logo
   Web Issue 3198 July 20 2008   
spacer
Welcome to new Scots
EDITORIAL COMMENTApril 27 2007

If there is a lesson from the latest Scottish population statistics, published yesterday, it is that Scotland needs its immigrants as much as they need us. Ever since Scotland's population first reached 5,000,000 in 1939, it has remained relatively stable. It is the make-up of that figure that has changed dramatically. Take 1950, a year when the tally of inhabitants was close to the latest total of 5,116,900. Today, more than 382,000 people in Scotland are 75 or over, while the number of those under 20, whose taxes and National Insurance contributions will be required to support them, is only 1,200,000. The equivalent figures for 1950 were fewer than 163,000 over-75s and more than 1,600,000 under-20s. It is an issue that First Minister Jack McConnell once described as the biggest single challenge facing Scotland.

We hear less about "the demographic timebomb" now than four years ago, when the registrar-general predicted the population would slump below the psychologically significant threshold of 5,000,000 by 2009. In the event, the population has risen each year since 2002. Two factors are responsible for this change. The most significant is the net inflow of predominantly young people coming to Scotland from both other areas of the UK and overseas, particularly the accession countries of the European Union. And, for the first time in many years, the number of births is edging up, while there are fewer deaths, thanks to advances in medical care. As a result, the gap between the two narrowed to just 300 last year. The figures do not tell us how many of these babies were born into immigrant families, though anecdotal evidence suggests that this is a factor in Scotland's recovering birthrate. Scotland's demographic timebomb may not have been defused but, as suggested in The Herald today, it has been "recalibrated".

However, we need to take account of these changes in the planning and provision of services. Many are already experiencing difficulties accessing decent affordable housing. If immigrant families are prepared to stay and put down roots, this has implications for everything from midwifery services and GP surgeries to school building and the recruitment of social workers. They deserve it. In general, immigration reduces wage and inflationary pressures and lowers unemployment, especially in the Scottish catering and hotel industries, where labour shortages are perennial. Immigrants are helping to rejuvenate towns and cities such as Fort William and Inverness. Their taxes and National Insurance contributions help to pay for public services and many also work in those services. If there is a failure in policy, it is in the comparatively small proportion of immigrants to Scotland working in "high-end" skilled jobs, especially business. A challenge to the next Holyrood administration will be to overcome the constraints of UK immigration policy and build on the modest success of the Fresh Talent initiative.


© All rights reserved. Reproduction in whole or in part without permission is prohibited.


Posted by: Jimmy, Glasgow on 9:23pm Thu 26 Apr 07
What about the indiginous population?

I have been unemployed for 2 years and have applied for over 2000 jobs all over the country. Of those 2000+ 1 actually bothered to reply.

New Labour are only interested in you if you are a minority of some sort.
Posted by: Robert, Glasgow on 11:21pm Thu 26 Apr 07
Jimmy, did you really apply for 2000 jobs?
Are you applying for jobs you are actually qualified to do or are you a troll posting nonsense?

When I arrived to this country I found a job in 3 weeks, despite my English being rather poor and lacking a University degree. After 8 years, I am now a high-rate tax payer and have a degree, all paid by myself, no funding. Hard work pays off. Get it?

There are plenty of vacancies in catering, tourism, social services and road maintenance and contact centres, just to name a handful of sectors. What’s your problem?

Stop complaining and get a bloody job, you lazy bum.
Posted by: iang, Glasgow on 9:03am Fri 27 Apr 07
#2 has a point in that thanks to successive governments we now have a culture where it is acceptable to live off benefit for some people, with 3 generations of the same families never having had a job.

but

#1 also has a point. As an employer I have seen many people who have many skills and years of experiance unable to get a job. I, hopefully am doing my bit but I am sure that it is tough for some people when employers are more happy to take someone from abroad rather than give a local person the chance. Thanks to reporting in the media the perception is that people here do not want to work, which is not the normal case.
Posted by: A.H., Glasgow on 8:03am Sun 29 Apr 07
There isn't much work around at the moment. There's a lot of inflamatory comment in the press about British people not wanting work, or smearing the people as lazy etc, but that's not my experience at all. It just strikes me as a - very poor - argument in favour of continued high levels of immigration no matter what the cost to the Scottish people. But then look at the aggression in post 2 above from Robert - he reveals a pretty nasty attitude towards the country he has adopted, and to its people. Not all immigrants are welcome. I'd happy release that one back to where he came from.
Posted by: Mr T, South on 12:24am Thu 17 May 07
Robert,

You may have found a job in 3 weeks albeit a job that probably exploited your services, i.e. underpaid etc... It is easier for foreigners to find work because most services especially catering and tourism look for foreign individuals like yourself, so they don't pay the going rate, social services require experience and qualifications, so if you have no job how can you pay for the courses? also Road maintenance (Labouring) require you to have a CSCS or CIS card now which requires registeration, foreigners can get away with this because they are not in a position to question, also another service that was easy to get into is Security - you even require an SIA licence which requires registeration and a course which costs just under £200, how can you afford this with no job and only £50 a week benefits?

The Police service are only recruiting for blacks, asians etc... so no white citizen has a chance in hell to work for the police.

hmm... Yeh REALLY easy to find work so far, right?

The rate most employers pay your probably better off benefits as you won't have much of a life earning an 'honest' wage.

I very much doubt you recieved no help whatsoever when you entered this country, you either recieved some kind of benefit money or you knew people to help you out. Foreigners are provided a roof, food and a little pocket money to survive all reluctantly paid for by the tax payer.

Add your comment
Please note: to publish your comment you must be registered on this site. If you are already registered, please enter your details below.
Email:
Password:
spacer
 IN YOUR AREA
 
Herald Appointments - Every Friday
Travel Shop
Airport Parking
Travel Insurance
Copyright © 2008 Newsquest (Herald & Times) Limited. All Rights Reserved   
Sitemap :: Circulation :: Syndication :: Advertising :: About Us :: Terms of Use