logo
   Web Issue 3203 July 19 2008   
spacer
Speaking from experience: Bob Holman on fellowship
BOB HOLMANMay 13 2008

The annual conference of the Social Workers Christian Fellowship (SWCF) is one I always attend. I identify strongly with my colleagues in the SWCF. None are rich. All are committed to siding with the most vulnerable members of society.

A chartered accountant happened to attend this year with his wife, who is a member. He said that he had never been in a group which so genuinely cared for each other.

We need each other's mutual support, criticisms and love. I call this fellowship. Years ago, I found this sense of togetherness within the Labour party as we promoted socialism. No longer.

Wendy Alexander says she will fight the SNP with socialism. Once again, I ask her what she means by socialism. She should go back to Richard Tawney, the great socialist whose classic book Equality (1931) shaped the politics of countless readers. In his classic biography R H Tawney and His Times, Ross Terrill gives Tawney's book a significant sub-title, Socialism as fellowship.

Tawney wanted a massive redistribution of income and wealth because he believed it wrong that some enjoyed luxury while others suffered poverty. In addition, he argued that inequality divides society, allowing some to lord it over others. Fellowship is destroyed by inequality.

He added that equality was the necessary condition for people to be in the right relationships with one another, in which they treated others with respect and kindness. Socialism is about fellowship.

Tawney saw a forerunner in these bonds between those who pursued socialism, those Labour supporters who shared a sense of collective purpose. It was this fellowship within the Labour party that I found so attractive in the 1960s and 70s.

What has happened to it? New Labour, under Blair and Brown, abandoned socialism for the free market. Not surprisingly, local membership and its sense of fellowship collapsed. But the effects have gone wider.

The Joseph Rowntree Foundation has published the results of an extensive survey about today's social evils. These are seen as a decline in community, a growth in selfish individualism, the spread of excessive greed and a reduction in shared values.

Of course, there are many explanations as to why these evils have flourished, but the respondents particularly point the finger at government.

In my understanding, by replacing the values of socialism by those of almost unfettered capitalism, New Labour has encouraged greed, undermined public services, neglected communities, glorified fat cats and increased inequality. Fellowship has been damaged in the party but also in society.

Not just Labour. In Scotland, the SNP is in power and it remains to be seen whether it offers not just pieces of legislation, but a philosophy that goes beyond nationalism and which can bind people together.

There is hope. At the SWCF meeting, there were young people - none of them members of the Labour party - who were committed to serving others even though this meant they would never be affluent.

Perhaps the tide is turning and the evil of personal greed can be challenged by the desire for collective fellowship.

  • Bob Holman is a retired professor of social policy and a community worker in Easterhouse, Glasgow.


  • © All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


    Related Links

    Posted by: SC on 9:41pm Mon 12 May 08
    I think this poor, deluded, defeated, fellow should read a bit of Adam Smith (or The Economist at least).

    If everyone just gets on with their lives, intefering with no-one, taking no money from others save for services rendered, we will have one smashing "society".

    Thankfully, modern Scotland has learnt from the socialist mistakes of the past, and is looking forward to a future based on work and prosperity - not glorified, perpetual poverty.

    Thanks to the oldtimers for teaching us those important lessons.
    Posted by: Hugh Kerr, Edinburgh on 12:05am Tue 13 May 08
    SC you are not fit to tie Bob Holmans shoe laces never mind disparage his column.Bob has in his life as an academic and a community worker has understood more about society than you and acted to change it for the better.
    As for Bob of course you are right about socialist values but why continue to look for them in the Labour Party, Wendy Alexander is not likely to provide them the only job she has done in the real world was as a consultant specialising in the privatisation of public services.The SNP are of course also a free market party but they do have a kind of social democratic ethos.An independent Scotland wont be socialist but it might be more like scandinavia than the USA and that cant be bad.
    Posted by: actvj, glasgow on 9:40am Tue 13 May 08
    No matter how you try to paint it, regardless of your political view, our society is becoming more selfish, alienated, vicious, violent, greedy, uncaring and with little sign of an answer or remedy to these ills. Sure we can point to instances of altruism and acts of heroism and fellowship. As a society fellowship is laughed at and seen as the pleading of the weak, when in fact it is the route that requires inner strength. I'm afraid our UK National Politicians of whatever hue have shown themselves to be masters of the grab as opposed to servants of the give. As one brought up to detest the SNP on religous grounds (only in the west of Scotland?) it apears to me now as an adult that they are about the only ones who are further from the grab and slightly nearer the give. I agree with Bob Holman that it is now the time for collective fellowship to challenge the personal greed of our system. Ther is no other option, we've tried the rest and they have failed.
    ps. A plasma screen in every house does not a society make
    Posted by: Observer, Glasgow on 7:50pm Tue 13 May 08
    The plasma screen in every house and the ''tide of personal greed'' has largely been financed by credit. You don't need to be Nostradamus to figure out what happens next. There are immensely practical reasons for living in fellowship with each other. The political party that can harness that feeling instead of kow towing to the market place could get a landslide tomorrow. People are largely fed up with a shallow drifting society, but they don't know what to do about it.
    Add your comment
    Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
    Email:
    Password:
    spacer
     IN YOUR AREA
     
    Herald Appointments - Every Friday
    Travel Shop
    Airport Parking
    Travel Insurance
    Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
    Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use