners. Well, there will be 5.3 million low earners cheering wildly when this lot get humped at the next general election.

Posted by: Luigi, Aberdeen on 8:31am Fri 4 Jul 08
I just heard on BBC Radio Scotland that as many as one in four mps hire at least one family member in theri office.

This is an absolute outrage - fair enough for pricvate company owners to hire relatives (or whoever they like), but these rogues are using public money. The practice of politicians hiring relatives should be gradually phased out and banned in 10 years. I think the Scottish government should show the way, clear up holyrood as an example and shame westminster into following.

It will be very difficult, since so many politicians have bought into this. However, any party/government that had the courage and conviction to clear up this mess would be onto a real vote-winner.
Posted by: Tony88, Glasgow on 8:36am Fri 4 Jul 08
Why would anyone be surprised by this? It clearly shows that most MP's (mostly Labour) are quite content to keep their noses in the trough and could not give a toss about public opinion. I hope this issue is raised continually at every election from now on, starting with Glasgow East. Let's all bombard them constantly about their greed.
Posted by: robmcdonald, East Kilbride on 8:44am Fri 4 Jul 08
From Douglas "White Feather" Fraser's article which we can't comment on as usual:
Ian Davidson, MP for Glasgow South-West, argued:.... While Labour stands up for Glasgow and invests in its future..........."

That would be Ian Davidson the well known Trough Licker? Holding his hand up for expenses of £24000 a year on a second home that people of Glasgow East can only dream about or read about in articles on MP's.

Black, burning shame on you, the whole disgusting lot of you. You make me retch! May your gods have mercy on you because the voters won't.
Posted by: Van Helsing - Nat Slayer, Lanarkshire on 8:47am Fri 4 Jul 08
Human nature I'm afraid. Let's face it, if all of you moaners had a great expenses/remuneratio
n package in your job and you had the chance to either vote to keep it or lose it, I am sure that you would all happily chose to lose the extra dosh wouldn't you? Aye Right! I'm not saying the trough is right - but if your at it you want to stay at it.
Forget the stage-managed SNP stance. This was a win/win situation for them. Vote against but it still goes through - looks good. Vote against and it doesn't go through - look even better. Finally, the point of posting the MPs names is.....?
Posted by: Van Helsing - Nat Slayer, Lanarkshire on 8:50am Fri 4 Jul 08
Human nature I'm afraid. Let's face it, if all of you moaners had a great expenses/remuneratio
n package in your job and you had the chance to either vote to keep it or lose it, I am sure that you would all happily chose to lose the extra dosh wouldn't you? Aye Right! I'm not saying the trough is right - but if your at it you want to stay at it.
Forget the stage-managed SNP stance. This was a win/win situation for them. Vote against but it still goes through - looks good. Vote against and it doesn't go through - look even better. Finally, the point of posting the MPs names is.....?
Posted by: pete, Bearsden on 9:01am Fri 4 Jul 08
This is disgusting - yet another nail in Labour's coffin.
Posted by: Strathdee, West Lothian on 9:02am Fri 4 Jul 08
Why are these expenses tax free?
Posted by: Lochnagar, Dunfermline on 9:04am Fri 4 Jul 08
It's now evident that many of our MP's have no ethics or morals. I would like to see the names of these spongers plastered across every newspaper.
Posted by: The Scudder, Scotland on 9:07am Fri 4 Jul 08
Don't know what all you folks are complaining about .,,.,.
Have you all forgotten ?
To get their "snouts in the trough" was the only reason for ever going into Politics in the first place ,.,.,. they're ALL bloody crooks !
I've said it before & no doubt will again ,,
Anybody who expresses a wish to go into Politics should be forever BANNED from ever doing so !!
Posted by: Strathdee, West Lothian on 9:07am Fri 4 Jul 08
Van Helsing - Nat Slayer wrote:
Human nature I'm afraid. Let's face it, if all of you moaners had a great expenses/remuneratio n package in your job and you had the chance to either vote to keep it or lose it, I am sure that you would all happily chose to lose the extra dosh wouldn't you? Aye Right! I'm not saying the trough is right - but if your at it you want to stay at it. Forget the stage-managed SNP stance. This was a win/win situation for them. Vote against but it still goes through - looks good. Vote against and it doesn't go through - look even better. Finally, the point of posting the MPs names is.....?
The point of posting the names of the greedy MP's is so that we the electorate know and remember them when we get to the ballot box.

If ordinary workers got these expenses then yes, it would be fair enough. But we don't - that's why it's unfair. If we did, you can bet your &rse HMRC would soon decide these BIK's were taxable. The othere point is that most ordinary workers are not in jobs where we claim to be working in the interests of the poor and disadvantaged. These MP's do exactly that but their actions speak louder than their hollow words.
Posted by: heavy, Glasgow on 9:08am Fri 4 Jul 08
TODAY AT WESTMINSTER AND AROUND THE WORLD

4th July - NEW WORLD ORDER Revolution.
http://www.youtube.c
om/watch?v=3Lxcq8fGY
9w

LJPR LEGAL JUDICIAL POLITICAL REFORMERS

Steps to a jury and democracy

(1) we demand our Right to Trial by Jury in any action
(2) the Judiciary deny us that Right
(3) we deny that they have the power to do so by saying, "I do not consent to be without a Jury and I Challenge the Jurisdiction of the Court."
(4) a Jury determines the Jurisdiction of the Court (of which a Judge is an Officer) and
(5) once a Jury overrules the Judge, the TRIAL re-commences BY JURY
Posted by: Andrew, Scotland on 9:24am Fri 4 Jul 08
What amazes me in the current circumstances is the way the people of the UK just appear to let all this happen with little or no protest! Are we all to frightened or to lazy to publicly demand change? I am afraid a change of MP in Glasgow East or anywhere else will change little in our corrupt political system. Just some other new snout for the trough. If 'everyone' in Glasgow East votes for someone other than New Labour then yes we might have a new PM but a change for the better in the longer term, I doubt it. Lets see the people in the streets protesting a bit more that might change things.
Posted by: bluenose, Glasgow on 9:25am Fri 4 Jul 08
I would like to know which Scottish MPs voted for and those that voted against , and those that abstained and in doing so actually voted yes
Posted by: John Clark on 9:32am Fri 4 Jul 08
These people make laws. Yes?

Now, who the Donald Duck is going to uphold laws that they make? NOBODY is going to listen to these people. They have lost all respect and ALL authority they had by virtue of this idiotic vote. Its blatant greed - and greed of the worst type. These people are just human manure. The Labour Party have committed electoral suicide.

BROWN allowed a free vote. HE allowed them to vote that way. How can he possibly survive now?

DSS scroungers? Well, there will be a lot more doing that now eh? Do you blame them reader? Do you blame people for avoiding and not paying tax and national insurance after that vote?

Posted by: Los Angeles, Edinburgh on 9:32am Fri 4 Jul 08

Vin Reisling - Nose Picker
Finally, the point of posting the MPs names is.....?
The accountability of elected representatives in an open democracy.

Next question.

Posted by: Jimmy Mac, Shetland on 9:37am Fri 4 Jul 08
Only half of the Commons voted. Gordon Brown didn't even bother to turn up, which shows the disdain - or is it contempt - these charlatans have for the electorate.
Posted by: les vegas, glasgow on 9:38am Fri 4 Jul 08
Are you honestly trying to tell me that the whole of Shettleston will be away on holiday for the Fair Fortnight?? Aye right...!! Shows you how out of touch our "esteemed" leaders are when they think that all the poor, the unemployed, minimum wage earners/junkies/down and outs etc. etc... will all be off to Benidorm for a fortnight!! laughable if it wasn't so tragic.
Posted by: sam, greenock on 9:43am Fri 4 Jul 08
Los Angeles wrote:
From the tone of comments on this and other forums discussing their resistence to accountability, it's clear they have no idea of the public mood, or how deep it runs.
LA,
I think they know fine well how the public feel, they're just saying fek yooz to the public
Posted by: Edward, Edinburgh on 9:44am Fri 4 Jul 08
bluenose wrote:
I would like to know which Scottish MPs voted for and those that voted against , and those that abstained and in doing so actually voted yes
These are the ones that voted for :
Gordon Banks (Ochil & Perthshire South),
Tom Clarke (Coatbridge, Chryston & Bellshill),
Michael Connarty (Linlithgow & Falkirk East),
Ian Davidson (Glasgow South West),
Brian Donohoe (Ayrshire Central),
David Hamilton (Midlothian),
Jimmy Hood (Lanark & Hamilton East),
Adam Ingram (East Kilbride, Strathaven & Lesmahagow),
Eric Joyce (Falkirk),
Tommy McAvoy (Rutherglen & Hamilton West),
James McGovern (Dundee West),
Anne McGuire (Stirling),
Rosemary McKenna (Cumbernauld, Kilsyth & Kirkintilloch East),
Sandra Osborne (Ayr, Carrick & Cumnock),
John Robertson (Glasgow North West),
Jimmy Sheridan (Paisley & Renfrewshire North),
Gavin Strang (Edinburgh East)
All Labour
No other Scottish MP voted for
apparently the other Scottish Labour MP's abstained
Posted by: murpho, glasgow on 9:46am Fri 4 Jul 08
Well, isn't it nice to see the self preservation society alive and well in our seat of Government. Mr Brown, Mr Darling et al are constantly in the newspapers and on TV telling us things are going to get worse with regards to the economy and that we must ride the pain in order to survive this. Now, here we have a group of Parliamentarians who were given the opportunity to 'share the pain' of their constituents - guess what - they chose to keep their highly criticised expenses format, keeping them safe from the impacts of current economic crises!

This decision is both disappointing and short-sighted. Politicians should remember they ARE accountable to the electorate - yes they can vote to keep an unfair expenses system, however we can also vote - to remove them from Parliament!

The Labour Government have chosen to ignore the warning signs - fuel protests, council election failures, by election disasters - but still chose to vote in this manner (well the vast majority of those who chose to protect these payments did).

With regards to the MPs mortgage subsidy scheme for a second property in London, if we as taxpayers are paying a proportion of the mortgage cost, then surely a similar proportion of the proceeds of the sale should be recouped by the Treasury?

As a lifelong Labour voter I am now becoming extremely disillusioned with regards to where the party is heading. Sadly though, I find it impossible to find a credible alternative among the other parties!
Posted by: Edward, Edinburgh on 9:47am Fri 4 Jul 08
les vegas wrote:
Are you honestly trying to tell me that the whole of Shettleston will be away on holiday for the Fair Fortnight?? Aye right...!! Shows you how out of touch our "esteemed" leaders are when they think that all the poor, the unemployed, minimum wage earners/junkies/down and outs etc. etc... will all be off to Benidorm for a fortnight!! laughable if it wasn't so tragic.
I would interpret it that the whole of those in employment and earning will be away, leaving those not earning etc to vote
Posted by: sam, Fort William on 9:49am Fri 4 Jul 08
Donald Anderson wrote:
The John Maclean March Hey Mac did ye see him as he cam in by Gorgie, Awa ower the Lammerlaw and north o’ the Tay? Yon man is comin’ and the hale toon is turnin’ oot, We’re aa’ sair he’ll win back tae Glasga the day. The jiners and hauders-on are marchin’ fae Clydebank, Come noo an’ hear him, he’ll be ower thrang tae bide. Turn oot Jock and Jimmie, leave yer cranes an’ yer muckle gantries Great John Maclean’s comin’ back tae the Clyde. Argyle Street and London Road’s the route that we’re mairchin’ The lads frae the Broomielaw are oot tae a man. Hey, Neil, whaur’s yer hoderums, ye big Hielan teuchter?. Get yer pipes, mate, and march at the heid o’the clan! Hallo Pat Malone, I knew ye’d be here, son The red and green, my lads, we’ll wear side by side, The Gorbals is his the day and Glasgae belangs tae him, Noo great John Maclean’s comin’ hame tae the Clyde. It’s forward tae Glasga Green we’ll mairch in guid order, Will grips his banner weel, that boy isna blate, Aye there man, that’s Johnny noo, that’s him, aye, the bonnie fechter Lenin’s his fere, Mac, and Leibnecht’s his mate. Tak tent when he’s speakin’ for they’ll mind whit wis said here In Glasgae our city and the hale world besides. Tha’s richt, lads, the scarlet’s bonnie, here’s tae ye Hielan’ Shonie! Oor John Maclean has come hame to the Clyde. An weel when it’s ower, I’ll awa hame tae Springburn, Come hame tae yer tea noo, John, we’ll soon hae ye fed! It’s hard wark the speakin’, an I’m sair ye’ll be tired the nicht, I’ll sleep on the flair, Mac, and gie John the bed. The hale city’s quiet noo, It kens that he’s restin’ Hame wi’ his Glasga freens, the fame and their pride. The red will be worn, my lads, and Scotland will rise again, Noo great John Maclean has come hame tae the Clyde. John MacLean, 1879-1923, Stood for a Scottish Workers Republic Q. What does Labour stand for? A. The Queen. Q. What does Labour stand for?
A. The Queen.

Izzat ye on aboot Davy Cairns again?
Posted by: sam, greenock on 9:51am Fri 4 Jul 08