logo
   Web Issue 3149 May 17 2008   
spacer
Speaking from experience: Bob Holman on racism
BOB HOLMANApril 22 2008

Forty years ago, when Enoch Powell delivered his "rivers of blood" speech, I was a lecturer in Birmingham. Of course, racism was widespread at the time - but Powell put his finger on a button that unleashed fear and fury.

At one meeting, I tried to debate with him. I can still see his bulging eyes and sweating face as he tore me to bits.

Handsworth was the district with the highest number of what were then called "residents born in New Commonwealth countries" - in other words, black people. I helped as a volunteer and met mothers who said that the lack of daycare stopped them getting jobs - and then they were blamed for living off the state. We acted together to found a daycare centre which, all these years later, still exists.

Have things got better? In some ways. The churches are now more likely to criticise racism than reinforce it. More black people are in managerial, professional and political posts, although not enough. Ours is still a society in which it is an advantage to be born white.

Racism always finds some outlet. As a boy, I recall the baiting of Jewish people in east London. Years later, Sir Keith Joseph - in some ways a humane man - asked me if the Irish really were "breeding like rabbits". Then arrivals from the West Indies became the focus of attack. Today the targets are economic migrants from eastern Europe and asylum seekers fleeing from persecution.

Many politicians are supporters of racial equality. Yet in May 2007, Labour Party minister Margaret Hodge proposed that local, British-born families should get social housing over new immigrants. The Conservative immigration spokesman Damian Green agreed and added that his party was calling for an explicit annual limit on the number of immigrants.

Both Hodge and Green failed to point out that the shortage of public accommodation stemmed from Margaret Thatcher's policy of selling off council housing.

Last week in Glasgow, I visited the excellent Positive Action in Housing, a voluntary agency that concentrates on supporting immigrants and asylum seekers. Last year, 123 of its users, 18% of the total, reported racial harassment, including repeated verbal abuse, physical attacks, damage to property and an arson attack. Victims often felt they could not go out at night, kept their children from using public play areas and sometimes asked to be re-housed. Positive Action has responded by working with immigrants, asylum seekers and agencies to create the confidence and knowledge to enable victims to report incidents to the police. One result is that the Glasgow Housing Association has improved the training of concierges and frontline staff.

As a boy in London, a young man in Birmingham and an old man in Glasgow, I realise that immigrants from different cultures and of different appearance can provoke hostility. Yet they can also bring about unity. In the church I attend, an African family became part of the body. One Sunday, they announced they had been granted asylum. We wept and cheered.

In Cardonald, a family from a war-divided state were suddenly removed by immigration officials. But their children had become so integrated into the school and community that it was residents who campaigned for their return.

Racism must be countered and unity promoted at the grass roots. Politicians should be there.

  • Bob Holman is a retired professor of social policy and community worker in Easterhouse, Glasgow.


  • © All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


    Posted by: Carnwarth on 7:58pm Mon 21 Apr 08
    I wonder if Professor Holman is surprised that it is New Labour thugs who terrorise children in dawn raids and that it is Trevor Phillips who has picked up Powell's torch.
    Posted by: alicmurray, Glasgow on 10:33pm Mon 21 Apr 08
    Positive Action on Housing is an organisation that was used for the ambitions of it s director Ms Quereshi. They do nothing but duplicate work done by others. Let Mr Holman's church pay for asylum seekers and economic migrants I for one have a severe case of compassion fatigue.
    Posted by: Kiera Hardie on 11:49pm Mon 21 Apr 08
    Bloomin' eck! The one thing you can't say about Positive Action in Housing is that it duplicates work done by others.

    Robina Qureshi is a true original. A wee bit scary mad (I mean that in a nice way), sure, but she is the real deal, a shining star.

    Positive Action takes on the jobs that the state doesn't. They do it for not a lot of money, and they save lives. They certainly put the begrudgers like alicmurray to shame, and you know what we say about begrudgers.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 1:07am Tue 22 Apr 08
    BOB HOLMAN writes:-

    Last week in Glasgow, I visited the excellent Positive Action in Housing, a voluntary agency that concentrates on supporting immigrants and asylum seekers.


    Excellent? - should be contemptible.
    voluntary? - over a £million received in funding.
    immigrants and asylum seekers? - should be failed asylum seekers and illegal immigrants.

    This ‘‘charity’’ was set up some thirteen years ago to create housing allocation (jumping the queue) for the so called ‘‘ethnic minorities’’. The initial reasons for establishing this charity are now defunct. Any attempts to give ethnic minorities, or anyone else, preferential treatment in housing allocation is discriminating and may even be racist against other house seekers.

    From the Scottish Executive, PAiH received £227,393 of taxpayers’ money from 2003-2006. They also received £92,677 from Communities Scotland over a similar period. We finance this ’’charity‘‘ to carry on their hostilities against our society. The Scottish Executive should withdraw funding to this charity.

    PAiH is now being used as a base to support failed asylum seekers. Once the Border and Immigration Agency (BIA) has made a legal decision that failed asylum seeking families have no right to be here and should be deported, Executive Director, Robina Qureshi and her tax-funded team swing into action. We get the usual harassment of our Immigration Officers to stop them from carrying out the law. The PAiH website and media is used to throw out the usual insulting bile at our Immigration Officials. Qureshi refers to the actions of our Home Office and Immigration Officials as ‘‘brutal, humiliating dawn raids / dawn raid teams, vans / immigration snatch squads / men in riot gear who arrive in their black people-carriers with the built in cages to carry out dawn raids / thugs with warrant cards’’ and refers to ‘‘doors being booted in by metal battering rams and children being dragged out screaming’’. Free from the fear of Ms Qureshi and her barrage of insults perhaps more of our City Councillors, MSP’s and MP’s would take action to stop farther immigration to this city and remove those who have no right to be here.

    This money-guzzling defunct ‘‘charity’’ should starved of funding and booted out of existence.
    Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 6:03am Tue 22 Apr 08
    It was London dockers and Midland car workers who struck and marched for Enoch Powell.
    Posted by: Kiera Hardie on 7:42am Tue 22 Apr 08
    What's your point, Donald Anderson? To think this wee bachle used to be allowed to teach his chauvinistic hatred in our schools.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 9:03am Tue 22 Apr 08
    BOB HOLMAN writes:-

    Many politicians are supporters of racial equality. Yet in May 2007, Labour Party minister Margaret Hodge proposed that local, British-born families should get social housing over new immigrants.


    Bob Holman, are you actually proposing that ‘local British-born families’ should have to wait in the housing queue alongside ‘new immigrants’? This of course could also bring about a situation whereby ‘local British-born families’ could end up still waiting whilst ‘new immigrants’ are housed.

    Bob Holman, why do you despise the indigenous British white people? You come over as another non-achiever who blames the people around him for his failure.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 9:20am Tue 22 Apr 08
    Carnworth wrote:-

    I wonder if Professor Holman is surprised that it is New Labour thugs who terrorise children in dawn raids and that it is Trevor Phillips who has picked up Powell's torch.


    There is no such happening as a ‘dawn raid’. The failed asylum seekers have had their claims to stay in Britain heard and rejected. Our immigration officers are merely turning up at the accommodation (ours) of the failed asylum seekers to carry out the law - to legally deport the legally failed asylum seekers.

    Got it? Do you understand?
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 9:32am Tue 22 Apr 08
    Kiera Hardie posted:-

    They certainly put the begrudgers like alicmurray to shame, and you know what we say about begrudgers.


    What DO ‘‘we’’ say about begrudgers? (so-called)

    I agree with alicmuray. Let Mr Holman's church and asylum supporters pay for asylum seekers and economic migrants. The money they give wouldn’t keep the immigrants in booze and fags.
    Posted by: John Allan, Glasgow on 10:04am Tue 22 Apr 08
    "From the Scottish Executive, PAiH received £227,393 of taxpayers’ money from 2003-2006. They also received £92,677 from Communities Scotland over a similar period. We finance this ’’charity‘‘ to carry on their hostilities against our society. The Scottish Executive should withdraw funding to this charity." Do you not have any up-to-date figures?

    I think this voluntary organisation does a fantastic job! Their work is unique and the amount of people using their service proves that they are not duplicating anything, where else would people go to get this service Alicmurray?
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 12:16pm Tue 22 Apr 08
    To John Allan et al:-

    BLOCKEM (me) posted:-

    Nothing like the mention of PAiH money to bring about the deletion of a posted comment.


    Told you. Our comments alluding to Robina Qureshi and PAiH finance have been deleted.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 12:23pm Tue 22 Apr 08
    Watch out for Michael Woods who represents Positive Action in Housing.

    Next underhand tactic will be for Woodsie to post malicious insulting postings using my monicker of ‘‘BLOCKEM’’

    Excellent charity - I think not.
    Posted by: Kiera Hardie on 7:00pm Tue 22 Apr 08
    What DO ‘‘we&#82
    17;’ say about begrudgers?
    We say feck 'em. Feck the begrudgers.
    Posted by: JamesM on 10:18pm Tue 22 Apr 08
    My concern about Positive Action in Housing is that they seem to be purely a lobby group for immigrants facing removal from the UK. That's fine as it is, but they seem to have little to do with the housing issue. I don't know if Robina Qureshi is nuts or not, but she does seem to be an unreconstructed sheridanite, if testimony from Tommy's trial is to be believed. Better looking than Tommy, though. Less hairy.

    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 10:18pm Tue 22 Apr 08
    Kiera Hardie drivelled:-

    What DO ‘‘we&#82

    17;’ say about begrudgers?

    We say feck 'em. Feck the begrudgers.


    With a peanut brain like yours and extremely limited rhetoric, who cares what you say about anything.
    Posted by: Kiera Hardie on 10:52pm Tue 22 Apr 08
    The expression Feck the begrudgers is a time honoured saying in the far west of Europe. Google it and learn.
    Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 4:20am Wed 23 Apr 08
    Posted by: Kiera Hardie on 7:42am Tue 22 Apr 08
    What's your point, Donald Anderson? To think this wee bachle used to be allowed to teach his chauvinistic hatred in our schools.
    What's your point, Donald Anderson? To think this wee bachle used to be allowed to teach his chauvinistic hatred in our schools.
    Posted by: Donald Anderson, glasgow on 4:22am Wed 23 Apr 08
    Posted by: Kiera Hardie on 7:42am Tue 22 Apr 08
    What's your point, Donald Anderson? To think this wee bachle used to be allowed to teach his chauvinistic hatred in our schools.
    What's your point, Donald Anderson? To think this wee bachle used to be allowed to teach his chauvinistic hatred in our schools.
    Waht is yOUr pibt here?

    Enoch once said that "power devolved was power detained". It is a fact that English workers downed tools to support his racist views.
    Posted by: Carnwarth on 9:09am Wed 23 Apr 08
    BLOCKEM wrote:
    Carnworth wrote:-
    I wonder if Professor Holman is surprised that it is New Labour thugs who terrorise children in dawn raids and that it is Trevor Phillips who has picked up Powell's torch.
    There is no such happening as a ‘dawn raid’. The failed asylum seekers have had their claims to stay in Britain heard and rejected. Our immigration officers are merely turning up at the accommodation (ours) of the failed asylum seekers to carry out the law - to legally deport the legally failed asylum seekers. Got it? Do you understand?
    I know exactly where you are coming from but what I am not clear on is why so many racists (you, Wullie, but not, he claims, the anti-immigrant Skunnurt) target the Herald.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 10:28am Wed 23 Apr 08
    Carnwarth posted:-

    I know exactly where you are coming from but what I am not clear on is why so many racists (you, Wullie, but not, he claims, the anti-immigrant Skunnurt) target the Herald.


    You have no idea where I’m coming from. You fail understand the immigration issue has nothing to do with racism - it’s to do with economy.

    I do not ‘‘target’’ The Herald, I reply to articles and comments covering asylum and immigration.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 10:31am Wed 23 Apr 08
    Kiera Hardie posted:-

    The expression Feck the begrudgers is a time honoured saying in the far west of Europe. Google it and learn.


    How can anyone really expect others to attach any credibility to their statements when they include such garbage as ‘‘Feck the begrudgers’’.

    ‘‘Google it and learn’’ ........ Bin it and forget.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 11:44am Wed 23 Apr 08
    JamesM posted:-

    My concern about Positive Action in Housing is that they seem to be purely a lobby group for immigrants facing removal from the UK. That's fine as it is, but they seem to have little to do with the housing issue. I don't know if Robina Qureshi is nuts or not, but she does seem to be an unreconstructed sheridanite, if testimony from Tommy's trial is to be believed. Better looking than Tommy, though. Less hairy.


    That’s precisely the Positive Action in Housing agenda. Robina Qureshi refuses to accept the legal decisions of Britain‘s courts of law and PAiH actively intervene to prohibit the legal deportation of legally failed asylum seekers.

    Examples ........

    PAiH appeals for, and arranges housing accommodation to conceal failed asylum seekers (now illegal immigrants) who have made themselves destitute (absconded) to avoid deportation.

    From their website PAiH urges asylum supporters to contact airlines which are being used to deport failed asylum seekers to disrupt the deportations.

    Robina Qureshi openly condoned the actions of the asylum seekers’ supporters who blocked Immigration Officials from removing failed asylum seekers.

    Robina Qureshi is undermining and challenging the laws our society. She is a constant heckler of our Government and Scottish Executive. All a bit ironic when her salary and expense account are paid from the wage packets of the society which she continually castigates.
    Posted by: Printanor, Glasgow on 5:50pm Wed 23 Apr 08
    Hooray for Positive Action in Housing, which speaks up when other organisations are too fearty. Hooray for Robina Qureshi, who calls on every resource she can find to rustle up hand-outs for people left destitute by Britain's inhumane asylum system. (Which frequently *gets it wrong*, Blockem and others - which is why some of us challenge it)
    And above all - hooray for Kiera Hardie, whose battle-cry 'Feck the begrudgers' will be adopted by this reader henceforth whenever he needs cheering up.
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 9:08pm Wed 23 Apr 08
    Printanor posted:-

    Hooray for Positive Action in Housing, which speaks up when other organisations are too fearty. Hooray for Robina Qureshi, who calls on every resource she can find to rustle up hand-outs for people left destitute by Britain's inhumane asylum system. (Which frequently *gets it wrong*, Blockem and others - which is why some of us challenge it)
    And above all - hooray for Kiera Hardie, whose battle-cry 'Feck the begrudgers' will be adopted by this reader henceforth whenever he needs cheering up.

    Boo for Positive Action in Housing, which speaks up when they are asking for donations. Boo for Robina Qureshi, who calls on every underhand tactic she can find to rustle up hidey-holes for people who opt to go destitute and abscond from Britain's humane asylum system. (Which always gets it right, Printanor and others - which is why we support our fine, upstanding and caring immigration officers)
    And above all? (you obviously don’t have a high opinion of PAiH) - boo for Kiera Hardie, whose battle-cry 'Fetch the beefburgers' will be adopted by Printanor henceforth whenever he needs fattening up.
    Posted by: Printanor, Glasgow on 4:54pm Thu 24 Apr 08
    Oh, Blockem, you are a wag!
    Posted by: BLOCKEM, Glasgow on 5:19pm Thu 24 Apr 08
    Oh, Printanor, you need gag!
    Add your comment
    Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
    Email:
    Password:




    spacer
     IN YOUR AREA
     
    Herald Appointments - Every Friday
    Travel Shop
    Airport Parking
    Travel Insurance
    Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
    Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use