logo
   Web Issue 3149 May 17 2008   
spacer
SNP a step closer to power

Scotland does not have a government yet, although a step towards the formation of an administration was taken yesterday when the SNP struck a deal with the Scottish Greens to work together at Holyrood. But a new lexicon is already evolving to describe and define the new political era. The phrase confidence and supply has achieved a cachet at Holyrood and among observers of the parliament without an administration. It is a product of proportional representation in the electoral process and has a habit of resulting in coalition or minority government. Scotland is heading towards the latter option, with Alex Salmond as First Minister.

Under a confidence and supply agreement, the minor party supports the majority partner in the event of a vote of confidence in an administration lacking a majority and in the vote on its budget (the supply element). These are, broadly, the two areas where a vote, going the wrong way for an administration, can bring it down. Confidence and supply can be a comfort or reassurance for the major partner seeking to push through its policies. For the minor partner, the agreement can give an enhanced opportunity to advance its agenda.

The SNP-Green deal is not strictly a confidence and supply agreement. It will ensure that the two Green MSPs will vote for Mr Salmond as First Minister. This should ensure his appointment if, as expected, the Scottish Liberal Democrats and Conservatives abstain in the vote. In return, the Nationalists will endorse a climate change Bill as an early priority and nominate a Green MSP to chair a Holyrood committee (under the rules they have too few MSPs to chair a committee in their own right).

Will this looser arrangement work, or will it be a recipe for instability? It does mean that the Greens cannot join Labour in a minority coalition administration, effectively Jack McConnell's last hope of forming a government, given the decision of the Liberal Democrats not to jump into bed with his party again and the refusal of the Scottish Conservatives to coalesce with anyone. There are policy areas where the SNP and the Greens could rub along nicely together but there are others where they are poles apart, notably transport. Mr Salmond has to pay a price for securing the support of the two Greens but he must not allow the tail to wag the dog, especially on projects such as the M74 extension that are vital for the economy but which the Greens oppose.

Mr Salmond suggested inadvertently another addition to the lexicon earlier this week when he said that the SNP would have to be nimble of brain and light of foot to govern effectively at Holyrood. The neophyte Nationalists will have to be that and more if they are to pass the test of government.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Ted on 9:34pm Fri 11 May 07
Shame on the Herald. The M74 extension is not even necessary to Glasgow in the sense that a fish can need a bicycle. It will gut the southeast of the city, aggravate congestion, aggravate pollution, and cause massive economic hardship.
Posted by: Sandy Campbell on 9:52pm Fri 11 May 07
The SNP should drop the M74. Ted is right the Public Inquiry said it wouldn't work and the up to a billion saved on it could fund Edinburgh Tram and Crossrail in both Edinburgh and Glasgow.
Posted by: DJ, Glasgow on 11:49pm Fri 11 May 07
Quality article Herald. It is now required of political parties to behave maturely. The SNP have to produce bills which can gain the majority consent of the parlaiment. Labour have to realise Scotand has changed and not be dogmatic.The people will judge again in four years. Principle and pragmatism will be rewarded. Dogma will be rightly punished.
Posted by: DJ, Glasgow on 11:55pm Fri 11 May 07
For parlaiment read parliament. Apologies for that spelling error - a few pints!
Posted by: Brian Blessed, Glasgow on 1:28am Sat 12 May 07
I am an SNP supporter, but hope that the Greens can push the SNP govt towards cancelling the M74. I am not against road building per se, but £500m on 5 miles of motorway, destroying the South Side of Glasgow in the process, for next to no benefit, is not a good use of Exec funding.

£500m could sort out Greater Glasgow's public transport for a generation - Crossrail, zero-emission buses, ClydeLink and much more - why blow it on vanity projects?
Posted by: murray smith, glasgow on 2:51am Sat 12 May 07
News headline:

Labour jump into bed with Lib-dems.

The Parliament will be asked to vote for 4 candidates for FM next week - Salmond, Stephen, McConnell and Goldie. It is very possible that Labour will vote for Nichol Stephen making a total of 62 votes (Tories abstain) against SNP/Greens 49 (Tories and Lib-dems abstain)

We could end up with a Lab-Lib-dem minority coalition with Nichol Stephen as FM and Labour taking the majority of the rest of the Cabinet positions.
Posted by: donald anderson, glasgow on 7:04am Sat 12 May 07
Pity the Greens excellent ideas do not take into account the backward state of Scotland's raods and poor transport infrastructure.

Even the EU and UN acknowledge these poor links in the modern world.
Posted by: Mac, Dundee on 9:06am Sat 12 May 07
The SNP doesn't need the Labour Herald to tell it how to run the Scottish Executive. The test that the SNP need pass is not to run the executive like the previous, and now discredited, Labour/LibDem administration.
Posted by: tcswim, Fife on 9:22am Sat 12 May 07
'It teks a long spoon tae sup wi a fly Fifer' With GB & Ming now we have two. GB needs the LibDams in order to try and hold on to Westminister after next election. Ming wants power soon. Deals will be /have been done. Wait and see.
AS should let the Thanes of Fife & Union Jack win authority In Edinburgh next week and the SNP will have more power across Scotland than they could ever imagine.

tcswim Fife
Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use